Tony Talarico

Tony Talarico

Senior Property Consultant
  •   4.4   (37 reviews)

About Tony

Tony is a Real Estate Agent. They have 37 verified reviews with an average rating of 4.4 stars

Tony's reviews

  4.4  
Tony has 37 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 6.
Review Tony
over 8 years ago
Reliable agent

Creditability should be built around close communication and quick responses as well as transparency. Would suggest Tony be an agent who has those aspects over the entire process.

over 8 years ago
Market knowedge etc good. Very poor communication following contract signing

From our expression of interest until the signing of the contract on our new property, Tony was great. Unfortunately that's where it ended. The property was tenanted and there seemed to be a breakdown in communication within Carter resulting in the tenant not being given notice as planned. Thankfully the Property Manager was able to find the tenant another suitable property within the required timeframe. There also seemed to be a misunderstanding at Carter regarding the settlement date. Numerous emails to Tony were just handballed to an administrator who continued to provide me with incorrect information and still there was no phone call from Tony. My frustration was exacerbated when I questioned the incorrect settlement date and was then just forwarded the previous email confirming the incorrect settlement date... After my second phone call to the office where I said I was not hanging up until someone spoke with me I was finally put onto someone competent and willing to speak with me who spent 10 minutes phoning 2 solicitors and sorting it out. Well done Katrina. There was no offer of a final inspection before settlement. Beyond that there was no note, letter of of congratulations, gift following purchase or anything of the sort that is just a nice added bonus that all other agencies give. I would not recommend either Tony or Carter to anyone as it seems once the contract is signed, that's the last you'll hear from them.

over 8 years ago
Very good agent

We were in the process of buying our first property and Tony was very helpful along the way with his knowledge and advices. He was also proactive in providing us with any updates and never hesitated to answer our questions. Tony is easy to understand and also easy to talk to. I hope someday we will be able to engage him again. Thank you Tony. Shun & Stephanie

over 8 years ago
Honest Agent

Tony was an excellent agent, understood the market well and what was required to sell my property. He kept me fully updated with potential buyers and feedback , he was friendly and genuine and I would recommend him to sell any property

over 8 years ago
Great Agent

Tony was really helpful throughout the campaign and kept us updated at all stages. He was really friendly and genuinely helpful with what ever questions we had. He arranged extra viewing out of hours and went above and beyond with anything he could. We were lucky enough to be the lucky purchases of the house and after the auction it was a really exciting and fun vibe that Tony and his team created. I would recommend Tony. Thanks again!

over 8 years ago
Integrity and good looks

Hard to find in an agent with integrity, though, seems to be Tony's strength.

Show all 37 reviews

Tony's properties

Tony hasn't had any property sale activity in the last 12 months

EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent