Nathan's profile

Nathan's reviews

  4.9  
Nathan has 340 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
about 1 month ago
A seamless, positive experience with a passionate team who helped us secure our perfect home.

We would like to sincerely applaud the Buxton Dingley Village + Keysborough team for their professionalism and genuine approach throughout our recent purchase. We’ve just secured our forever family home through them, and we couldn’t be more thrilled with the outcome. Buying at auction wasn’t initially our preferred path, but when this property came up through Buxton, we knew we couldn’t let it pass—it was perfect for our family. Earlier in the year, we attended an auction on Mussert Avenue led by Nathan, which was our first real introduction to the property market. It was clear from the outset that he is exceptional at what he does. Nathan has a natural way with words that feels both warm and authentic, and his pride in the Dingley Village area really shines through. After that auction, I remember my husband saying he hoped that when the time came, we’d be buying through Nathan and his team—and that’s exactly how it turned out. Nathan and Melissa were incredibly helpful, responsive, and transparent throughout the entire process, always quick to answer any questions we had. We’re so grateful to have worked with Nathan, Melissa, and Katie, and couldn’t recommend the Buxton team more highly for anyone considering their next property purchase.

about 1 month ago
Superstars!!

Nathan and Melissa did an amazing job selling our first home last weekend and helped us achieve an incredible result! From start to finish they were professional and completely on top of every detail while having some fun along the way! They made the stressful process feel smooth and we always felt confident that we were in good hands. We’re so grateful for their work and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Nathan and Melissa to anyone looking to sell their home 👌👌

about 1 month ago
Excellent Agent and Excellent Communicator

Nathan is an amazing Real Estate Agent in Dingley Village. Very professional, excellent communicator and helpful. We purchased our new family home through Nathan and the team and the way he treated the home, buyers and the vendors were with utmost care and respect. All of our questions were answered promptly to make critical final decisions and did not try to play any "real estate" games. Definitely genuine, friendly and knowledgeable agent in the area ♥️ Thankyou once again for helping with our purchase and highly recommend

2 months ago
Well prepared, well informed and supported at every stage

Nathan is highly professional and a great communicator. Nothing is too much trouble. I contacted him in a slight panic just before an open for inspection when I had a plumbing issue and my plumber was out of action. Nathan got a plumber there in no time - problem solved. This example highlights Nathan’s approach. He is there with you providing expert advice and support to get you through the property sale process with an outstanding result. He is generous with his knowledge and expertise and is kind and caring at all times. We highly recommend Nathan to anyone looking to sell their home and achieve an amazing outcome through a well planned and executed campaign tailored to your particular needs.

5 months ago
Nathan is dynamic, driven, and deeply client-focused—delivering standout results with integrity.

Selling my mum’s unit after 40 years was a big milestone, and Nathan Arrowsmith from Buxton made the entire process smooth and supportive. From the beginning, Nathan said the unit had a real “vibe,” and his confidence, honesty and charisma were backed by clear communication and genuine professionalism. He understood how significant the sale was for our family and treated the property with genuine care and enthusiasm. Nathan’s guidance throughout the campaign was reassuring, and his expertise truly showed on auction day — the unit sold above reserve, exceeding our expectations. We are very grateful for his work and highly recommend Nathan to anyone looking for a dedicated, trustworthy and skilled real estate agent.

6 months ago
Great result!!

Engaged Nathan and his team to sell my home. The marketing and internet presence was put together brilliantly and was outstanding against other properties in the area. Nathan, Melissa and Katie were 100% professional and their interaction with both me and prospective purchasers was fantastic. Got the end result that I wanted with minimal fuss and certainly little stress. Highly recommend Nathan and his team to anyone looking to sell their home.

7 months ago
Great Result

Nathan and his team at Buxton were recommended to us by a trusted associate active in the property market. They recently helped us achieve an excellent result with the sale of our property in Chelsea Heights. The sales plan was sound, communication was clear and consistent, and while results can never be guaranteed, in our case the outcome exceeded expectations. We’re very happy with the process and result, and hope others experience the same success with this team.

8 months ago
Fantastic!

Nathan, Melissa and the Buxton team were fantastic in the sale of our house. Their expertise and professionalism really showed in the entire selling process from the start to the end when they achieved an excellent auction result for us. The whole process was a breeze and we would highly recommend Nathan to any potential vendors. He was an absolute pleasure to work with!

8 months ago
Selling property in Mordialloc

Nathan, Mel and the team were very supportive through the process to get us the best final result, would highly recommend for those looking to sell their property.

8 months ago
Professional knowledgeable caring

Nathan and his team provided us with an honest knowledge of the market, stress free communication during the entire process of selling, and auction day was a breeze with a terrific outcome. Highly recommend.

8 months ago
Amazing People

Thank you Nathan and everyone at Buxton for all the help, support and guidance over the last little while. Buying and selling is not for the faint of heart but the team was absolutely amazing through both. We truly wouldn't have wanted to do it without them all! Thank you for wonderful result and thank you for taking our endless calls. We'll miss hanging out every weekend at open homes and late night text messages lol. They're a great bunch of people who are committed to doing the very best. Thank you!

9 months ago
Fantastic service

A huge thank you to Nathan, Katie and team for helping us sell our little family home. From the very beginning, their communication was outstanding — always keeping us informed and answering every question with patience and care. Their persistence and dedication ensured we achieved a fantastic price, and the whole process felt smooth and well-managed. We’re so grateful for their hard work and highly recommend them to anyone looking to sell.

1 - 12 of 340
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent