From 73 reviews overall
Darcy Mercieca
Global Property Warners Bay

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Fennell Bay
Median days on market
15 Lake Road Fennell Bay
Reflecting on the Sale of Our Home Selling our home was a significant milestone for our family, and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience than the one we had with our real estate agent. From the moment we met, the agent demonstrated genuine care, professionalism, and an in-depth understanding of the local property market. What stood out most was the agent’s clear communication and willingness to answer all our questions, no matter how big or small. They took the time to walk us through each stage of the process—from preparing the property for sale, arranging inspections, and negotiating with prospective buyers. Their advice on styling and presenting our home really paid off, resulting in strong interest and ultimately an excellent sale price. The agent’s attention to detail and dedication meant that every aspect of the sale ran smoothly. We appreciated their honesty, their prompt responses (even on the weekend), and their ability to keep us informed every step of the way. It truly felt like we were in safe hands throughout the journey. Above all, the agent’s friendly and approachable manner made what could have been a stressful process surprisingly enjoyable. We are grateful for their hard work and would highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. Thank you for making this such a wonderful experience!
From 5 reviews overall

Maya O'Brien
LJ Hooker Lake Macquarie | Toronto
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Fennell Bay
Median days on market
16 Blandford Street Fennell Bay
Selling our mother’s home of 70 years was an emotional and difficult decision, Maya guided us through with such genuine warmth and care. She was always respectful of our situation, quick to respond, and nothing was ever too much trouble. Her communication was clear and compassionate, which made the process so much easier for us. Most importantly, her professionalism and expertise delivered a result at auction that exceeded all expectations. We are so grateful to have had Maya as part of the team.
From 306 reviews overall

Kathleen Matinlassi
Kathleen Matinlassi and Co

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Fennell Bay
Median days on market
10 Blandford Street Fennell Bay
My initial comment is that review systems don't allow me to show a result just short of absolute perfection - in this case the experience was great, good communication, flexibility as we navigated the process and decisions, and a great outcome in the end I think that represented a balanced result for buyers and sellers... I am walking away happy. But being an old-fashioned curmudgeon I would have provided 4.75 stars because nothing in life is perfect. The true test however, if I need to purchase or sell in the future I have my go-to person.
10 Blandford Street Fennell Bay
Kathleen and the team were professional and on point at all times throughout the sale of my home. Selling over winter took extra time but they did not back off or become complacent. I recommend Kathleen and her attentive friendly team to anyone looking to sell a high quality home around Lake Macquarie.
City Top 5
ratemyagent award
Newcastle - Maitland2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Eleebana2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Valentine2026From 371 reviews overall

Peter Shiels
Shiels + Co Property

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Fennell Bay
Median days on market
8 Brougham Avenue Fennell Bay
Pete was excellent to work with. His communication was clear and consistent throughout the entire process. As the property was still tenanted, he initially explored an off-market opportunity to try to secure a sale while minimising disruption, which we really appreciated. Natalie was always prompt in responding to my many questions and kept everything moving smoothly. Ruby was highly efficient in coordinating the details and ensuring nothing was missed. The whole team worked well together and made the process straightforward. I would happily recommend them.
Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Charlestown2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Whitebridge2026