Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 131 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: hard-working, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Sold before auction
almost 7 years ago
Sold before auction

We are very pleased that Peter was able to find us a buyer for our property, at a price that was above our reserve, before auction. He was very professional and we’re glad we chose him for the sale of our property.

Seller review
Goes the extra mile
almost 7 years ago
Goes the extra mile

We have known Pete Hickey for approx 8 years through club sport, school and local community. We were always impressed with his professionalism. When it came to selling our property, for us, there was no other choice. Pete understood the challenges we were facing and made the entire process seamless. Pete achieved an amazing outcome for our property in an incredibly difficult market. We would have no hesitation in recommending him as an agent.

Seller review
Great service, prepared to go the extra mile.
almost 7 years ago
Great service, prepared to go the extra mile.

This is the first time I have sold through Peter Hickey at Buxton Sandringham although I have purchased through him twice. I continue to find his service extremely professional, prepared to get to know his clients and potential buyers and to go the extra mile to deliver a good result.

Buyer review
A very pleasant Experience.
almost 7 years ago
A very pleasant Experience.

We had the pleasure of meeting Peter at an open house and were very impressed by his low key way of being available to answer every question we came up with and the way he was able to cross refer to other properties in the area when we expressed any doubt about a point. He immediately recognised us on a repeat visit, and handled our negotiations to purchase with quiet calmness and every facility we could want until the deal was complete. Extremely professional and helpful throughout.

Seller review
Rview by Glenda and Warren Stahel
almost 7 years ago
Rview by Glenda and Warren Stahel

When we decided to sell our home we walked the nearby streets to ascertain which local real estate agents had the most "for sale" boards up. We chose two agents to provide us with an evaluation, describe the process plus judge who we could work confidently with. We meet Peter and the decision was made. It was not an ideal time to sell our property with the recent slump in market prices, the handing down of the results of the Banking Royal Commission and the looming Federal election, however we certainly chose the best agent for the job. Peter was at all times professional and forthright. All through the process Peter communicated honestly with us every step of the way, alleviating any concerns and making suggestions. We really felt he was working for us, the vendor. Peter is a genuine person who is passionate about helping people through his knowledge of the real estate market. We will have no hesitation in referring him to our friends and family.

Seller review
Never gives UP!!
almost 7 years ago
Never gives UP!!

Peter was an excellent choice as our Agent. He knows the area exceptionally well and is up to date with possible buyers and developers. Even with the downturn in the market, he wanted the best price for my elderly Father and wouldn't settle for less. He liaised with all the potential buyers, without being pushy and gave us detailed feedback throughout the process. He was available to us at any time when we had questions and went out of his way to achieve the best possible result for us. I would highly recommend Peter to anyone in the process of buying or selling their house, as they would be in the best possible hands.

Seller review
Peter is a realestate agent my husband & I have looked to for advice over many years.
almost 7 years ago
Peter is a realestate agent my husband & I have looked to for advice over many years.

Because Peter is such a nice person to deal with he can make the whole experience trouble free. Buying & selling realestate can be very stressful. Peter is businesslike, honest & knows this area very well. He sold my family home 5 years ago. I would encourage my friends to seek Peters advice. Rae Moir

Seller review
One of best agents I have ever had sell a property for me, a miracle worker!
almost 7 years ago
One of best agents I have ever had sell a property for me, a miracle worker!

As a property developer I deal with many agents and I can say Peter is one the best. He managed to sell one my properties in a very bad market after a failed campaign with another agent and he had no campaign behind him. Thank you Peter for all your help through a very difficult time.

Buyer review
House purchase review
about 7 years ago
House purchase review

Cheerful, proactive and happy to help. I found Peter very approachable and willing to discuss his thoughts on the current market.

Seller review
A Great Agent
about 7 years ago
A Great Agent

My wife and I would like to congratulate Peter Hickey from Buxton Sandringham for his practical, honest and professional advice in handling the sale of our house in Beaumaris which we had lived in 22 yrs. We exchanged views and opinions in a professional and business manner. Thanks Peter. We would highly recommend Buxton Sandringham to handle you real estate needs.

Seller review
Excellent Agent
about 7 years ago
Excellent Agent

Peter has sold four of our families properties over the last few years. We have always used Peter, as we have found him to be very professional in aspects of selling our properties. He has always been able to extract that extra dollar out of a potential buyer either during the sale or after. I would have no hesitation in recommending him to any future client. Regards David Flood

Seller review
A job well done for a great result
over 7 years ago
A job well done for a great result

We agreed to a low key, directly marketed strategy, which resulted in a prompt sale at a very good price, without the hassle of an expensive marketing campaign.

49 - 60 of 131
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent