Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Pleasant and positive
about 6 years ago
Pleasant and positive

Jay worked hard to ensure that we got the perfect home for us. Great quality service.

Buyer review
Great Experience
about 6 years ago
Great Experience

Jay made the experience of buying my first house seamless. He was very supportive and answered all of my questions. A wonderful agency!

Buyer review
Easy and stress free
about 6 years ago
Easy and stress free

My experience with jay was an extremely positive and easy one, there was never any issue he would always find time to fit me in for inspections even with late notice. Jay was helpful and knowledgeable and about the region and the houses in it. He was able to bring houses to my attention that were what I was looking for instead of showing me what ever, Jay was able to get me into the house that best suited what I wanted everything was easy and any questions I had were answered promptly and I was well informed through the entire process, Jay is a genuine good bloke and I was happy to buy my house through him and would do so again, by far the best I had dealt with while looking for a house.

Seller review
Honest Sale
about 6 years ago
Honest Sale

Jay was very honest and realistic from the beginning of the whole process, keeping us informed every step of the way. Would highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother to others.

Buyer review
Fantastic!
about 6 years ago
Fantastic!

Great communication, clear, honest, easy to talk to and very helpful

Seller review
Jay is the Man
about 6 years ago
Jay is the Man

we found Jay to be up front, direct and knows his market. He gave us his honest opinion straight up and kept in constant contact with feedback after showing clients through property. Had the house sold within the first week. We were thrilled. So easy to deal with in a really tough market. 5 stars plus!!!

Buyer review
Impeccable manners and outstanding customer service
about 6 years ago
Impeccable manners and outstanding customer service

We purchased our home through Jay and were impressed by his outstanding customer service skills. We found him to be a meticulous and dedicated real estate agent with high integrity, not afraid to tell us when he didn't know the answer to some of our questions but quickly sourcing them for us. This made us confident we had genuine informations during the whole process and made for a very smooth experience. We are delighted to recommended Jay's services to any prospective buyers expecting professional experience and honesty.

Buyer review
Excellent agent
over 6 years ago
Excellent agent

Great communication, kept well informed of the process.

Seller review
Great service, above and beyond!
over 6 years ago
Great service, above and beyond!

Thanks Jay for your professional approach. I appreciated you staying in touch and keeping me informed. Your service was outstanding. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this service to everyone I know. I would use this service again 100%.

Buyer review
We would not have our beautiful 2.5 acres if it wasn't for Jay Cleary
over 6 years ago
We would not have our beautiful 2.5 acres if it wasn't for Jay Cleary

We would not have our beautiful 2.5 acres if it wasn't for Jay Cleary. We spoke to Jay and pinpointed areas around Bathurst we would like to make our own. He was able to quickly identify our perfect 2.5 acre block of land at The Lagoon. The negotiations were quick and painless and within a week, we had had our offer accepted. Jay's determination to find something for us created the situation for something to appear. His professionalism and advice were testament to his years of experience. For someone who had never bought property, Jay made the process wonderfully simple. His communication with us was quick and he always had the right answers. Thanks Jay. We couldn't be happier with our stunning patch of paradise.

Seller review
Fantastic!!Highly recommend
over 6 years ago
Fantastic!!Highly recommend

If you are looking to sell a house Jay is the person to see. He presented us with the information we needed to set our sale price and we were not disappointed. A fast sale and Jay kept us informed from the start of the sale right through to exchange of contract. We’ve sold a house before and never had anywhere near this level of service. Thanks so much Jay!

433 - 444 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent