Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
129 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, friendly, honest, supportive, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Service was wonderful...
about 2 years ago
Service was wonderful...

We were completely impressed with both John and Caitlin, their professionalism and customer service is second to none. Highly recommend them.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Customer focused and supportive
about 2 years ago
Customer focused and supportive

John and Caitlin made our experience of selling our family home a positive one. Being out of practice of buying and selling houses, they were supportive of us from the time we made the decision to sell, preparing it to be ready to put onto the market, and then kept us up-to-date with information over the campaign period. We feel very positive with the final result.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptional service and professionalism
about 2 years ago
Exceptional service and professionalism

John and Caitlin were very professional and excellent to deal with. We purchased our home while we were overseas and they made the whole process seamless. They were very contactable, always polite in their manner and answered all our questions in detail.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Very experienced professional
over 2 years ago
Very experienced professional

John has been excellent from start to finish with the sale of our home. He has always kept me informed of proceedings. He is friendly and humorous. He has also been an invaluable advisor in the purchase of a new property and contacts in the industry. I highly recommend his services.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
110% great job
over 2 years ago
110% great job

John is a great agent who really is knowledgeable and also considerate of his clients, both the Vendor and the purchaser. If I ever sell a property I would like him to act for me in this transaction. Great job indeed

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Absolutely the best
over 2 years ago
Absolutely the best

I would Highly recommend John and Caitlin to anybody wanting to sell their property John and Caitlin made me feel comfortable with their knowledge of the current realestate market. John’s and Caitlin’s assistance with selling my property during a very sad and difficult time was greatly appreciated with their kindness and professionalism. John and Caitlin’s wealth of knowledge of realestate along with the understanding of the Adelaide market made for a quick seamless sale of my property. I can highly recommend John and Caitlin to anyone wanting to sell a property based on their professionalism, timeliness of communication (I live interstate). John was always courteous at all times , added to this his wonderful sense of humour made selling a pleasure. I can’t thank John, Caitlin and the team enough for all they did to facilitate the sale of my property!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of our house
over 2 years ago
Seller of our house

I first met John and Caitlin at an open inspection. I was impressed by their professionalism. When the time came to sell my house I met with 4x agents. John and Caitlin were the clear standouts. John has excellent market knowledge, he was professional throughout the process and was always approachable. I can’t recommend John and Caitlin enough. John and Caitlin achieved a great result for our sale and made the selling process as easy as possible.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Communication, Very Flexible
over 2 years ago
Great Communication, Very Flexible

John was great to deal with. Very responsive to our needs, and provided timely responses. Additionally, John and the team were very organised and we felt very comfortable with the whole process. Would highly recommend!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of Property
over 2 years ago
Seller of Property

We highly recommend John! We couldn't fault his exceptional knowledge and professionalism and more so, he is just a really great guy to deal with and we feel exceptionally lucky and thankful. Caitlin, who works with John, was also absolutely awesome to deal with as well... we're very grateful !

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Brilliant service and unwavering dedication
over 2 years ago
Brilliant service and unwavering dedication

John and Caitlin were invaluable in allowing my partner and I to move into our dream home. Despite a number of hurdles along the way, John continued to support us throughout the whole process and managed to support the sale of our home which went comfortably above the original asking price. I cannot recommend John’s service highly enough.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Communicated on any enquiry that we hadin a very professional manner
over 2 years ago
Communicated on any enquiry that we hadin a very professional manner

Right from the start we knew we had picked the right agent as John and Cailin were happy to make our selling experience as less stressful as possible. They followed through all the questions we had and got the best possible sale price for us. John even helped us in securing our new property, even though we were buying through another agent We would reccommend John and Caitlin wholeheartadly to anyone wanting to sell their property.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
37 - 48 of 129
Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
Contact Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent