Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 377 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: easy to work with, honest, supportive, responsive, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
5 Star Experience
7 months ago
5 Star Experience

Pete and Natalie made buying our new home and selling our current home easy. They provided a professional but personable experience and always provided timely feedback and great communication. Thanks Pete and Nat!

Seller review
Professional, friendly, and there when needed
7 months ago
Professional, friendly, and there when needed

Took the time to understand our full needs and what mattered most to our family. Always contactable and responsive, making the whole process feel smooth. Friendly, supportive team who guided us at every step and made us feel confident in our decisions.

Seller review
Outstanding Performance
7 months ago
Outstanding Performance

Peter was excellent throughout the whole process. He gave us an accurate estimate and worked quickly to get us the price we wanted. He maintained outstanding communication throughout, providing us with regular updates. I couldn’t recommend him enough if selling in the Lake Macquarie area.

Buyer review
Friendly and Professional
7 months ago
Friendly and Professional

Peter and the team made the process of buying very easy and simple. We never felt pressured and always felt listened to. I would recommend the team!

Seller review
Smooth sailing in selling mums property with Pete.
7 months ago
Smooth sailing in selling mums property with Pete.

Pete’s continued communication on the progress of the sale was excellent. His advice in preparing the home with stylists paid off. The sale price of mum’s home exceeded our expectations.

Seller review
"Above and Beyond in Every Way"
7 months ago
"Above and Beyond in Every Way"

Selling my home in Dudley was a deeply emotional and stressful experience, but having Peter Shiels as my agent made all the difference. From the very beginning, Peter approached the sale with genuine enthusiasm and a clear commitment to achieving the best outcome for me. His efficiency and professionalism were outstanding — every step of the process was handled smoothly and with absolute attention to detail. What truly set Peter apart was his excellent communication. He kept me informed at every stage, responded to my queries quickly and patiently, and always made sure I understood what was happening and why. During moments when the process felt overwhelming, Peter was encouraging, supportive, and reassuring. I always felt I had someone in my corner who truly cared. I couldn’t have asked for a better agent to guide me through such a significant life transition. I would highly recommend Peter Shiels to anyone looking for an agent who is not only skilled and efficient but also compassionate, responsive, and genuinely invested in their clients.

Buyer review
Above and Beyond Experience
8 months ago
Above and Beyond Experience

From the very first time we met Pete and Natalie, we were impressed by your energy, professionalism, and genuine kindness. Your time, effort, and unwavering support throughout the process were truly appreciated. You made everything smooth and transparent, always considering both sides—the buyer and the seller—which gave us complete confidence in every step. 🩷🏠 We absolutely loved the thoughtful gifts and are so grateful for them. Thank you for helping us secure our home sweet home just in time for Christmas—it means the world to us. Wishing you both a wonderful Christmas and a happy New Year. And of course… Go Newcastle Knights! 🥳🏉 Warm regards, Catia & Trent

Seller review
Excellent. So easy to associate and communicate with.
8 months ago
Excellent. So easy to associate and communicate with.

I am very impressed by how Peter and Natalie were in their professional approach to the sale of the house. I was appreciative of their guidance and ease of talking to them. Couldn’t have asked for a better agency. Even Ruby and the office staff were excellent . Would definitely recommend Shiels Agency for selling or buying.

Buyer review
Excellent
8 months ago
Excellent

Peter was incredibly professional and wonderful to deal with. Understanding, made you feel heard and very quick to respond. Heartfelt thanks for helping us secure our dream home.

Seller review
This bloke delivers every time!
8 months ago
This bloke delivers every time!

This is the second time we have sold with Pete and his incredible team. Pete and Nat had us pumped from our initial catch up and Ruby kept us in the loop with all the paperwork and worked around our timings for open homes. You can really tell the experience in Pete’s guidance and support and we couldn’t be happier with the outcome. Shiels & Co has our business for life!

Buyer review
Incredibly helpful agent
8 months ago
Incredibly helpful agent

Peter was incredibly helpful and professional. Though out the process, he went above and beyond to guide and assist me with the buying and cooling off processes. Buying with him was noticeably less stressful then many of my other real estate agent experiences and communication with him was very easy and re-assuring.

Seller review
Outstanding
9 months ago
Outstanding

Great customer service and an excellent negotiator who was able to sell our home for a price significantly higher than expectations. I couldn't recommend him and his team more highly

25 - 36 of 377
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent