Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
129 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, friendly, honest, supportive, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Couldn't ask for a better agent!
over 2 years ago
Couldn't ask for a better agent!

John and Caitlin are lovely people, extremely easy to deal with and excellent to communicate with. Majority of our property sale was done remotely and they made the whole process incredibly easy. They have a sound knowledge of the current market and produced a very satisfactory result for us. Thoroughly recommend them!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Seamless and great communication
over 2 years ago
Seamless and great communication

John & Caitlin were fantastic to deal with. We had tenants in the property and they communicated really well with them and made them feel comfortable with people coming through the home. There was a large number of groups that came through, and they did the extra ground work to find out information regarding each offer. Would definitely use again

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Friendly and very professional service
over 2 years ago
Friendly and very professional service

John made the experience of purchasing a home very easy. Very helpful and he made sure everything went smoothly. I cannot recommend him highly enough.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Best Agents Ive worked with in Adelaide!
almost 3 years ago
Best Agents Ive worked with in Adelaide!

John and Caitlin make an excellent team - John with the extensive market & industry experience, and Caitlin with both the in-depth understanding and fresh eyes to access and service a broad audience. Really nice people too. Highly recommend.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
5 Star Agent/Team, 5 Star Service, 5 Star Execution, 5 Star Outcome.
almost 3 years ago
5 Star Agent/Team, 5 Star Service, 5 Star Execution, 5 Star Outcome.

John brings many years of experience to not only the role as your agent but also a truly extensive knowledge of the market and the area. Together now with Caitlin as his associate, they are just a Super team, with John's experience and expertise combined with Caitlin's energy, exubrance and get-it-done-today approach, their combined super powers will ensure the sale of your property is executed with absolute excellence, and the outcome you want. Our most recent sale was challenging in that the property was tenanted and required some love prior to sale; Caitlin and John handled everything while maintaining a productive relationship with the tenant. Marketing on point, negotiations and follow up to perfection - multiple offers and sold within 4 days of the 1 open inspection. That's faultless execution. 5 Stars for the Super team....

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Very Professional Salesperson
almost 3 years ago
Very Professional Salesperson

We were extremely happy with John and Catlin's service. They certainly knew the market and guided us through how the property should be marketed and sold. We had continual feedback how opens went and the property was sold quickly to our expectations.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, Friendly, Supportive, Well-informed Agents
almost 3 years ago
Professional, Friendly, Supportive, Well-informed Agents

Extremely happy with the service that John and Caitlin provided from their knowledgeable advice right from the start, the friendly & caring support all the way through, and a very quick sale once on the market. I am very grateful for their help and highly recommend them to anyone wishing to sell their property.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent knowledge
about 3 years ago
Excellent knowledge

John and Caitlin were warm and friendly. They gave us clear and as it turned out brilliant assessment of Barbara’s likely ease of sale and price

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Incredible
about 3 years ago
Incredible

John and Caitlin were truly exceptional. Their responsiveness was incredible. If they didn’t pick up, they always call back. The delivery of the information was straightforward: present the info and talk about pros/cons/strategy for moving forward. They really treat the situation like pros. Their cool, calm mindset kept our anxiety low and gave us the confidence they would get the job done – and they did! Their promptness, knowledge of the market, strategic mindset, kindness, good energy made a potentially chaotic sale process simple. I’ve already recommended them to two of my good friends. When we are looking to sell again we will not hesitate to call them again for their services.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
No cheap headline from me
about 3 years ago
No cheap headline from me

John is a great guy but he has oñe small fault. He didn't laugh at my jokes hard enough ! Seriously though thanks for your help and good wishes. You've made everything smooth for me including the plumbing so you have my deep appreciation . And thanks for the lovely pressy. Love and regards Trev. PS Italian coffee constantly available

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Everard Park
about 3 years ago
Everard Park

To whom it may concern, John Muscat and Caitlin Clarke are the team from GaryJSmith of Glenelg SA who auctioned my Parent’s home recently. John and Caitlin were superb. Confident that I had procured the services of top Agents and that my unit would soon find a new owner, John and Caitlin handled all details unobtrusively and with the highest level of professionalism They are extremely passionate about great customer service, market knowledge and effecting the best possible outcome. To my good fortune they sold my property after only one open day! John and Caitlin I have nothing but the highest praise and look forward to the future, with many thanks to you always. Kind regards, Magi

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Thank you John!
about 3 years ago
Thank you John!

I appreciated that John is an honest, no-nonsense agent that doesn't beat around the bush (no slimyness here!). He's willing to choose the best option for the seller, not necessarily the easiest option for himself. He kept me well informed and reassured throughout the process. I know he was working very hard in the background and he got us a fantastic result for our house. Thank you very much to John and Caitlin!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
49 - 60 of 129
Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
Contact Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent