Matt's profile

Matt's reviews

  4.7  
Matt has 75 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
about 8 years ago
professional Agent you can trust

Matt is a very experienced and professional agent with a thorough knowledge of the local area. His communication skills are excellent and he has a great ability working with the seller and prospective buyers. Matt works with a very professional team at Cunninghams and it is the team approach which i makes the difference

about 8 years ago
Matt was great to work with.

He was always there to assist me when I needed help. Matt answered the 'million' questions I asked and even provided leads for contacts that I needed. He went the extra mile and did it all with a smile. Thanks Matt.

about 8 years ago
Couldn’t be happier with choice of agent!

We warmed to Matt right from that start when we met him as potential buyers. We are super happy that we then appointed Matt Nicastri and Michelle Galetti as a team to sell our home. Matt was a real pleasure to work with throughout the process with his down to earth and honest approach, upbeat demeanour and can do attitude. He genuinely cares about the interests of all parties involved and he builds real connections with people quickly. He has also had a great understanding of the market. He worked super hard throughout the campaign, going above and beyond on many occasion, to get us the best possible result and we’re delighted with the outcome. We would recommend Matt highly to anyone looking to sell. He and Michelle complement each other perfectly and make a really strong team

about 8 years ago
Great Agent

Matt was fantastic to deal with throughout our purchase- he was very diligent and transparent, with great communication which helped us through the process. We highly recommend him!

over 8 years ago
A Fantastic Experience....

We originally met Matt and Liliana over twelve (12) months ago when we first began our house search on the Northern Beaches. From the very first time we met, Matt and Lili went out of their way to get to know us personally and to also fully understand what we were looking for and how they may be able to assist us with our search. After countless open homes and a year-long search, we finally found the one and we are thankful that Matt and the Cunninghams team was handling the listing. Throughout the entire process from inspection through to negotiation and finally contract signature, Matt was accommodating of our requests, honest with his feedback, professional and at all times very transparent. This was very refreshing as purchasers and made the whole process less stressful. In the end it was Matt's intimate understanding of all aspects of what and why we were interested in this particular property that enabled him to negotiate a great outcome for us with his Vendors and when we got the news the property was ours, we couldn't have been happier! Matt and the entire Cunninghams team certainly go above and beyond and we would not hesitate recommending them if you are searching for a property on the Northern Beaches.

over 8 years ago
Communication - passion - results

Matt Nicastri is one of a kind. We have met nearly every agent in our area over the past few years while looking to buy a house and Matt certainly stands out from the crowd. He is kind and thoughtful, incredibly hard working and honest. He certainly breaks the stereotypical image of the real estate agent that we have experienced in the past. Matt sold our home for the price we wanted. His negotiation skills were outstanding, but he maintained a kind and compassionate demeanour throughout, which and made the whole process as smooth and painless as possible. The team Matt has around him are awesome; Liliana & Daniel, the amazing photographer and videographers, copywriter and office staff, their superior professionalism is unsurpassed. We could not recommend Matt more highly to sell a house and would use him again in a heartbeat!

over 8 years ago
No one more trustworthy than Matt Nicastri

Trusting a person to sell something that can literally change the course of your life is like standing on the edge of a cliff with base-jumping expert and saying, "do you think we'll land safely, mate!" And, for those like me who fear real estate agents will be pleasantly surprised by Matt's authentic approach and straight-forward honesty. Matt genuinely cares about you, your property and understands the impact he can have on the next phase of your life if you don't get it right. Such qualities are hard to find. When selling my unit, I never felt like I was sailing off into stormy buyer waters with Matt. Moreover, when the swell picks up as buyers begin to bite Matt's captaincy steadied the emotional ship I was on and calmly guided the process to the finish line. You won't regret partnering with Matt Nicastri, and if you don't think selling your unit is a partnership then you are talking to the wrong agent.

over 8 years ago
Very happy dealing with Matt for an investment property.

We recently bought an investment property through Matt Nicastri, Cunningham Real Estate Agency, Dee Why. We found Matt extremely knowledgeable regarding buying property in the Dee Why to Narrabeen location and his friendly nature assisted us in sealing the property we were after. His dedication to assist us during the viewing of the property, both during open for inspection as well as early evening revisit, was great. It allowed us to see the property and surrounding area both during the day and early evening to make sure we were making the right decision for us. Liliana and Daniel, his colleagues, were also very helpful and we found Cunningham Real Estate to be a very professional yet friendly business to deal with. We would gladly refer our friends and family to them if they were thinking of purchasing property around this area. L&R Buchanan.

over 8 years ago
Fantastic agent

Matt was absolutely fantastic to work with and we would definitely recommend him if you are looking for an agent! From our first meeting with Matt he supported us throughout every step of the selling process. Matt is so down to earth and friendly and was great at updating us regularly on how our campaign was going. We were thrilled with the selling price Matt achieved for us, which exceeded our expectations. Thank you Matt!

over 8 years ago
Awesome Agent

Matt was fantastic from start to finish, great knowledge of what was happening in the area and kept us up to date every step if the way.

over 8 years ago
Pleasure to work with

Matt was a pleasure to work with during the negotiation and purchase of my property. He was always easy to get in touch with when I had questions and provided me with a sense of comfort on the morning of the auction. As the auctioneer he kept it relaxed which was very comforting and made the whole event as enjoyable and easy as possible.

over 8 years ago
Genuine and professional

We met Matt Nicastri and Liliana O'Toole as the agents on the property we purchased. From the first meeting we felt at ease and found them both to be friendly, warm and professional. They were interested in finding out what we were looking for as buyers, without being pushy, and we felt like they were genuinely interested in helping us find the perfect home. They kept us well informed throughout the marketing process, and treated us fairly and with respect. They were accommodating when we requested extra inspections and when it came time for us to make an offer they handled the negotiations fairly and openly. We are thrilled with our purchase and based on our experience as buyers certainly recommend Matt and Lili as agents.

25 - 36 of 75
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent