Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 569 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent, would highly recommend
over 6 years ago
Excellent, would highly recommend

We purchased our home with Jay around 13 years ago. When it came time to sell, we were keen to go with Jay again, and we're so glad that we did. He made everything so simple, right throughout the selling process. No question was ever silly (and I had many!) and he was always available. He's so down to earth and easy to work with, and that makes such a difference. I would definitely recommend Jay (and Sandy - they were both great!) if you're interested in buying or selling. You won't be sorry!

Seller review
The quality of service was fantastic
over 6 years ago
The quality of service was fantastic

Jay gave us quality service, nothing was too much trouble. His knowledge of the local market was second to none and his professional approach both our sale and purchase could not be faulted. We would highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother Property Bathurst.

Seller review
JAIS A NO FUSS MAN THAT GETS THE JOB DONE WITH A SMILE
over 6 years ago
JAIS A NO FUSS MAN THAT GETS THE JOB DONE WITH A SMILE

thankyou Jay for selling our house Jay has been helping us bye and sell houses for a few years now we has always found him to be well informed on the local market and very professional his caring and happy manner make the process very comfortable, not just your every day real estate man

Buyer review
I have recently brought a property with Jay as my agent. I would highly recommend him.
over 6 years ago
I have recently brought a property with Jay as my agent. I would highly recommend him.

I have been in the market for a house and went to a couple of open houses. The real estate agents said they would contact me but never did. I decided to go to another open house and that is when I met Jay. I told him my situation and he listened to everything I had to say. I looked through the house and eventually put an offer on it. If I had any questions Jay answered them promptly and he was with me every step of the way. Jay made the purchase of the property easy. The communication with him was outstanding. I would highly recommend him.

Seller review
My Life with Jay and Sandy
over 6 years ago
My Life with Jay and Sandy

Both guys are excellent!! I have had things to do with Sandy previously, very friendly and knows his stuff. This time around I dealt mainly with Jay. He knows the industry well and all the things handy for both purchaser and seller to know throughout entire process. Very impressed with the tips given, all advice was spoton! I really appreciated the regular updates and a no bulls#$t way of dealing with ideas and issues. No mucking about and got the job done for me, I am sure the purchaser would have similar sentiments. Thank you gentlemen.

Buyer review
Professional and a good laugh
over 6 years ago
Professional and a good laugh

Jay is knowable within the market. Jay never pressured us on the sale and always had the answers to our questions no matter what time. It was a pleasure to take this next step with him.

Seller review
Outstanding service. Absolutely brilliant
over 6 years ago
Outstanding service. Absolutely brilliant

Jay is one of the most knowledgeable and professional agents I have ever dealt with. I have recommended every family member, friend and colleague to Jay over the past 15 years. We have received outstanding service and always with a smile and a can do that attitude.

Buyer review
An absolute joy to work with!
over 6 years ago
An absolute joy to work with!

Right from the get go, Jay was a pleasure to work with. He is professional, knowledgeable, personable and went above and beyond to ensure the process was smooth as possible. As a first home buyer, I was nervous (as expected) and unsure as to the process. Jay's exceptional local knowledge of the Bathurst region as well as the purchasing process allowed me to obtain the reassurance I needed. Jay always made himself available, communicated at every step along the way and really made the entire process seamless. Jay exudes integrity and honesty to which I am grateful for having the pleasure of working with him. If anyone is thinking about selling or buying, I would recommend you choose Jay. For all first home buyers like myself - Jay is the person you want to talk to. Thank you for making my first purchase a great experience!

Seller review
Honest and Reliable
almost 7 years ago
Honest and Reliable

Jay from listing to sale kept us updated on everything that was happening , very professional

Seller review
Sold our family home
almost 7 years ago
Sold our family home

Geoff and I are so grateful to have used the services of Jay and Sandy from Cleary Fairbrother Property. We were fortunate enough to have had Jay sell our first home previously, so it was an easy decision when we found out about the new development in there business venture. Both Jay and Sandy worked so we professionally and effortlessly to sell our house in a high pressure situation. 
Always contactable and approachable the agents make selling and buying property easy and effortless.

Buyer review
Very Professional
almost 7 years ago
Very Professional

Thanks Jay, everything went smoothly and very happy with the result

457 - 468 of 569
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent