Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
255 reviewsacross 29 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Considerate
almost 3 years ago
Considerate

We found Carl to be very helpful and more than willing to oblige us with our resquests prior to settlement. He was extremely attentive to details and always, always responded promtply to any communication. Carl and his team are a credit to the business. I would be always willing to recommend Carl to anyone wishing to do business in this area of Brighton that he knows so well.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Great agent
about 3 years ago
Great agent

He did everything we asked and kept us informed on all stages of the sale great agent

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Carl Calio has our vote!
about 3 years ago
Carl Calio has our vote!

From the first meeting with Carl we noticed how friendly he was in an understated way. His kindly manner without any ego or pressure is what we admired and were comfortable with. He showed a thorough local market knowledge and has intimate knowledge of the history of property sales and purchases. He was easy to communicate with and went over and above to accomodate our expectations. He was able to help with referrals when needed for other services related to the purchase. These were much appreciated. We would highly recommend the Calio & Scott team to anyone wishing to purchase or sell. Because of our satisfaction in the purchase of our new property, we engaged Carl to also sell our existing home. This too has proceeded extremely well and exceeded our expectations in a very timely manner. We vote Calio & Scott number 1.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Smooth dealings for house sale
about 3 years ago
Smooth dealings for house sale

Carl was very professional and knowledgeable of the market. He worked hard to get the best price in the Sale of my house, smoothing out any concerns I had.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Extremely professional
about 3 years ago
Extremely professional

Carl was a pleasure to deal with throughout the whole purchase process. He was friendly, responsive, knowledgeable to the area and accomodating to any pre-purchase requests I had thus making the sale process a lot less stressful. Great professional and community oriented service which was really refreshing.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Great knowledge of the area and market valuation.
about 3 years ago
Great knowledge of the area and market valuation.

Carl is on the money open transparent with all people involved as we have just sold our rental property through Calio & Scott Real-estate nothing was to hard continual updates throughout the whole process great Job Carl and your Team keep up the good work. Regards.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Sold off Market
about 3 years ago
Sold off Market

Home was sold within a week of contacting Carl. Great price and communication throughout the process which continued through to settlement day.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Very positive experience
about 3 years ago
Very positive experience

Carl showed me a few houses prior to settling on one. He was very obliging and had an excellent knowledge of the area. He was patient and quick to respond to communication. I had been looking for 8 months with interactions with many agents. I felt absolutely no pressure. Highly recommend Carl for anyone selling or buying.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Great service and look after you.
about 3 years ago
Great service and look after you.

Great service ,very friendly and willing to help you with any issues. Would recommend them anyone .

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Experience
about 3 years ago
Great Experience

Incredibly helpful & supportive. Highly recommend.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Carl is the best!!
about 3 years ago
Carl is the best!!

Carl is one of the most honest, authentic agents!! We are so pleased to have bought our house with someone who knows the area so well - a true gem! 10 stars!

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional
about 3 years ago
Very professional

Very very professional, educational and showed genuine concern that I was accommodated in every occassion 👍!

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
73 - 84 of 255
© 2026 RateMyAgent