Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
144 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, local expert, friendly, well-prepared, responsive, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Landlord review
Excellent!
about 1 year ago
Excellent!

I had the pleasure of working with Emma at McGrath to lease out my apartment, and I couldn’t be more impressed with her service. From start to finish, she was incredibly responsive, always keeping me updated and answering any questions promptly. Her communication was clear, concise, and professional, making the entire process seamless. Emma’s expertise and dedication really stood out, and I felt confident every step of the way. I highly recommend Emma to anyone looking for top-notch real estate services. She truly goes above and beyond!

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Professional Agent!!
over 1 year ago
Professional Agent!!

Emma has taken over managing over rental property, she is professional, communicates well and is really trustworthy and transparent. We highly recommend her. Landlords (Avalon Apartment).

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Professional Service
over 1 year ago
Professional Service

McGrath were very helpful in finding a suitable tenant for my property. Communication could be improved, especially in relation to breakdown of fees as agreed in the agency agreement. All communication is via email, and limited interaction by phone. Emails are easily missed and would prefer a regular phone call to keep me updated on the tenant inspections, condition of my property, and property related expenses

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Prompt, helpful, decisive
over 1 year ago
Prompt, helpful, decisive

Prompt, helpful, decisive says it all. We ared currently living overseas, our tenants unexpectedly moved out, and within what felt like just a couple of weeks, with a new agency, we had new tenants sorted, lease fees and arrangements agreed and the property handover completed

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
So glad to have changed agencies
over 2 years ago
So glad to have changed agencies

After having a less than satisfactory experience with a another large Northern Beaches agency, and finding I was doing a lot of the run around, yet being charged higher rates for a ‘superior’ service, it was a relief to switch to McGrath Avalon. Caitlin, Stefano, and their team are super organised, on the ball, and happy to handle anything that arises. I feel really peaceful knowing they’re managing things for me.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Dedicated and responsive property manager
over 2 years ago
Dedicated and responsive property manager

Caitlin Capp has been managing our property for over 10 years and has consistently provided an excellent and professional service. We would not go anywhere else for property management.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Highly Recommend
over 2 years ago
Highly Recommend

I would highly recommend Caitlin. She is friendly, professional, responsive & a clear communicator. The landlord/agent relationship can be somewhat transactional however that is not the case with Caitlin, her actions show she has a genuine interest in delivering a high-quality service to both the landlord and their tenant. She is an asset to the McGrath Pittwater office and a pleasure to deal with.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Responsive and professional
over 2 years ago
Responsive and professional

Caitlin Capp and all at Mcgrath have been professional and responsive.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Highly Recommend
over 2 years ago
Highly Recommend

Caitlin and the team have been amazing finding the perfect tenants over the last 4 years. Spot on market knowledge and always very professional in their approach to finding the best tenant to suit my property. Helpful and quick to respond.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Friendly and efficient
over 2 years ago
Friendly and efficient

I bought my unit through Adrian at Pittwater McGrath and have been renting out the unit through Caitlin at the same agency. Adrian, Caitlin and her team have been fantastic, very efficient, knowledgeable, professional and helpful and totally on the ball. I can highly recommend their services.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Great team
over 2 years ago
Great team

Caitlin and her team at McGrath were great to deal with. They were generous with their time, highly communicative and helpful, such nice people whom were also very professional. I can see why Caitlin was recommended to me in the first place. Thank you for everything

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Could not be more happier with my experience with McGrath
over 2 years ago
Could not be more happier with my experience with McGrath

Caitlin and her team from McGrath Avalon have been the best agent I have been with . They just found me the perfect Tennant , which I am so happy with. Caitlin and her team are so helpful, professional and reliable, nothing is ever a bother. Emails and calls always returned same day if not immediately. I am happy to say that they are literally my dream real estate agency. Caitlin is an amazing agent, she really cares, is very experienced and super nice. She also was able to connect me with a selection of very good and affordable handymen McGrath is using (when needed for my property! ) I can highly recommend her as a property agent, she goes above and beyond and is also a lovely person;) Verified by RateMyAgent

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
1 - 12 of 144
© 2026 RateMyAgent