Matt's profile

Matt's reviews

  4.7  
Matt has 75 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
over 8 years ago
Great agent!

Our house was a little out of the ordinary as it was built on a battle axe block with steep access and no backyard. Matt was extremely knowledgable and knew exactly how to market a niche property and attract the type of buyer that would fall in love with it. Everything from photography, to marketing to price negotiations was spot on and we achieved a price we were extremely happy with. Matt kept us well informed after open homes and often showed buyers through the house outside the listed inspection times. I'd highly recommended his services to anyone thinking of selling. Scott and Daina Cunningham

over 8 years ago
Great Agent

Great professional agent

almost 9 years ago
Fantastic Agent!

Incredible! Was able to work his magic in securing us the price we wanted after 8week plus campaign with only 2 buyers with not much more in offers! We are extremely happy the outcome!

almost 9 years ago
Easy and Simple

Buying from Matt was great, especially compared with other agents we were dealing while house-hunting. Very open and easy to communicate with, and everything seemed above board and reliable.

almost 9 years ago
Highly recommended

We chose Matt Nicastri from Cunninghams to sell our home. He was personable, professional and honest throughout our campaign. We were pleased with his open communication, support and service. We highly recommended Matt and Cunninghams when you are buying or selling a property. A great result thank you!

almost 9 years ago
Recommended!

Matt Nicastri is very professional and knowledgeable about his market yet also very approachable. Our purchase experience through Cunningham was very smooth.

almost 9 years ago
Exceptional Agent

Matt Nicastri has provided the most outstanding service since listing my property for sale. Matt has been in touch constantly throughout and has provided clear and precise explanations of all open home results. I have found Matt a most honest and diligent Agent who has put in a lot of time and effort outside of normal business hours. Matt has the ability and keenness to go beyond to obtain the best possible outcome. At no time did I feel that Matt was not working for me. He has ensured the best result for me which exceded my expectations. I would encourage anybody who wants to sell their home to go with Matt and Lili. A dynamic Duo who get the best results.

almost 9 years ago
Highly recommend using Matt Nicastri and Liliana O'Toole

From the outset Matt and Liliana were consummate professionals, providing us with excellent advice regarding renovations and the best way to present our property for sale. They did all of the project management of that and made sure it was all completed expeditiously. Their advice around marketing and price points was also spot on. In the end we sold prior to auction for a price we were very happy with, and the whole process took less than a month. Could not have asked any more of them, the whole process was seamless! Highly, highly recommend them to potential vendors!

about 9 years ago
This is an agent who gives 110% & instills confidence

From the first day we met with Matt we were impressed with his professionalism & enthusiasm. He worked tirelessly to achieve an attractive offer before going to auction (which was our preferred option) Contracts were exchanged 18 days after the property was listed (for an amount that we were both comfortable with), an outstanding effort. Matt is a very genuine person. We would (& will) recommend him to anyone looking to sell their property. Tom & Louise Menhennitt 10th May 2017

about 9 years ago
Nice to deal with an agent that is honest

What a great agent to deal with. No under quoting or dishonest bs that purchasers go through. I've been round the game long enough and would quite happily buy and sell with Matt. Legend. Can't praise him enough.

about 9 years ago
Highly recommend!

Matt is a very professional and personable agent. He cares for his clients and goes above and beyond. Would highly recommend Matt and look forward to dealing with him again sometime in the future.

37 - 48 of 75
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent