Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Professional, easy going, knowledgeable.
over 2 years ago
Professional, easy going, knowledgeable.

Jay made purchasing my first home very easy. He was kind, professional and respectful, and the communication was excellent throughout. He frequently kept me in the loop without being at all ‘pushy’, and was very easy to deal with. Jay had thorough knowledge of the property, and if I had any questions he was unsure of, he would find out the answer and get back to me efficiently. I would definitely recommend this agent to others!

Seller review
We highly recommend Jay.
over 2 years ago
We highly recommend Jay.

Jay’s knowledge of the market is the reason we once again asked him to sell our property, his understanding of our needs and professionalism made this experience easy. From day one he kept us informed about everything. We highly recommend Jay and we look forward to working with him in the future.

Buyer review
Exceptional Service
over 2 years ago
Exceptional Service

Jay was extremely accommodating when scheduling viewings and making himself available on short notice. We found the perfect property and Jay gave us a chance to negotiate a price exclusively with the owners.

Seller review
Sale of house
over 2 years ago
Sale of house

Jay was outstanding to work with upon the sale of our property. His professionalism and prompt communication made the experience quick and easy. He had the best interests of the buyers, sellers and tenant in mind as he worked through the process to achieve an excellent result.

Buyer review
A pleasure
over 2 years ago
A pleasure

Jay was a pleasure to deal with. From start to finish he was contactable, approachable, knowledgeable and professional. Very impressed by his response time. Many other real estates have you waiting for details or answers, however Jay was always on the ball ready to reply. I highly recommend you contact Jay if ever needing an estate agent. Thank you for helping me start my new live in Bathurst xx

Seller review
Sold in 3 weeks
over 2 years ago
Sold in 3 weeks

Jay was instrumental in getting our small house sold for above expected price and within 3 weeks. His professionalism is second to none and as novices, he guided us through the process via regular check ins as well as always answering the phone when we needed further advice. Jay also sent us weekly updates with all of the necessary information to show the data of views and inquiries. We cannot recommend Jay at Cleary Fairbrother highly enough. If you are looking for an agent who is working for the seller and always aims for the best price in the most time efficient manner, these are the men to do it. Thanks Jay.

Buyer review
Exceptional
over 2 years ago
Exceptional

Jay’s experience in all aspects of the process was evident from the outset ensuring we were equipped with all of the information required to assist us in not only the decision to purchase the property, but to ensure a smooth transaction after the offer was made. Jay’s communication was succinct and he displayed professionalism at all times. His friendly, no nonsense demeanour made him a pleasure to deal with and can highly recommend him to all.

Seller review
Always a job well done
over 2 years ago
Always a job well done

Market knowledge, communication and professionalism are all exemplary.

Seller review
Outstanding
almost 3 years ago
Outstanding

Another great result From Jay extremely happy with the process and result achieving top dollar for our property Highly recommend Jay and Sandy

Seller review
Always a pleasant experience
almost 3 years ago
Always a pleasant experience

Selling our home could have been a scary and daunting task. With Jay and Sandy by our side it was quite the opposite. They were here to navigate us through the process making it stress free and easy. Open communication and answering all questions big or small they supported us all the way.

Seller review
Service that exceeded our expectations
almost 3 years ago
Service that exceeded our expectations

Jay's experience and professionalism certainly made selling our home easier. He was approachable and never stopped working to get us the best price possible. When challenges arose Jay went above and beyond what is expected of an agent, to find us a solution and sell our property. I highly recommend Jay and his team to anyone looking to sell or buy.

Seller review
Goes above & Beyond
almost 3 years ago
Goes above & Beyond

Jay Cleary is hands down the hardest working agent. He has gone above & Beyond to get the sale of our home over the line. I would highly recommend him to sell your home. An absolute proffessional and a great person to help you through the process of selling.Thankyou

157 - 168 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent