Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
132 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, friendly, honest, supportive, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
No cheap headline from me
about 3 years ago
No cheap headline from me

John is a great guy but he has oñe small fault. He didn't laugh at my jokes hard enough ! Seriously though thanks for your help and good wishes. You've made everything smooth for me including the plumbing so you have my deep appreciation . And thanks for the lovely pressy. Love and regards Trev. PS Italian coffee constantly available

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
Everard Park
about 3 years ago
Everard Park

To whom it may concern, John Muscat and Caitlin Clarke are the team from GaryJSmith of Glenelg SA who auctioned my Parent’s home recently. John and Caitlin were superb. Confident that I had procured the services of top Agents and that my unit would soon find a new owner, John and Caitlin handled all details unobtrusively and with the highest level of professionalism They are extremely passionate about great customer service, market knowledge and effecting the best possible outcome. To my good fortune they sold my property after only one open day! John and Caitlin I have nothing but the highest praise and look forward to the future, with many thanks to you always. Kind regards, Magi

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
Thank you John!
over 3 years ago
Thank you John!

I appreciated that John is an honest, no-nonsense agent that doesn't beat around the bush (no slimyness here!). He's willing to choose the best option for the seller, not necessarily the easiest option for himself. He kept me well informed and reassured throughout the process. I know he was working very hard in the background and he got us a fantastic result for our house. Thank you very much to John and Caitlin!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Buyer review
First home buyer
over 3 years ago
First home buyer

John was diligent, courteous and responsive. He made the experience of buying my first home stress-free and exciting. It was a pleasure, thanks John!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
Brilliant Honest Helpful
over 3 years ago
Brilliant Honest Helpful

John and Catlin we nothing short of "brilliant". Very easy to deal with, honest, no smoke and mirrors. They just got on with the job, whilst keeping us informed throughout the sale process. We would have no hesitations in recommending them to sell your property.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing experience
over 3 years ago
Amazing experience

They were professional, friendly and nice to deal with. From the open inspection to buying the house it was an easy non pushy experience with all the staff having a really extensive knowledge of the real estate market . We were treated very well and all questions enquires were dealt with in a very timely professional matter. The whole transaction was smooth and communicated well.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic result!
over 3 years ago
Fantastic result!

John and Caitie were fantastic! They kept us well informed throughout the whole process and were able to achieve us a price that was far beyond our expectations. We could not be happier with their services.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
EXCEPTIONAL
over 3 years ago
EXCEPTIONAL

Some 12 years ago, I purchased an apartment in Glenelg marketed by Gary Smith real estate, I have now sold the apartment again through Gary Smith and could not speak highly enough of the professionalism and integrity of the people that handled the sale. - John Muscat and Caitlin . They achieved an excellent result, given some difficult circumstances beyond their control. I They have an excellent knowledge of the market and the Glenelg area, and I Highly recommend their service.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
Friendly, enthusiastic and very Professional Agent
almost 4 years ago
Friendly, enthusiastic and very Professional Agent

This is the second time we have dealt with John as a Real Estate agent. We purchased our current home from him several years ago and found him to be very professional and friendly. We therefore didn't hesitate to contact John when considering selling our investment property. His advice , guidance, professional approach and sale skills allowed us to secure a sale exceeding our expectations. John and Caitlin are a formidable team providing excellent customer service, advice and most importantly they deliver on promises. We have no hesitation in recommending their services. Thankyou guys Susie and Peter Snedden

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent knowledge and professional service by John
almost 4 years ago
Excellent knowledge and professional service by John

John went above and beyond to make the selling process as stress free as possible. His attention to detail and keeping us informed at all times was excellent. Knowledge and advise was exemplary. Would highly recommend his professional service to all.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
Seller review
Great experience
almost 4 years ago
Great experience

John was always professional and easy to communicate with. Will use him again if I have to sell another property.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (233 reviews)
61 - 72 of 132
Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
Contact Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent