Shellie's profile

Shellie's reviews

  4.9  
Shellie has 461 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shellie's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, honest, friendly, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Always available, A friend, and a great result
about 3 years ago
Always available, A friend, and a great result

Shellie Nightingale has an excellent knowledge and experience in the Tablelands area. Shellie was very straightforward to deal with and we found her trustworthy and very reliable. Shellie was able to achieve an excellent result after negotiating multiple offers. We would highly recommend Shellie Nightingale to sell or buy your next property.

Buyer review
A pleasure to deal with
about 3 years ago
A pleasure to deal with

Shellie worked hard, made herself available at short notice, was responsive to enquiries, was professional and frank in her advice, and did everything possible to achieve an outcome that both parties were happy with. Highly recommended.

Buyer review
Thanks to Shellie
about 3 years ago
Thanks to Shellie

We were very fortunate to have Shellie as our agent to communicate to. She was extremely helpful and had good knowledge of the seller's character. Shellie was always there for us if we needed her to ask the seller any questions. She had a good idea on the market pricing and guided us through. Thankyou Shellie and look forward to popping in and saying hi when we get there. Thanks again Keith and Jeanine

Seller review
Can't recommend enough!
about 3 years ago
Can't recommend enough!

I can't recommend Shellie enough for the sale of our property!, she had achieved a sale price that i didnt think was possible! and the property had been appraised substantially lower from other "popular" agents in the community. Shellies communication was professional, friendly and prompt and she made it easy for me to understand all of the technical sides of selling a house which I had no idea about !, if you want an honest trustworthy and reliable agent look no further !, thanks again Shellie for all your hard work !

Seller review
Recommendation for Shellie’s strong knowledge, communication and professional sales support.
about 3 years ago
Recommendation for Shellie’s strong knowledge, communication and professional sales support.

Shellie was pro active in identifying potential buyers based on her strong local market knowledge, understanding of the sales requirements and buyers on her books. Shellie maintained strong communication keeping me informed of any changes with prospective buyers and the local market influences. Shellie gave what I considered were honest and considered opinions during our conversations on options at various times. I feel the sales process was easy and uncomplicated. I have no hesitation in recommending Shellie to prospective sellers or buyers.

Other review
Excellent work
about 3 years ago
Excellent work

Shellie was a pleasure to deal with buying our new property, she was up front, honest and communciated well. Even after the property was purchased she has gone over and above assisting us with further enquires. She is a true professional. Thanks Shellie.

Seller review
Truly the best ♥️
about 3 years ago
Truly the best ♥️

Shellie is nothing but a pleasure to work with. This is the second home she has sold for us and it was just as smooth as the first. She is reliable, knowledgeable, honest and realistic and I would not hesitate to use her if I were buying or selling again. Her passion for her job really does show in everything she does. 🏡

Seller review
Best agent one could ask for.
about 3 years ago
Best agent one could ask for.

Shellie has been amazing, from buying through her and now selling through her. Answered any questions I had and was always very helpful, making the transition very easy. Thank you Shellie, you're a true gem.

Seller review
Highly Recommended
about 3 years ago
Highly Recommended

Shellie and the team @ Elders are exceptional when it comes to selling. They made the whole experience for us so easy and achieved a fantastic result. The girls went above and beyond with communication....

Seller review
Pleasing Process , Successful Outcome
about 3 years ago
Pleasing Process , Successful Outcome

Shellie was upfront from the start. We took her advice when determining the price and communicated with us during the process of selling. We were pleased to have successfully sold with Shellie.

Buyer review
A pleasure to work with.
about 3 years ago
A pleasure to work with.

Shellie made the purchase of our new investment property so easy. She was efficient, knowledgeable and a pleasure to work with.

Buyer review
Australia's best property manager does it again !
about 3 years ago
Australia's best property manager does it again !

We met Shellie two and a half years ago, and we have always found her to be authentic honest and down to earth. She wouldn’t romanticise a property even If she thought it would suit our needs and our goals perfectly she was never pushy; always relaxed, offering us the opportunity to make our own decisions without trying to influence us, those sorts of qualities are rare in any industry selling products and are traits that as a health professional I truly align with. We would recommend Shellie to anyone wanting to buy or sell a property.

193 - 204 of 461
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent