Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1241 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
 I couldn’t recommend her highly enough
12 months ago
I couldn’t recommend her highly enough

I was selling my house after I had a stroke and brain injury. I could not have had better support for me than Su and her team. They made something that was very daunting to me, easy and pleasurable. They communicated with me and my family continuously and answered every question and call and had tremendous patience with me and my situation. Su and her team always treated my house with care. Su got me a great result for my property and I couldn’t recommend her highly enough.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (360 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a house in Byron Bay, NSW
12 months ago
Seller of a house in Byron Bay, NSW

Tara is the most amazing real estate agent to engage to sell your property. Tara’s integrity, credibility, compassion, support and warmth, and her outstanding ability to sell properties for her clients in a short period of time. and achieve unrivalled results are unsurpassed. Due to Tara’s contemporary approach to selling properties by being an accomplished digital selling agent combined with genuine warm connections, Tara achieves positive outcomes for her sellers and buyers. Thank you Tara!

Tara Torkkola

Tara Torkkola

  4.9   (295 reviews)
Seller review
My experience with Su and her team was exceptional
12 months ago
My experience with Su and her team was exceptional

My experience with Su and her team was exceptional. In my opinion and experience, they went above and beyond to sell the property that needed a special buyer. At all times I was kept well informed, as I lived in a different state and all communication was remote. I'd certainly recommend Su and her team to anyone wishing for a professional, experienced agent.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (360 reviews)
Buyer review
Buyer of a house in The Channon, NSW
12 months ago
Buyer of a house in The Channon, NSW

Had a great experience buying our property through Sharon. Honest, transparent, friendly and personable she was great to deal with and gave us a lot of confidence that our genuine interest in the property was relayed honestly to the vendors. Sharon was thorough and prompt in communication especially around queries about the property, expectations and timelines. Sharon's professionalism and great communication helped make the process smooth and as stress free as possible.

Sharon McInnes

Sharon McInnes

  4.8   (82 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW
12 months ago
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW

Sally treated the property with enthusiasm and honing in on the specific buyers who would be interested in it. Your communication was brilliant (we were never left wondering what was happening) and even more, we really appreciated being able to directly ask for your advice on next steps. We felt confident your recommendations were an accurate take on the market conditions/value.

Sally Green

Sally Green

  4.8   (16 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW
about 1 year ago
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW

Sally and jasmin were amazing with there professional approach, couldn't recommend any higher. It was a great experience selling my house with Sally, the communication about everything was above and beyond i knew exactly what was happening everyday

Sally Green

Sally Green

  4.8   (16 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW
about 1 year ago
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW

Sally was very responsive and kept me up to date with everything. She worked very hard to get us the offer that we were comfortable with.

Sally Green

Sally Green

  4.8   (16 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a house in Dunoon, NSW
about 1 year ago
Seller of a house in Dunoon, NSW

From the very beginning, Sharon listened with presence, patience, and unwavering support. She held the sale of my property with honesty and grounded, intuitive guidance. Selling a home is not just a transaction—it’s a transition—and Sharon honoured that with integrity & kindness every step of the way. Thank you, Sharon, for making this experience one of trust, ease, and grace—you restored my faith in the process.

Sharon McInnes

Sharon McInnes

  4.8   (82 reviews)
Buyer review
Buyer of House
about 1 year ago
Buyer of House

Oliver was friendly, professional, and made the home-buying process easy. Highly recommend!

Oliver Aldridge

Oliver Aldridge

  4.9   (57 reviews)
Seller review
We would happily recommend Su to sell your property.
about 1 year ago
We would happily recommend Su to sell your property.

Su was extremely helpful and kept us updated and informed throughout the whole process. She went over and above to help us sell our property. We would happily recommend Su to sell your property.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (360 reviews)
Buyer review
Thanks to Su Reynolds integrity, attention to detail and commitment
about 1 year ago
Thanks to Su Reynolds integrity, attention to detail and commitment

I recently purchased a rural property in the Byron Shire with the assistance of Su Reynolds and First National Byron and I was very pleased with the experience. From the very first on-site inspection with Anna Gilham and 2nd inspection with Su to the final settlement, Su provided a level of service that was professional and genuinely honest, accurate and accommodating from start to finish. Su Reynolds was instrumental in helping me secure the property at a fair and reasonable price and ensure that everything progressed smoothly. We were granted early access to the property for pre-emptive transfer of work tools and the settlement took place precisely on the day on which it was scheduled. Communication was always clear and opportune at every stage and I was felt that my best interests and the interests of the vendor were both being looked after equally well. Thanks to Su Reynolds integrity, attention to detail and commitment to service, the experience was very straightforward and stress free. I would highly recommend Su Reynolds and First National Byron to anyone seeking a trustworthy, honest and dedicated real estate agency.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (360 reviews)
61 - 72 of 1,241
© 2026 RateMyAgent