Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 90 reviewsacross 28 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, honest, friendly, reliable, supportive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Disappointing Experience with Property Purchase
7 months ago
Disappointing Experience with Property Purchase

Disappointing Experience with Property Purchase I regret to say that this has been the worst property purchase I have ever made. The seller, along with their agent, Mr. Peter Menaglio, attempted to downplay numerous issues with the unit, which were later confirmed by a concerning structural report. Despite raising these concerns, we received little to no support or rectification from Mr. Menaglio. Even after conducting a final inspection, several problems became apparent, and upon moving in, additional issues surfaced. Below is a list of the major concerns: Overall, I did not expect this level of negligence from a reputable real estate agent. The lack of attention to detail and the absence of follow-through on promised repairs have made this experience incredibly frustrating. I strongly advise potential buyers to proceed with caution.

Seller review
Recommended
10 months ago
Recommended

Peter was knowledgeable, he was polite, and he explained the selling process clearly and patiently. And he found a great sale price. Thanks Peter

Buyer review
Friendly, helpful and thorough
12 months ago
Friendly, helpful and thorough

We bought a property from Peter. He was polite, friendly, thorough and honest. The property required some minor repairs, and he attended to these promptly, well within the settlement date. He was also east to communicate with, responding quickly to all messages.

Seller review
Professional
12 months ago
Professional

I found Peter to be a very professional and knowledgeable agent. His wealth of experience and knowledge helped me to have a very successful sale on my villa. Highly recommend Peter to any prospective seller.

Seller review
Well informed, and good communication
over 1 year ago
Well informed, and good communication

Peter provided excellent service, understood the market well, and communicated well. I was very happy with the outcome.

Seller review
Professional approach, knowledgeable, excellent communicator
over 1 year ago
Professional approach, knowledgeable, excellent communicator

I was referred to Peter by a buyers agent and upon the initial call I felt comfortable working with Peter from that point forward. Peter talked me through the process which included arranging an appraisal. After that was conducted he gave his thoughts as to the presentation and price range of the property based on his research and knowledge of the market. From listing to offers, Peter was engaged, clear and timely communication, advice was given where sought, and he worked with the buyer and property manager through this process, including the final inspection where there were some issues that suddenly arose. I really appreciated Peter's efforts right throughout the process and was happy with the sale and outcome achieved.

Seller review
Very professional and easy to deal with
over 1 year ago
Very professional and easy to deal with

Peter was very knowledgeable and easy to deal with. He took care of everything and ensured the process of selling my house was smooth and without stress. Very pleased with the result, would definitely recommend.

Buyer review
Fantastic service
over 1 year ago
Fantastic service

Peter treated us with nothing but respect and kindness as first home buyers. Peter's communication was brilliant, making sure we were kept in the loop. We would happily recommend / utilise Peter's services in the future.

Seller review
Peter's knowledge of the market was exceptional, his communication & professionalism was excellent.
almost 2 years ago
Peter's knowledge of the market was exceptional, his communication & professionalism was excellent.

We had no hesitation in choosing Peter to sell our rental property as we had worked with Peter before. His knowledge of the market is exceptional and he got us a great price, way above the starting price. He stayed in contact with us and kept us up to date through the whole process. He was very professional and honest with us from the very start. I would have no hesitation in recommending Peter to anyone who is looking at selling their property.

Seller review
Successful Sale
almost 2 years ago
Successful Sale

Peter acted in a very professional and friendly manner while achiever top dollar for the sale of our investment property.

Seller review
Professional Sales Agent
almost 2 years ago
Professional Sales Agent

I recently had the pleasure of working with Peter to sell my property. Peter has deep knowledge of the local market, his experties achieved the best result for me. Thank you Peter.

Buyer review
Very professional
almost 2 years ago
Very professional

Professional, friendly, quick response

1 - 12 of 90
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent