Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 589 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Upfront and Honest, Genuine and Reliable
8 months ago
Upfront and Honest, Genuine and Reliable

Jay is always upfront and honest. Genuine and reliable. On the ball and helpful with everything real estate. Including conveyancing when required. You always know where you stand with Jay. I can't recommend Clearly Fairbrother Real Estate highly enough. These guys really know their stuff and this time due to their networking they sold our house prior to entering the market. A dream sale. Thank you ance again Cleary Fairbrother Real Estate.

Seller review
Would 100 percent recommend.
8 months ago
Would 100 percent recommend.

Jay from Cleary Fairbrother was totally professional, courteous and kind. He kept a realistic approach throughout the whole process. His communication was brilliant and knowledge was outstanding, down to the minute details, especially in key regards to the obligations to presenting the home. I would 100 percent recommend Jay for buying or selling your home. If you’re in Bathurst, give him a call.

Seller review
Easy smooth transaction
8 months ago
Easy smooth transaction

We recently worked with Jay and Sandy at Cleary Fairbrother Real Estate and couldn’t be happier with the experience to sell our elderly mothers home . From start to finish, they were professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly responsive. They kept us informed every step of the way and made what can be a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. Their attention to detail and strong communication skills truly set them apart. We would highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell. We were also impressed that the sale took place over the Christmas break .

Seller review
A true professional!
8 months ago
A true professional!

This is the second house we have purchased through Jay. Both times he has been open and honest with us. He is incredibly professional, but also kind and compassionate. He took the time to get to know us, and our family and was able to get us what we wanted. He communicates clearly and timely, and I never felt like I was asking a dumb question. I would, and have, recommend him to anyone. Thanks Jay

Buyer review
Reliable, responsive, and great to work with
8 months ago
Reliable, responsive, and great to work with

We had a great experience working with Jay throughout the purchase of our home. From the very beginning, he was responsive, easy to deal with, and kept us updated regularly at every stage of the process. As first-home buyers, we had plenty of questions, and Jay was always happy to help—no question ever felt too small or silly. He explained things clearly, followed up when he said he would, and made the whole experience feel much smoother and less stressful. We really appreciated his professionalism, communication, and support, and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to others.

Seller review
Open and Honest communication
10 months ago
Open and Honest communication

Jay provided feedback to me regarding open home arrangements during the sales process. I appreciated the weekly updates and his thoughts on how the property was viewed. Jay is kind and provides honest and realistic feedback. The property sold and i was delighted with the results, thx Jay

Seller review
Absolute dedication
10 months ago
Absolute dedication

After consulting with a number of various agents, I chose Jay as my agent. It was immediately evident he puts the greatest of care into looking after his clients, where the others treated it as “just another job”. He walked me through the process, helped me get in touch with additional services such as a great solicitor, and provided helpful advice and guidance along the way. His consistent communication and reporting back of advertising reach and inspection reactions was outstanding and a fantastic asset. Even with some difficulties due to events out of our hands, Jay was always a phone call away and eager to share progress, and go above and beyond to keep things moving. His dedication and commitment to looking after me has been second to none and I could not be happier with my choice to have him as my agent. Thank you Jay & team!

Seller review
Sale of my property.
10 months ago
Sale of my property.

2 days on the market and offers were made. Excellent communication from Jay through the whole process. The speed at which everything happened most impressive. Jay kept me informed all the way. Great result. Thank You Cleary Fairbrother R/E Bathurst.

Seller review
When experience matters - Jay Cleary has it in spades.
10 months ago
When experience matters - Jay Cleary has it in spades.

We recently sold our home with Jay Cleary and couldn’t be happier with the experience. Jay was incredibly easy to deal with, genuinely cared about us and the outcome, and always made us feel like he was in our corner. We had a few curve balls along the way, which Jay handled calmly and confidently - a true reflection of his experience. We felt supported, informed, and looked after from start to finish. Highly recommend.

Buyer review
Honest and efficient
10 months ago
Honest and efficient

Jay was honest and efficient went out of this way out of hours to support in the process was very timely creating less stress. I was highly impressed with Jane‘s process review when we did not get one House rather than just moving on was able to contain us whether not honest point kept us engaged in the Realastate Lots of information about current market current price current availability I would highly recommend Jane go to

49 - 60 of 589
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent