Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 131 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: hard-working, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Extremely professional, would sell through Peter again
almost 5 years ago
Extremely professional, would sell through Peter again

Peter was fantastic to deal with from the start, gave us great advice kept us updated through the process an was extremely respectful of our home. We would sell through Peter again and would highly recommend him to others looking for an honest, easy process and professional experience

Seller review
Peter Hickey is one of the best agents in Bayside!
almost 5 years ago
Peter Hickey is one of the best agents in Bayside!

I have been using Peter to sell my developments for the past 10 years reason being is that he is one of the best agents in Bayside and has a great office behind him. The best thing about Peter is that I know he leaves no stone unturned when selling any of my properties and has a leave it with me kind of attitude. As a result he always gets a great result in any market condition. I would not hesitate in recommending Peter sell anyone's home.

Seller review
Highly recommended
almost 5 years ago
Highly recommended

All business, Peter gave us high expectations and he achieved them.

Buyer review
easy going, great to deal with , excellent service
over 5 years ago
easy going, great to deal with , excellent service

Our property purchase has been really smooth and Peter has been always available to help us when we called him. He has been very patient and has great eye to detail on what ever he sells. As an Buyer, we had a wonderful experience dealing with him.

Seller review
Top Notch Professional !
over 5 years ago
Top Notch Professional !

Peter had been in regular contact with us for nearly 10 years. When the time was right to sell, he was the first & only agent we contacted, as he is the Sandringham specialist and was never pushy , but always attentive. The outcome we received was better than we expected and the way he negotiated the final price with the buyer was incredible. Thank you Peter for being there when we needed you. We cannot recommend you more highly. You are a Top Notch Professional !

Seller review
I could not be happier!
over 5 years ago
I could not be happier!

Peter’s knowledge of the Bayside market was impressive and supported by property comparisons and previous sales. All enquiries and calls were responded to quickly and eloquently in a timely and courteous manner.

Buyer review
Peter has been exceptional to deal with !
over 5 years ago
Peter has been exceptional to deal with !

Peter has been exceptional to deal with, despite being the vendor's agent and I was the buyer. His communications have been genuine, thorough and timely. He has responded and accommodated all our requests to the best of his ability and has done so with a high level of professionalism and integrity. I have no hesitation in recommending Peter and definitely look forward to working with him again.

Seller review
I would highly recommend Peter to any bayside buyer/seller.
over 5 years ago
I would highly recommend Peter to any bayside buyer/seller.

I would like to acknowledge Peter for his great work in selling our property within 2 weeks of being on the market over the covid-19 period. We engaged Peter to sell our family home of 20 years after he assisted us in the purchase of a smaller property earlier in the year which was not straight forward. Peter is very passionate and positive, very helpful in giving advice, has a good network and great local knowledge. I would highly recommend Peter to any bayside buyer/seller.

Seller review
Peter Hickey is the Consummate Professional
about 6 years ago
Peter Hickey is the Consummate Professional

Peter Hickey was a consummate professional throughout the campaign. He sent detailed emails on likely numbers of candidates interested following open for inspections. When the Covid crisis emerged he switched gears instantly enabling a fantastic result by contacting those buyers who were seriously interested. Thank you Peter. Highly recommend Peter for any campaign.

Seller review
You're In Safe Hands With Peter Hickey
about 6 years ago
You're In Safe Hands With Peter Hickey

You're in safe hands with Peter Hickey. We chose to work with Peter after interviewing several top agents operating in our area. Peter stood out as the best choice, based on his experience, personability, attention to detail and integrity. The confidence and trust Peter inspired was well deserved as he worked closely with us over the course of the campaign. In very trying and unforeseen circumstances outside all of our control, Peter remained professional and delivered an excellent result.

Seller review
From beginning to end, we were again impressed by Peters professionalism and attention to detail !
over 6 years ago
From beginning to end, we were again impressed by Peters professionalism and attention to detail !

This is the second time Peter has sold a property for us. Peter's knowledge of the local market enabled him to accurately advise us of the right price range at which to pitch our home. From beginning to end, we were again impressed by Peters professionalism and attention to detail. Peter has also successfully sold homes for several friends too, and we have no hesitation in recommending him to others.

25 - 36 of 131
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent