Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 59 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, dedicated, supportive, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent experience in selling my dads place.
10 months ago
Excellent experience in selling my dads place.

I recently sold my dad’s Unit in over 55's Village. I had the pleasure of working with Jay throughout the process. He did a fantastic job — the sale went through quickly and smoothly. Jay was thorough, professional, and always approachable. He kept me well-informed at every stage and was genuinely helpful and friendly. His attention to detail and calm, confident manner made what could have been a stressful experience feel easy. I’m very grateful for his support and would highly recommend him to anyone looking to sell.

Buyer review
"Outstanding Support and Transparency from Start to Finish"
10 months ago
"Outstanding Support and Transparency from Start to Finish"

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I recently purchased a home in Anna Bay Village through Jay Grogan from PRD Salamander Bay, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. Jay was absolutely amazing to deal with — professional, straightforward, and transparent every step of the way. He went above and beyond to support me throughout the process, even making himself available to coordinate access for tradespeople so I could obtain quotes and make informed decisions. Nothing was ever too much trouble. If you're looking for an honest, reliable, and genuinely helpful real estate agent, I highly recommend Jay. A pleasure to work with from start to finish!

Seller review
Excellent and very prompt
10 months ago
Excellent and very prompt

Jay was absolutely wonderful , very polite and very professional. If i had any questions he was there to help out straight away. Highly recommend for anybody for Jay to sell your property and he excelled in his professional . very happy with his quick turnaround that he provided .

Seller review
Excellent professional always up todays with progress of sale
about 1 year ago
Excellent professional always up todays with progress of sale

I found jay a member of your team very helpful in the progression and sale of my property very easy to contact and kept me with updates weekly. I would not hesitate to sell another property with PRD.

Seller review
Sale of 2 bedroom unit in Nelson Bay
about 1 year ago
Sale of 2 bedroom unit in Nelson Bay

Jay worked quite hard for the sale of the property and he did communicate regularly. I did not fully agree with the marketing strategy but did agree to go with his advice as I felt he would have the experience. It did sell in a reasonable amount of time so am quite happy with the outcome. I fully understand a property is only worth what someone will pay for it.

Seller review
Professional and positive experience
over 1 year ago
Professional and positive experience

Jay was very professional and efficient in organising every aspect of the sale. He listened to my requests on marketing/advertising of the property and reduced costs. He was proactive in getting clients through before launch. Talked about pricing of house and my expectations on market sales. Only had one open house. Always in contact with me regarding clients coming through and once an offer was made dealing with buyer and solicitors. Great communication. Always positive. Very happy with Jay and PRD.

Seller review
I cannot fault Jay for the experience he provided and the compassion he shown towards my family.
over 1 year ago
I cannot fault Jay for the experience he provided and the compassion he shown towards my family.

I cannot fault Jay, we were selling the property as it was a deceased estate and was a very hard time for my family to process. Jay was very compassionate to our needs. We went to auction which was a new experience for us however Jay explained the process easily. Although we did not sell through auction the communication between the parties in regards to the sale was very transparent. I highly recommend Jay

Seller review
Great communication skills
over 1 year ago
Great communication skills

Jay was very easy and friendly to work with, taking us through the process step by step. He is a great communicator, always keeping us up to date with inspections and how they went, then offering helpful suggestions on the next step.

Buyer review
Articulate, Comprehensive, Friendly and Reliable Agent
over 1 year ago
Articulate, Comprehensive, Friendly and Reliable Agent

We have been working with Jay , looking for a house to purchase in the Port Stephens area. During that time, he regularly was in contact with us, especially to give us a chance to view a potential properties prior to market release. The properties were close to meeting our needs, but there was something that didn’t quite gel with us about them. Jay was not dissuaded and the last property he offered us, a pre-market inspection, was the deal clincher. He worked with us to help understanding what the seller wanted and what our purchase limits were. Since engaging Jay, he has been keeping us informed, working with both parties and our legal teams to ensure the purchase progressed smoothly, without any undue pressure being applied. Great communication, a good understanding of our property limits/requirements and the patience to deal with a couple of newbies to the property market by helping to explain the various processes along the way. The entire process of working with Jay to find and eventually purchase a property has been, dare I say, an enjoyable one.

Seller review
Knows the Market
over 1 year ago
Knows the Market

Jay was such a pleasure to deal with, he had a comprehensive understanding of the market in Salamander Bay and provided us with regular updates on how the local area was doing. He was not pushy in any way, in fact he was the upmost professional salesman I have come across. I would highly recommend Jay Grogan and PRD Salamander Bay to manage the sale of any property.

Seller review
Ultimate professional
over 1 year ago
Ultimate professional

Polite efficient and great communicator. Jay worked tirelessly for the best result. We would highly recommend him ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

13 - 24 of 59
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent