Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Consistent, dedicated and communicative
about 1 year ago
Consistent, dedicated and communicative

I had a positive experience selling with Jay who managed the sales process with consistency and clear communication at every stage. Jay was open to my ideas and always listened thoughtfully but gave solid professional advice too without pressuring me. He was honest and reliable and did not cut corners. Additionally, he organised regular garden maintenance and kept an eye on the vacant property. I’m very happy with the result and would highly recommend Jay for his calm, no-nonsense approach.

Seller review
Cleary and Fairbrother get the job done!
about 1 year ago
Cleary and Fairbrother get the job done!

Jay showed exceptional knowledge when teaming up with Sandy for the sale of our home. He was diligent at every appointment throughout the sale, making us feel supported and confident throughout the entire process. We would highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother Property for the sale of your home.

Buyer review
Prompt, Professional and a pleasure to deal with!
about 1 year ago
Prompt, Professional and a pleasure to deal with!

Our experience purchasing a property through Jay Cleary was a breeze. Jay showed excellent communication and negotiation skills, was always available to answer our calls and questions when needed. Jay was very easy to deal with every step of the way and extremely helpful throughout the process. Jay displayed extensive knowledge of real estate in the area and gave sound advice. It was a pleasure buying our second property with Jay and would be more than happy to use him as our agent in the future.

Buyer review
What a breeze!
about 1 year ago
What a breeze!

Jay was a pleasure to work with and made the process of buying our first home a breeze, very approachable and easy to communicate with. We’d heard nothing but good things from friends & our conveyancer that had previously dealings with jay. We look forward to working with him in the future!

Buyer review
Exceptional Service and Market Expertise
about 1 year ago
Exceptional Service and Market Expertise

I recently had the pleasure of purchasing a block of land with the help of Jay Cleary, and I couldn’t be more satisfied with the experience. Jay’s market knowledge was outstanding—he provided valuable insights that helped me make an informed decision with confidence. His communication was clear, prompt, and professional throughout the entire process, ensuring I was always kept up to date. Jay’s approachable and honest nature made the transaction smooth and stress-free. I highly recommend Jay Cleary to anyone looking for a reliable and knowledgeable real estate agent.

Seller review
If you want down to earth, relatable realestate agents, these are your guys 🫵
about 1 year ago
If you want down to earth, relatable realestate agents, these are your guys 🫵

Jay and Sandy were very thorough and informative throughout the whole process. They provided constant communication and always kept us informed of any updates regardless of whether it was good or bad news. Due to their collective approach it didn’t feel like there was ever a lull while our house was on the market as they both put a lot of effort into open houses and organising private inspections. Without them we may not have the price we wanted.

Seller review
Great Communication
about 1 year ago
Great Communication

Jay was excellent throughout the whole process and kept me informed every step of the way to make it a seamless sale. Very happy with the result.

Buyer review
Seamless and hassle free
over 1 year ago
Seamless and hassle free

Working with Jay was a breeze. He made this whole process so seamless from start to finish. It was a pleasure working with him. Thank you so much for all your hard work Jay!

Seller review
Experienced, professional, friendly, knowledgeable & genuine!!
over 1 year ago
Experienced, professional, friendly, knowledgeable & genuine!!

Have known and dealt with Jay for nearly 20 years- so trustworthy, genuine and really does act in your best interests. Wouldn’t think of going any where else to either buy or sell a property! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ service, thanks Jay and Sandy.

Seller review
Great guy
over 1 year ago
Great guy

Have sold and purchased a few houses through Jay and he is great to deal with and always gets the job done with great communication all the way through

Seller review
Dedicated, experienced and genuine.
over 1 year ago
Dedicated, experienced and genuine.

We would happily work with Jay again and recommend the agency to others. Jay and his team made the whole process of selling our house smooth from start to finish. They very thorough, and he kept us informed during every stage of the process. Jay was easy to contact, thoughtful and honest about any issues, and very genuine in his approach.

Seller review
Professional and caring
over 1 year ago
Professional and caring

Sandy and Jay were amazing! Very professional and also caring, nothing was a problem or too much effort. Would not hesitate to recommend 100%

73 - 84 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent