Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
152 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Seamless & Effortless Sale
10 months ago
Seamless & Effortless Sale

We recently had the pleasure of selling our home with Toni, and the entire experience exceeded our expectations. From the outset, Toni coordinated every detail, from organising beautiful coastal-inspired styling and furnishings to recommending and liaising with a local conveyancer, ensuring the process was seamless from start to finish. Her honest and realistic appraisal of our property set the foundation for a very successful campaign. Toni’s professionalism was evident at every stage – she managed inspections with ease, kept us fully informed of buyer interest, and executed a broad-reaching sales strategy that delivered a fantastic result. Remarkably, our property sold after just one open home. The whole experience was effortless, stress-free, and incredibly well managed. Toni’s integrity, professionalism, and “nothing is ever too much trouble” approach truly set her apart. We cannot recommend Toni highly enough to anyone considering selling their home.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Agent Extraordinaire!
10 months ago
Agent Extraordinaire!

Toni was fantastic from start to sale. Her attention to detail was exceptional and she always kept me informed and worked very hard to get the perfect sale for me. I could not be happier than the experience I had, highest of recommendations and would definitely use Toni again. 🌟

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding
10 months ago
Outstanding

I had the absolute pleasure of buying my dream home from Toni. Her direction, action and follow up was second to none. I have dealt with many realestate agents over the years and valued Toni’s honest, down to earth approach which made the whole experience a breeze and a joy. Toni goes above and beyond any expectations that I ever had of a real estate agent. The agent responsible for selling my property elsewhere was unable to sell it in six weeks so I handed it to Toni who sold it in two weeks. Exceptional work. If you want someone who can do the job with a friendly smile and a fabulous work ethic, l couldn’t recommend her more highly! I will only sell and buy through Toni as trust and honesty in this industry is paramount.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Number one agent on the Mornington
10 months ago
Number one agent on the Mornington

Toni has been an absolute legend from start to finish when she sold our house. Toni was the most positive, hardworking and thoughtful agent we have ever had. Nothing is ever a problem, she is professional, knowledgeable and achieved a great result. Toni really does stand out above the rest and we would definitely recommend Toni to sell your house and make it an enjoyable time.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent communicator!
11 months ago
Excellent communicator!

Dealing with Toni has been terrific. Updates all the time what’s going on with our property. Very patient with our probate affairs. Couldn’t fault her.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Brilliant!
12 months ago
Brilliant!

We were so happy we chose Rachael to sell our house. She was very knowledgeable, extremely professional and we are really pleased with the outcome. Everything went very smoothly and we found the whole process very easy. Thank you Rachael!

Rachael Holman

Rachael Holman

  5   (24 reviews)
Seller review
Best Agent Perfect Purchaser Happy Vendors
about 1 year ago
Best Agent Perfect Purchaser Happy Vendors

From our initial meeting with Toni we felt she had a great handle on the local Market & most importantly, understood our motivations & emotional connection to our property. Finding the “right” purchaser was important. Toni did an amazing job of negotiating the best possible outcome for all parties! We would highly recommend Toni to anyone looking to sell in the Rye area.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Contact/feedback, contact/feedback, contact/feedback, what else could a seller want..
about 1 year ago
Contact/feedback, contact/feedback, contact/feedback, what else could a seller want..

Toni listens and gives no b......t feedback. Says it as it is. You would think Toni is a family friend, actually, she is now. Keeps you in the loop all the way, what a breath of fresh air compared to some other agents. Very professional. I am sure the purchaser would feel the same way. Thanks Toni, great stuff. Geoff / Emily

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Toni is a superstar!
about 1 year ago
Toni is a superstar!

We had the pleasure of purchasing a property through Toni as the selling agent and were so impressed that we didn't hesitate to engage her to sell our own home. Throughout the entire process, she conducted herself with the utmost professionalism, kept us well-informed at every stage, and brought a warm, reassuring presence that helped ease the stress of selling. Toni made what is a stressful and challenging time feel smooth, enjoyable and even exciting! We highly recommend her.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Good experience
about 1 year ago
Good experience

Very professional and a great deal of knowledge about the property market.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
A true professional, highly motivated and great to have a laugh with!
about 1 year ago
A true professional, highly motivated and great to have a laugh with!

Toni was a hidden gem! Our journey included two previous agents and a long slog due to market changes, interest rate hikes and many other factors. We hit jackpot with Toni. Her professionalism, market knowledge and determination got the sale done. Toni is a great communicator and a delight to deal with. We had many laughs along the way, we felt at ease with her steering the ship and overcoming obstacles by thinking outside of the box. We strongly recommend Toni for your property journey.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
A genuine local agent, honest advice, aways available, professional and extremely personable.
about 1 year ago
A genuine local agent, honest advice, aways available, professional and extremely personable.

It has been such a privilege to have the support and guidance of Toni when selling my first home. This was a huge decision and was not made lightly. Toni took the time to explain the process. She showed me comparisons on the market, reflecting the location, cost, and demands. Toni also introduced me to a financial advisor and a mortgage broker. Her referrals were also fantastic, supportive, and down to earth. We originally planned for an auction. However, due to uncontrollable cirstimances, we decided on an offer that I was incredibly pleased with. I am very satisfied with the outcome. I was so excited to sign the paperwork that she offered to drop my house to finalise the paperwork that evening of the sale. The process was made so easy for me, it's has been a very personalised and memorable experience for me. Toni is currently assisting me in finding my new home, I'm extremely excited, and so far, she is on point with all the features, requirements, and most of all, the price point that I am after. I look forward to another exciting and successful sale with Toni.

Toni Katsivelas

Toni Katsivelas

  5   (52 reviews)
25 - 36 of 152
© 2026 RateMyAgent