Nathan's profile

Nathan's reviews

  4.9  
Nathan has 343 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nathan's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent Agent
over 4 years ago
Excellent Agent

Got a great result during a very difficult time. Nathan was very professional and honest.

Buyer review
Always professional and enthusiastic.
over 4 years ago
Always professional and enthusiastic.

Nathan Arrowsmith is an excellent agent! He always took our calls or returned them promptly, gave us the most accurate advice, was very friendly and made us feel confident in his abilities. His professional manner and enthusiasm for real estate always shone through and we appreciated Nathan’s honesty and integrity during the process of buying our new home.

Seller review
Always a pleasure to deal with Nathan - an easy and simple transaction
over 4 years ago
Always a pleasure to deal with Nathan - an easy and simple transaction

Nathan has great communication skills - always keeping me in the loop with the progress of the sale. His area knowledge was outstanding and his professionalism was refreshing. This was a quick sale in a tough market. I was very happy with the outcome and would highly recommend him.

Seller review
Excellent Sale experience
over 4 years ago
Excellent Sale experience

I found Nathan and Melissa to be a fantastic choice to market and sell my home of 25 years. Knowledge and advice was exceptional. I would recommend to anyone looking for a very professional team.

Buyer review
One of the best you find in Melbourne!
almost 5 years ago
One of the best you find in Melbourne!

Nathan helped us secure a beautiful property amidst all the uncertainties and craziness that came with Melbourne lockdowns. He is honest, straightforward to deal with, and always has a smile on his face no matter what (his headshot photo is very accurate). Communicating him was seamless and timely. I would recommend talking to Nathan whether you are selling or buying and he will surely look after you :)

Seller review
Saved by Nathan and Melissa
almost 5 years ago
Saved by Nathan and Melissa

We had a disastrous experience with another agency and agent. We asked Nathan Arrowsmith to take over the sale of our property. Nathan and Melissa Smith worked as a team, took the stress off us and sold our home for a very satisfactory price within the time frame Nathan planned. Open for inspection times were few and easy to manage. Nathan's fee for selling was most reasonable. No gimmicks or tricks; just a straight forward fee as a percentage of sale price. In addition, Nathan negotiated with the agent who had sold us our new home to ensure a smooth transition. Lastly, and of most importance, both Nathan and Melissa are nice people. They are professional but also warm and friendly and genuinely interested in our welfare during what is always a testing time. We're certain that Nathan and Melissa are estate agents working for more than just money and commissions. They are also helping people and caring for clients.

Buyer review
Excellent communicator!
almost 5 years ago
Excellent communicator!

Nathan's communication, knowledge and professionalism is of the highest standard. He helps to perpetuate the overall experience we've had with Buxton Dingley Village. We sold a property and bought our next property with Buxton and were very happy with the experience. Nathan was always responsive and helpful. Working with Nathan eliminated the unknowns and all the anxiety that comes with buying a new property. We would definitely recommend Nathan to anyone looking for a new home.

Seller review
Professional and diligent
almost 5 years ago
Professional and diligent

Nathan Arrowsmith was the agent for selling my late parent's home in Dingley Village in which he took on with empathy and understanding of our loss. He went above and beyond during a difficult period including COVID lockdowns. We are thankful and could not recommend him highly enough for his kindness, professionalism and hard working ethic. We achieved a sale price above and beyond through his hard work and knowledge of the market. Thanks so much Nathan and Melissa and team at Buxton Legendary Team Work achieving a terrific result for our family.

Buyer review
Outstanding agent
almost 5 years ago
Outstanding agent

Nathan is how most agents should be- honest, empathetic, responsive and easy to deal with. This was the only property that we looked at and it was a seamless and relatively stress free transaction. I would highly recommend Nathan to prospective buyers or sellers.

Buyer review
First Class
almost 5 years ago
First Class

My wife and I are absolutely over the moon With our New Home. Nathan was and is “First Class”, All the team at Buxton Dingley were so easy to speak to and most friendly “Gold Sticker”

Seller review
Professional - Creative - Adaptive
almost 5 years ago
Professional - Creative - Adaptive

We would recommend that anyone considering selling their home engage with Nathan & his team. Even with all the hurdles placed in front of him through government restrictions, he achieved a brilliant result for us in very quick time. Nathan was very adaptive & creative with our campaign so as to keep it on track & allow us to maintain our timeline for our next journey. Nathan & Melissa kept us regularly updated & are easily the best people to entrust with the sale of your important asset.

Seller review
A great experience with a professional agent
about 5 years ago
A great experience with a professional agent

We made the right decision choosing Nathan and his team at Buxton to sell our home. Nathan was Professional, honest and understanding throughout the whole process. Selling through COVID and a lockdown didn’t slow Nathan’s drive and determination . He was extremely creative in getting us a great result for our home.

85 - 96 of 343
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent