Mystery Bay, NSW, 2546

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

Agencies in Mystery Bay, NSW, 2546

Sorted by most reviews for agencies in Mystery Bay over the past 12 months.

Sort by

Butterfield Property

4.8

From 282 reviews overall

2026 Award Winner

Meet the team

Last 12 months in Mystery Bay

Reviews in Mystery Bay

Sold

For Sale

$570k

Total sales value

$570k

Avg. sale price

5 Casey Crescent Mystery Bay

Verified Review

Excellent Service from start to finish!

Working with Mick was a breath of fresh air. He responded to every inquiry within minutes, kept us updated at every stage. His professionalism shone through in every interaction, and his dedication made us feel like we were his top priority. Thank you Mick & the team at Butterfield Property for A true 5‑star experience from start to finish!

Dale & Roxanne Allison 9 days ago

Ben Bate Real Estate

4.9

From 464 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Mystery Bay

Reviews in Mystery Bay

Sold

For Sale

$890k

Total sales value

$890k

Avg. sale price

6 Emma Close Dalmeny

Verified Review

Helpful and knowledgeable

Belinda was kind and supportive for a first home buyer. Happy to answer all my questions and help me navigate the unknown.

Tonille over 1 year ago

Marshall+Tacheci Real Estate

5.0

From 16 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Mystery Bay

Reviews in Mystery Bay

Sold

For Sale

$980k

Total sales value

$980k

Avg. sale price

51 Murrah Street Bermagui

Verified Review

Great experience dealing with Marshall & Tacheci Real Estate

I had a great experience dealing with Marshall & Tacheci Real Estate. The staff were friendly, helpful and guided us through the purchasing process.

Cate Armstrong over 3 years ago

Whale Coast Realty

4.8

From 556 reviews overall

2026 Award Winner

Meet the team

Last 12 months in Mystery Bay

Reviews in Mystery Bay

Sold

For Sale

N/A

Total sales value

N/A

Avg. sale price

352 Bodalla Park Drive Bodalla

Verified Review

We found Bryan to be highly professional and knowledgeable about the market we were selling in.

Bryan was very knowledgeable, professional and had great communication with us. We really had the dream sale, everything was communicated perfectly from our first meeting to sale. We couldn't recommend Bryan more highly.

Greg & Megan Race & O'Brien 14 days ago

11 The Loop Narooma

Verified Review

An absolute joy to work with from start to finish.

Bryan doesn't muck about. And he knows his stuff. His willingness to go above and beyond just great advice ensured the property was sold at a premium, but fair, value and within weeks of listing. His assistance with the contract, once we'd found a buyer, was also incredibly insightful and saved us additional time, money and fuss.

about 1 month ago

17 John Reilly Street Dalmeny

Verified Review

Friendly and very approachable staff. Always kept me up to date. Would happily use them again

I do not want to do this so please respect my wishes

about 2 months ago

Video

Accolades

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Dalmeny2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Kianga2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Narooma2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

North Narooma2026

LJ Hooker Narooma

4.9

From 124 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Mystery Bay

Reviews in Mystery Bay

Sold

For Sale

N/A

Total sales value

N/A

Avg. sale price

12 Yellowfin Close Narooma

Verified Review

Ease of sale and trust

Great and easily understood communications, trustworthy and down to earth salesman which allayed any doubts for us.

3 months ago

1 - 5 of 5

View nearby Suburbs

Terms & Conditions

Sitemap