Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 540 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Professional, extensive knowledge of the market and understanding
7 months ago
Professional, extensive knowledge of the market and understanding

Having bought two homes and sold one with Jay and Michelle, I never hesitated in choosing an agent to sell my last home which was sold in 13 days! His extensive knowledge even helped with my last move interstate. Nothing was too much trouble despite some complex issues/needs. When I bought my last home, in Newport, both Jay and Michelle were always available to reply to any concerns and could recommend people to assist me, as a person with complex needs. Even after living there for 4 years they were always there to assist and give recommendations. You cannot be in better hands. Even though my last move was interstate Jays vast knowledge greatly assisted me in buying my current home in Bowral. Team Peters, you are amazing and I’m so very happy to write this review. Thank you.

Buyer review
Next level RE professionals
7 months ago
Next level RE professionals

Jay and Michelle have a market leading reputation on the Peninsular. They connect with the buyer but are clear that they represent and work hard for the seller. Nothing is too difficult and they go out of their way to guide you through the buying process.

Seller review
Great experience
8 months ago
Great experience

Jay, Michelle and their team did a great job. Clear communication, passionate and transparent. I would highly recommend

Buyer review
Outstanding Service and Support from Start to Finish
8 months ago
Outstanding Service and Support from Start to Finish

I had a fantastic experience working with Jay!! From start to finish, he was incredibly responsive and helpful - always quick to reply to any questions or concerns we had. He was always kind, accommodating, and went out of his way to ensure everything went smoothly. Highly recommend working with Jay - truly a pleasure!

Buyer review
Excellent Service and Communication
8 months ago
Excellent Service and Communication

I recently purchased my new apartment and had the pleasure of dealing with Jay as the selling agent, alongside my buyer’s agent. Jay was fantastic to work with—always easy to deal with, professional, and approachable. His communication was prompt and clear, and I really appreciated the transparency he showed throughout the process. Even though I was represented by my own agent, Jay made sure everything ran smoothly and was straightforward in all our interactions. I’m super happy with the service he provided and would not hesitate to recommend him to anyone buying or selling.

Buyer review
Excellent from Start to Finish
8 months ago
Excellent from Start to Finish

Right from the start when I made an inquiry regarding properties for sale in Newport, the professionalism of both Jay & Michelle stood out from the rest. They were the only team that rang me to confirm viewing times and also the only team to message me on the morning of viewings to remind me of time’s and addresses. They quickly had a good understanding of what I was looking for and as they have outstanding knowledge of the area (they also live here) and market conditions, they were able to match me with my ideal home. I have no hesitation in recommending Jay & Michelle, whether you are buying or selling you will be in good hands.

Seller review
Awesome experience
8 months ago
Awesome experience

We recently had the pleasure of working with Jay and Michelle Peters from Ray White to sell our home, and the experience was awesome! From our very first meeting, they brought professionalism, warmth, and genuine care, helping us through the entire process with clarity and confidence. Their knowledge of the local market was impressive, and they provided honest, practical advice that made us feel fully informed every step of the way. Communication was excellent—always responsive, proactive, and reassuring - making what could have been a stressful process smooth into something straightforward. Beyond their expertise, Jay and Michelle were simply wonderful to work with - approachable, reliable, and committed to achieving the best possible outcome for us. We couldn’t be happier with their service and would highly recommend them to anyone looking to sell their property.

Seller review
Fantastic
8 months ago
Fantastic

Jay, Michelle and their team were very professional. They worked hard selling my house right next to a building site. They gave honest feedback and advice. Their communication during the process was excellent, feedback was given on every person who viewed the property promptly. They are personable and approachable. Having viewed many properties myself and met lots of agents I definitely picked the dream team. Thank you all for your hard work.

Seller review
Professinal and friendly real estate agent.
8 months ago
Professinal and friendly real estate agent.

Jay & Michelle Peters are a great team with lots of real estat experience which i found a huge help in getting my property sold in 3 weeks. Thank you for ensuring I used a stagging company as that made all the difference in the selling.process. Their negoitation experience help me gain a great price for house Thankyou Team Peters

Seller review
Very very very happy
8 months ago
Very very very happy

From day 1 till unconditional Professional, Easy , and absolutely will be letting everyone know where to go for Real estate needs

Buyer review
Market knowledge, communication. Professionalism all of a very high standard
9 months ago
Market knowledge, communication. Professionalism all of a very high standard

If buying or selling a house we would thoroughly recommend Jay and Michelle as your agent. They don't try to overplay the market which is a real benefit especially for the seller. We searched for 6 months through various agents and found Jay and Michelle to be the most honest and friendly and realistic agents in the Newport area. They truly care for both the seller and buyer and want the best for both parties involved. A truly magnificent experience through Jay and Michelle, we Thank you both.

Seller review
The Best Agents on the Peninsula!!
9 months ago
The Best Agents on the Peninsula!!

I cannot thank Jay & Michelle enough for their professionalism, time and commitment to sell my property! From the initial sign up, to assistance in preparation for open homes, to on time updates on all things related to the sale, I cannot fault them. Being local allows both Jay and Michelle to provide great insight to potential buyers and ensured the perfect sale to the perfect buyer! Absolutely recommend you get in touch with them if you are looking at buying or selling - they are your go to!

49 - 60 of 540
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent