Paul's profile

Paul's reviews

  4.9  
Paul has 313 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
3 months ago
Excellent communicator, Bayside knowledge and network, third time engaging in Paul

I first engaged Paul some time ago to sell my parents’ property, and after that experience I was keen to have him involved in selling my own apartment. Paul and Nat - what a dynamic duo. From the first couple of phone calls to arrange an initial meeting right through to the sale, everything was exceptional. Our contracts were signed within two weeks of going to market, which was an incredible outcome. I couldn’t be happier. Communication throughout the process was fantastic. We received updates straight after every inspection, and I really appreciated the proactive approach and transparency. Paul has been looking after the Bayside area for a long time, and it truly shows in his professionalism, knowledge and results. I would highly recommend Paul and his team. You won’t be disappointed ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

3 months ago
Excellent Communicator and Experienced Team

Paul, Natalie and Team, Thank you for not only helping us buy this house but now for guiding us through the selling process. Thank you for your professionalism in working with our Vendor advocate and making the whole process run smoothly and most importantly, successfully!

3 months ago
Excellent Communicator and very professional.

Paul was excellent to deal with, things ran smooth from start to finish. The buying process was definately made easier with Pauls display of professionalism and knowlesge throughout. Paul also displayed great transparency and follow up at key moments only cementing my trust in him to finalise buying my first property. Would recommend Paul when looking to buy your next property.

4 months ago
Excellence backed by a formidable team at Buxton Hampton East.

Our Experience with Paul Sibley at Buxton Hampton East Initial Recommendation and Background Paul was recommended to us via Open Agent when we began searching for high-performing agents in our area to sell an apartment in Highett. From the very first contact by text message, it was evident that Paul had a sound knowledge of our building and after conducting my own analysis of Paul’s sales within our building, I discovered he had sold half of the apartments in the building, with some even sold more than once. First Impressions and Readiness to List At our initial meeting with Paul, it quickly became apparent he was the right agent for us. Since our apartment had just been renovated and staging was already completed, we were in a strong position to list the property straight away. Support from the Buxton Hampton East Team Paul, Natalie and the entire team at Buxton Hampton East were incredibly helpful in every aspect of getting our property to market within just a few days. Paul and his team acted swiftly and efficiently, ensuring everything proceeded smoothly. Throughout the process, we were kept informed of all progress and advised whenever the property was shown to potential buyers, even outside scheduled open for inspections. Successful Sale and Recommendation Paul’s expertise and professionalism were instrumental in achieving a sale in just three weeks. If you are considering selling in Highett, we highly recommend Paul as your agent.

6 months ago
Responsive and great outcome

Could not fault Paul and Nat throughout our sales Campaign. They were efficient, responsive and true subject matter experts. Made a busy time as seamless as it could be. Got us a great outcome too, prior to auction!

7 months ago
Very professional, bang on the market and clear, uncomplicated communication

Paul was referred to me as being the top real-estate agent in the Moorabbin area and he didn't disappoint. He has excellent knowledge of the market and worked hard generating multiple prospects that lead to a good auction day result. His agency is a well-oiled machine, and their processes very easy to follow in what otherwise might have been an overwhelming experience. The job was done in 3 weeks. He was also very engaging and entertaining as an auctioneer, which I'm sure counted on the day. I would highly recommend him and his agency.

7 months ago
An Agent Your Can Trust

Paul was an absolute pleasure to deal with and someone that I will certainly be looking to sell in the future with. Things moved very quickly with the purchase and Paul was prompt and honest and open right throughout the 24-48 hour period before the Under Offer/Sold Sticker went up. Unlike other agents, Paul was honest and wasn't here to waste anyone's time, giving clear direction around the vendor's expectations and the other feedback from other buyers. I couldn't recommend him any higher!

9 months ago
Professional, friendly, and efficient agent/auctioneer delivering on communication and result

Paul was professional and friendly throughout the entire process of selling our family home. He was easy to deal with, always quick to respond to messages and calls, and kept us well informed by liaising with us consistently across the campaign. We particularly appreciated his honesty, efficiency, and clear communication, which made the whole experience smooth and stress-free. his negotiation skills helped achieve a reasonable price, and even after the sale, his follow-up and post-communication were thorough and timely. We are very grateful for his support and highly recommend him.

9 months ago
Thankyou Paul Sibley !

I had experienced Paul's professionalism, knowledge and friendliness to prospective buyers at various properties in the Hampton area over the last few years. This, and the outstanding way he conducts an auction made it a no brainer when choosing an agent to sell my unit in Hampton. The whole experience was seamless, positive in all respects and produced a fantastic result. I would not hesitate to use Paul and his team again, and I highly recommend him to anyone contemplating selling in the wider Bayside area.

about 1 year ago
10/10 in all aspects, professionalism, knowledge and communication

Paul displayed great expertise and insight throughout the campaign and as an auctioneer, achieving a better than expected result. I found Paul to be honest and very approachable, and his excellent communication always kept me up to date with the progress of the campaign. As a team both Paul and Natalie understood my requirements and focussed on achieving them, they were very personable and a pleasure to work with. I would highly recommend Paul and Natalie for the sale of your property.

about 1 year ago
Excellent Service and Result

Thanks Paul and Natalie for making the process easy. We reached a great result and decided to sell prior to auction. The experience was excellent from start to finish. Transparent communication and real expectations were set. This is the second time we've engaged Paul and Natalie. Totally recommend. You won't be disappointed.

1 - 12 of 313
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent