Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 371 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: easy to work with, honest, supportive, responsive, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Friendly and responsive sales team
5 months ago
Friendly and responsive sales team

Peter and the Shiels team were direct in communication and easy to deal with, and accommodated all of my requests around property inspections and information with ease. The purchase process was friendly throughout and given the busy timing just before Christmas, the team were responsive and ensured that everything was finalised before holiday closures. All in all my purchase felt like a genuine and low-stress experience.

Seller review
Pete and his team are 10 outta 10!
5 months ago
Pete and his team are 10 outta 10!

Pete and his team secured us out asking price and kept us in the loop the whole time with great communication and support. If you live in the 2290 don’t sell with anyone else.

Seller review
Communication and professionalism
5 months ago
Communication and professionalism

Pete was amazing to work with, nothing was ever a bother, always had the answers and supported us through the process. Had the best communication, we always felt like we were looked after and in safe hands. Would highly recommend Pete.

Seller review
Best house sale experience ever!
5 months ago
Best house sale experience ever!

I sold my house with Shiels & Co and it was the best experience imaginable. The house was under offer and subsequently sold very well in what must be a record time of one day after listing! My experience with Peter has been nothing but fantastic. He is professional, punctual and respectful, offered insight and advice and was always just a quick call away. Peter clearly understands the market and the area very well, as is evidenced by the many successful sales I could see - something that influenced my decision to engage him in the first place. Similarly, my experience with the agency was great, from the listing process and organising the one house inspection I actually had, to general advice and the mechanics of the sale. Natalie and Ruby were very helpful and it was always easy to know exactly where I was in the process, what was needed etc. With Shiels, I always felt that things were in hand and everything was transparent - the way it should be. So with all this in mind, I am very happy that I chose to go with Peter and company, would use them again and would wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone looking for a truly professional representation in the market and a smooth, hassle-free and transparent sale process.

Buyer review
5 Star Experience
5 months ago
5 Star Experience

Pete and Natalie made buying our new home and selling our current home easy. They provided a professional but personable experience and always provided timely feedback and great communication. Thanks Pete and Nat!

Seller review
Professional, friendly, and there when needed
5 months ago
Professional, friendly, and there when needed

Took the time to understand our full needs and what mattered most to our family. Always contactable and responsive, making the whole process feel smooth. Friendly, supportive team who guided us at every step and made us feel confident in our decisions.

Seller review
Outstanding Performance
6 months ago
Outstanding Performance

Peter was excellent throughout the whole process. He gave us an accurate estimate and worked quickly to get us the price we wanted. He maintained outstanding communication throughout, providing us with regular updates. I couldn’t recommend him enough if selling in the Lake Macquarie area.

Buyer review
Friendly and Professional
6 months ago
Friendly and Professional

Peter and the team made the process of buying very easy and simple. We never felt pressured and always felt listened to. I would recommend the team!

Seller review
Smooth sailing in selling mums property with Pete.
6 months ago
Smooth sailing in selling mums property with Pete.

Pete’s continued communication on the progress of the sale was excellent. His advice in preparing the home with stylists paid off. The sale price of mum’s home exceeded our expectations.

Seller review
"Above and Beyond in Every Way"
6 months ago
"Above and Beyond in Every Way"

Selling my home in Dudley was a deeply emotional and stressful experience, but having Peter Shiels as my agent made all the difference. From the very beginning, Peter approached the sale with genuine enthusiasm and a clear commitment to achieving the best outcome for me. His efficiency and professionalism were outstanding — every step of the process was handled smoothly and with absolute attention to detail. What truly set Peter apart was his excellent communication. He kept me informed at every stage, responded to my queries quickly and patiently, and always made sure I understood what was happening and why. During moments when the process felt overwhelming, Peter was encouraging, supportive, and reassuring. I always felt I had someone in my corner who truly cared. I couldn’t have asked for a better agent to guide me through such a significant life transition. I would highly recommend Peter Shiels to anyone looking for an agent who is not only skilled and efficient but also compassionate, responsive, and genuinely invested in their clients.

13 - 24 of 371
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent