Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 59 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, dedicated, supportive, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Jay was an excellent communicator who progressive updates so we always knew where we stood.
5 days ago
Jay was an excellent communicator who progressive updates so we always knew where we stood.

Jay was always helpful with identifying market movement and was honest in his representation of property interest. It was his honesty that we found confidence in as part of his marketing style. Jay was very knowledgeable of the local market. We felt confident that he had our best interests at heart particularly as he negotiated the sale. Jay was always professional in his dealings with us and the vendor.

Seller review
Enthusiastic and good communicator
2 months ago
Enthusiastic and good communicator

Jay communicated very well and kept me up to date with all potential buyers and strategies. He also went out of his way to do some minor maintenance tasks for the house, that you would not normally expect from a real estate agent. Even though I didn't get the price I was hoping for, it wasn't from lack of enthusiasm and professionalism from Jay and the team.

Seller review
Jay was a pleasure to work with. Professional, responsive & genuinely committed to the best result.
2 months ago
Jay was a pleasure to work with. Professional, responsive & genuinely committed to the best result.

Working with Jay to sell our property was an excellent experience from start to finish. From the very beginning he was professional, proactive and clearly committed to achieving the best possible outcome. Jay’s communication throughout the process was outstanding. He kept us informed at every stage of the campaign, sharing updates after inspections and providing clear feedback from potential buyers. We always knew what was happening and felt confident in the approach he was taking. He was also very responsive whenever we had questions, which made the whole experience feel smooth and well managed. What really stood out was how hard Jay worked. It was clear he was putting in the time and effort to ensure the property received strong interest and that every opportunity with buyers was followed up carefully. He approached the sale with real dedication and attention to detail and it felt like he genuinely cared about achieving the best result. Jay also brought strong market knowledge and a calm, confident approach that made a big difference during what can often be a stressful process. He guided each decision point with clear advice and professionalism. Thanks to Jay’s commitment and hard work we achieved the best possible outcome. I am very grateful for the effort he put into every part of the sale and would absolutely recommend him to anyone looking for an agent who is professional, communicative and truly invested in delivering a great result.

Seller review
Very Professional
4 months ago
Very Professional

We found Jay very professional in selling our house. Communication was always present between us. Couldn’t have asked for a better out come highly recommend PRD.

Seller review
Thanks to Jay Grogan the sale of our property was completed swiftly and amicably.
5 months ago
Thanks to Jay Grogan the sale of our property was completed swiftly and amicably.

I can thoroughly recommend Jay Grogan as a salesman for PRD Salamander. He is thoroughly professional. He has a sound, realistic knowledge of the property market and seller and buyer can both be confident that the selling price of a property is its realistic value. Jay Grogan keeps the seller informed following property inspections. He is very approachable and returns phone calls immediately.

Seller review
A relaxed approach that is effective
5 months ago
A relaxed approach that is effective

Jay is relaxed, calm, friendly and positive. He always keeps you updated with phone calls, text messages or emails. This approach makes selling a house less stressful and is most appreciated. Jay works hard (even on Sundays) accommodating the needs of the client to get the desired outcome. In a tough market, Jay was able to achieve a good outcome.

Buyer review
Absolutely brilliant and excellent real estate agent.
6 months ago
Absolutely brilliant and excellent real estate agent.

Jay is an excellent realtor from the beginning of my inquiries to the purchase of the property. He went over and beyond to make the purchase a smooth transaction. He answered all my questions no matter what time of day it was. I would highly recommend him for any sale or purchase of a property. Thank you so much Jay.

Seller review
selling our house with Jay was very easy
6 months ago
selling our house with Jay was very easy

having chosen Jay from a selection of other realtors was the correct decision over the past few weeks from start to sold Jay has been constantly updating and communicating every step of the way it has been pain free and effortless experience he is a friendly and professional agent.

Seller review
Great Result
8 months ago
Great Result

Jay put in the time and effort to get a great result, on what was not an easy property to sell. Thank you Jay

Seller review
Professional
8 months ago
Professional

Jay’s first visit was clear and informative, with the best way to market our property. We felt very confident in Jay to be able to sell Our HOME. The result clearly showed that we made the right decision. Sold within 2 weeks

Seller review
Jay delivers on his words 110%
9 months ago
Jay delivers on his words 110%

From start to finish Jay listens to what you want and delivers on his words even over delivering. Jay not only sold our home he also helped us find our new home. His knowledge and experience in the local community was extremely helpful. His professionalism and patience throughout the process Priceless especially when the heat is on. PRD is a well respected and established real estate company and they are very lucky to have such a great team member and they can be very proud of the work that Jay delivers. My family and I highly recommend Jay when it comes to anything regarding real estate especially here at Port Stephens the greatest place on earth. What you see is what you get with Jay which is rare to find and he has a team of like minded people who work with him in the community that deliver above and beyond 110%. Not that we are planning on moving but if we did we will be calling Jay. Keep up the great work Jay we have really enjoyed and appreciated your exceptional service you deliver. Thank you Kindest regards, Andy and the girls ❤️👍

1 - 12 of 59
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent