Natasha's profile

Natasha's reviews

  4.7  
Natasha has 49 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Best we've ever worked with in real estate
almost 5 years ago
Best we've ever worked with in real estate

Natasha is the best we've ever worked with in real estate. From the get-go she took very good care of us and held our hand throughout the process. Her suggestions in marketing the property was on point with exactly what todays buyers look for and her 20+ years of experience is evident in her negotiation skills. Even when unexpected situations arise, she was calm and poised and achieved an amazing outcome for us and the buyers. I cannot recommend Natasha and her team enough. Well done McElwaine!!

Seller review
Precise communication
almost 5 years ago
Precise communication

Professionalism and on time, precise communication is the big take I experienced with McElwine Estate Agents. It includes the right advice, partnership during the process and acute knowledge of the market. And very easy to handle everything; simplicity made very close to wisdom. Great experience (and remote locations; though, enjoyable process!!!).

Seller review
Highly Professional
almost 5 years ago
Highly Professional

Natasha and her staff were highly professional and always approachable in all aspects leading to the sale of our property in February this year. All detail was thoroughly explained to us & we always had same day feedback with each inspection Natasha organised. We would gladly recommend McElwaine Real Estate to anybody contemplating the sale of their property. Thank you Natasha & staff.

Seller review
Exceptional knowledge and professional experience
about 5 years ago
Exceptional knowledge and professional experience

Our experience has been sublime. As very inexperienced sellers with a long attachment to our home, Natasha had patience and understanding as we navigated the real estate market. She provided expert advice on presentation of the house and her team produced highly professional marketing material to highlight the features of the property. At all check points, Natasha and her team consulted, ensured that our needs were met, whilst still representing buyers fairly and providing opportunity to consider all aspects of the sale. Natasha showed great care, was always timely in her communication and in operating the open houses and worked to achieve a great outcome for our sale. Natasha has made the process of selling our much loved home a calm experience and her knowledge, professionalism and ability to negotiate fairly have earned our deep respect and gratitude. We recommend Natasha and the McElwaine team very highly and if selling again, would choose this agency without hesitation.

Buyer review
very poor communicator
over 5 years ago
very poor communicator

Overall a pretty poor experience. She was consistently poor at replying to texts/answering calls, often not hearing back for several days. 2 weeks after we had paid the deposit and had an offer accepted we had to do a final inspection of the property to check some minor maintenance and she organised another couple to also view the property at the same time without telling this other couple that there was already an offer accepted (wasting their time) . Wouldn't use by choice

Seller review
Achieved amazing results
over 5 years ago
Achieved amazing results

We have now used McElwaine Real Estate twice to sell our homes and would do so again. Natasha has both times achieved amazing results for our sales. Natasha concentrates on getting great results for her clients over mass sales. With Natasha you are her priority and not just a number. I would use Natasha again and recommend her to anyone wanting excellent quick results. Thank you Natasha and your team.

Seller review
Would Definately Recommend the McElwaine team
about 6 years ago
Would Definately Recommend the McElwaine team

We are happy with the sale of our home. It was an emotional time for us and Natasha was understanding and helpful the whole the way along. Nothing was too big or too small for her to handle for us and she always made us feel like we were a top priority. She believed in our home and that’s what made all the difference to us, she never spoke about it like just a house, but knew it meant more than that to us. Her office communicated well with us and kept us updated with everything we needed to know. Would recommend Natasha and the team to others in the Maitland area.

Seller review
Very professional team all round
over 6 years ago
Very professional team all round

Our experience with Natasha, Zoe & Elizabeth was always professional & easy going. The team worked very hard & tirelessly in a challenging market - Natasha even worked new year's eve! Always kept us up to date with all market enquiries. Didn't quite reach our goal price but still extremely happy. Thoroughly recommend the McElwaine team to anyone wanting to sell or buy 😊

Seller review
95 Swan street Morpeth
over 6 years ago
95 Swan street Morpeth

Congratulations Natasha and your team especially Zoe on the quick sale of my property

Buyer review
Purchase - 95 Swan St, Morpeth
over 6 years ago
Purchase - 95 Swan St, Morpeth

I purchased 95 Swan St, Morpeth and dealt with Zoe for the purchase. Zoe was lovely, personable and extremely helpful throughout the whole process.

Seller review
First class Real Estate
over 6 years ago
First class Real Estate

We were very impressed with Natasha and her team. The marketing and presentation of our house was well presented. Elizabeth was at the open houses and her kind and caring attitude made it so much easier to leave all in her capable hands. We highly reccomend McElwaine Real Estate, we are so please d with the price and how fast it sold.

Seller review
Land Sale Bolwarra
over 6 years ago
Land Sale Bolwarra

Natasha and staff were very helpful, professional and pleasant.

13 - 24 of 49
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent