Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 589 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
We would not have our beautiful 2.5 acres if it wasn't for Jay Cleary
over 6 years ago
We would not have our beautiful 2.5 acres if it wasn't for Jay Cleary

We would not have our beautiful 2.5 acres if it wasn't for Jay Cleary. We spoke to Jay and pinpointed areas around Bathurst we would like to make our own. He was able to quickly identify our perfect 2.5 acre block of land at The Lagoon. The negotiations were quick and painless and within a week, we had had our offer accepted. Jay's determination to find something for us created the situation for something to appear. His professionalism and advice were testament to his years of experience. For someone who had never bought property, Jay made the process wonderfully simple. His communication with us was quick and he always had the right answers. Thanks Jay. We couldn't be happier with our stunning patch of paradise.

Seller review
Fantastic!!Highly recommend
over 6 years ago
Fantastic!!Highly recommend

If you are looking to sell a house Jay is the person to see. He presented us with the information we needed to set our sale price and we were not disappointed. A fast sale and Jay kept us informed from the start of the sale right through to exchange of contract. We’ve sold a house before and never had anywhere near this level of service. Thanks so much Jay!

Buyer review
Purchase of residential property
over 6 years ago
Purchase of residential property

Jay was great to deal with- no pressuring like some agents. Genuine and friendly. Achieved a good result.

Buyer review
The quality of service was fantastic.
almost 7 years ago
The quality of service was fantastic.

All concerns were addressed promptly and resolved as soon as possible. Jay has been a great help with local information and local tradespersons. I would recommend Jay without hesitation for quality of service and friendly attitude to all aspect of buying and selling Real Estate.

Seller review
Fantastic service!
almost 7 years ago
Fantastic service!

From our first meeting with Jay and Sandy, we were confident we were making the right decision in asking Cleary Fairbrother Property to sell our home. This was proven when we accepted an offer after only 1 week on the market! Both Jay and Sandy are such personable and professional agents and their knowledge of and experience in the local market is second to none. We will happily recommend them to anyone!

Buyer review
Purchasing first home
almost 7 years ago
Purchasing first home

Excellent knowledge of the market. Very good and quick communication. Would recommend to anyone buying or selling. All round top agent!

Buyer review
Outstanding!
almost 7 years ago
Outstanding!

We have known Jay for 15 years and already had the confidence in his knowledge and professionalism however Jay exceeded our expectations. After a short chat with Jay, he had a very clear understanding of the sort of home that would suit us. Jay inevitability found us our perfect home, our forever home. We could not have asked more from this man. He literally covered every single basis and some. Jay was with us every single step of the process and was more then happy to answer some silly questions along the way. We have 100% faith in Jay and would very highly recommend him to anyone looking for a real estate agent.

Seller review
very satisfied
almost 7 years ago
very satisfied

Attention to detail great communication leaves you feeling confident he is looking after you knows his job and the market definitely recommend him to sell your property

Seller review
Excellent, would highly recommend
almost 7 years ago
Excellent, would highly recommend

We purchased our home with Jay around 13 years ago. When it came time to sell, we were keen to go with Jay again, and we're so glad that we did. He made everything so simple, right throughout the selling process. No question was ever silly (and I had many!) and he was always available. He's so down to earth and easy to work with, and that makes such a difference. I would definitely recommend Jay (and Sandy - they were both great!) if you're interested in buying or selling. You won't be sorry!

Seller review
The quality of service was fantastic
almost 7 years ago
The quality of service was fantastic

Jay gave us quality service, nothing was too much trouble. His knowledge of the local market was second to none and his professional approach both our sale and purchase could not be faulted. We would highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother Property Bathurst.

Seller review
JAIS A NO FUSS MAN THAT GETS THE JOB DONE WITH A SMILE
almost 7 years ago
JAIS A NO FUSS MAN THAT GETS THE JOB DONE WITH A SMILE

thankyou Jay for selling our house Jay has been helping us bye and sell houses for a few years now we has always found him to be well informed on the local market and very professional his caring and happy manner make the process very comfortable, not just your every day real estate man

Buyer review
I have recently brought a property with Jay as my agent. I would highly recommend him.
almost 7 years ago
I have recently brought a property with Jay as my agent. I would highly recommend him.

I have been in the market for a house and went to a couple of open houses. The real estate agents said they would contact me but never did. I decided to go to another open house and that is when I met Jay. I told him my situation and he listened to everything I had to say. I looked through the house and eventually put an offer on it. If I had any questions Jay answered them promptly and he was with me every step of the way. Jay made the purchase of the property easy. The communication with him was outstanding. I would highly recommend him.

469 - 480 of 589
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent