Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 569 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great Agent
almost 9 years ago
Great Agent

I would recommend Jay Cleary to anyone. He straight forward and upfront and very positive person. He sold our house within a month very happy with the result.

Seller review
A real pleasure to work with
about 9 years ago
A real pleasure to work with

We bought and sold a property with Jay. On both occasioons we found him to be courteous, helpful, knowlegable and straight up with his thoughs and advice. I would recommend him to anyone without hesitation. Dudley Patterson

Seller review
Fantastic experience!!
about 9 years ago
Fantastic experience!!

I could not recommend Jay (and the whole team) any more highly. Jay was thorough, gave great advice and kept us well informed the whole way through. He made the whole sale process easy (and quick!) There is a reason he is as recommended as he is.

Buyer review
Great Agent
about 9 years ago
Great Agent

Jay was a great to deal with- quick to respond to all communication, helpful, and acted with integrity. Would happily work with him again.

Seller review
Well done Jay
about 9 years ago
Well done Jay

Jay got the job done! Thanks Bathurst Real Estate and to Jay. His knowledge of the market got the result we wanted quickly.

Seller review
Good result in a flat market
over 9 years ago
Good result in a flat market

Jay worked tirelessly to achieve a good result for us in a flat market. He communicated well and kept us informed of progress. As remote sellers his regular updates were extremely helpful to us. Jay highlighted the positives of our house and achieved a sales result that reflected the state of the market.

Buyer review
My first home
over 9 years ago
My first home

Jay cottoned pretty quickly as to what my needs were in a house having shown me a few 3 bedders and so when he insisted I went to an open house for a 2 bedder an hour or so later I did so and of course it was the right house for me & I bought it. He has taken on board my advice that for a newbie purchaser that we need more help around the rules - my rental property had to be left pristine and yet vendors can leave it filthy and to have to clean two houses top to bottom was a shock to the system!

Seller review
The best Agent I have had in 30 Years
over 9 years ago
The best Agent I have had in 30 Years

I have bought and sold quite a number of residential and commercial properties over 30 years and Jay is the only one I ever gave a Christmas gift for , let alone, a bottle of single malt. RESILIENCE, PERSEVERANCE AND TENACITY, the three qualities that Jay has any vendor would want. Jay was recommended by a friend, who told me not to talk to anyone else but Jay. Being the sceptic that I am, I gave two other agents the opportunity. My friend was right.

Buyer review
Purchase of my first investment property
over 9 years ago
Purchase of my first investment property

Jay has great communication and helped me significantly on my search for the right investment property. Nothing was ever too much hassle, very friendly, helpful and knowledgeable on the Bathurst region. I will seek Jay's assistance in the future for assistance with purchases and sales within the Bathurst area.

Buyer review
Highly recommended
over 9 years ago
Highly recommended

We would absolutely recommend Jay. He was the only person we sat down with and went through everything we wanted with our new house. He only needed to take us to one house because he listened to exactly what we wanted and completely delivered. The process (although complicated from our end) was smooth and easy to get through as Jay helped us navigate and was always available to answer our questions. Take the stress out of buying or selling and call Jay!

Buyer review
Made the process a Breeze
over 9 years ago
Made the process a Breeze

Jay has once again made the Real estate process smooth and easy. Purchase was made to be a hassle free process with the land also being expertly recommended to us. Would highly recommend.

493 - 504 of 569
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent