Our profile

Our reviews

  4.7  
283 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, friendly, supportive, honest, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent service and very professional
over 8 years ago
Excellent service and very professional

We engaged Andrew for the sale of our property. Andrew's knowledge of the market is excellent and the plan to sell was well thought out. He kept us informed all the way through the sale process negotiated a great outcome with the sale. Throughly recommend Andrew

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Seller review
Reliable and Trustworthy???
over 8 years ago
Reliable and Trustworthy???

We found Andrew to be reliable, honest and trustworthy agent when selling our home up until the time the contract was signed. We then felt he didn't feel he was responsible for deposit collection and miss informed us when asked was the deposit paid. We also feel Andrew would have been comfortable with selling the property at a lower price more than $10,000 lower than the actual selling price. The agent failed in receiving of deposits which resulted in an after auction contract being lost. The home had to be re-advertised when another purchaser was found again the deposit wasn't fully paid as per contract. We the sellers followed up with Andrew three times and the deposit still was not fully paid until another agent took over (seemed like Andrew had lost interest) and the purchasers were advised legally that they were in default for not paying deposit as required on the contract. The purchasers fully paid the deposit two weeks before settlement. In essence the house was sold twice because deposits were not received properly. When we followed up with the second agent we were told that Agents are not debt collectors, no they are not, but they are the receiving point of deposits. We have bought and sold previously with other agents and never had these issues. What do you think?

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent
over 8 years ago
Great Agent

Andrew Cruickshank really knew what he was talking about. Friendly, approachable and no BS! Delivered what he promised and sold my house in 2 weeks at a higher than asking price. Great service and can highly recommend him

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Buyer review
Mr Salvatore & Lilly Arancio
over 8 years ago
Mr Salvatore & Lilly Arancio

Lachlan was very helpfull to help us in purchasing the property in 12 Balme Court, Hoppers Crossing, Well manned, Always available, didn't put any pressure in making a decision.

Rob Westwood

Rob Westwood

  4.6   (129 reviews)
Seller review
Enthusiastic Agent
over 8 years ago
Enthusiastic Agent

Rob offered us guidance in preparing our family home for sale. He was supportive and assisted our agent Eugene with promotion of our home during our pre auction campaign. He assisted us to set a realistic reserve and our house was sold successfully at auction due to the interest that Rob, Eugene and the team were able to develop during the sales campaign.

Rob Westwood

Rob Westwood

  4.6   (129 reviews)
Seller review
Made our sale a breeze!
over 8 years ago
Made our sale a breeze!

This was the first time we’ve gone through the experience of selling a house and Rob and his team made it an unbelievably easy process! We were approached with confidence and professionalism from start to finish and would recommend them to everyone. They put our needs and wants first and we’re even really polite when I would call just to query thing because of my nativity of everything. Thankyou guys!

Rob Westwood

Rob Westwood

  4.6   (129 reviews)
Seller review
Sale of 12 Mayfair St Wyndham Vale
over 8 years ago
Sale of 12 Mayfair St Wyndham Vale

Would like to thank both Andrew and Rachael Kapitelli on the professional way they carried out the sale and managed the property while being let. Regards Carole and John McFarlane

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic communication
over 8 years ago
Fantastic communication

Andrew kept us updated weekly. And guided us with the best possible outcome.we felt he had our best interest in mind at all times

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Seller review
Offers within 2 weeks and sold within 30 Days
over 8 years ago
Offers within 2 weeks and sold within 30 Days

Truthfully speaking I didn't think Andrew would be able to sell our home over the reserve and tight timeframe given to him. Initially it was just to get a feel for the market. He absolutely proved me wrong with offers flowing in within 2 weeks and home sold under 30 days. Congratulations on a great job Andrew!! :-) You definitely threw us off guard (in a god way)

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Seller review
Amazing agent
over 8 years ago
Amazing agent

We would like to thank Andrew for all his work throughout our sale. The communication was great and we were kept up to date with everything. Would highly recommend, whatever he promised he certainly delievered!

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Agent. Highly Recomended
over 8 years ago
Great Agent. Highly Recomended

I had a fantastic experience using Andrew from First National. He was friendly face after dealing with lots of dodgy real estate agents in the area asking me for unconditional offers. Andrew was honest, fair and upfront. I would definitely use him again.

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
Seller review
Wonderful agent
over 8 years ago
Wonderful agent

Communion was great I would highly recommend Andrew

Andrew Cruickshank

Andrew Cruickshank

  4.6   (125 reviews)
145 - 156 of 283
© 2026 RateMyAgent