Our profile

Our reviews

  4.8  
283 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Excellent communicator with deep understanding of the local market
3 days ago
Excellent communicator with deep understanding of the local market

We had a fantastic experience selling our home in Bermagui. From start to finish, Mel was clear, concise, attentive and genuinely friendly to work with. She really listened to our wants and needs and approached the sale with thoughtful consideration and care. We always felt informed, supported and confident throughout the process. We’re so grateful for her guidance and would happily recommend her to anyone selling their home.

Melisa Ashton

Melisa Ashton

  5   (57 reviews)
Buyer review
Happy outcome
15 days ago
Happy outcome

Can’t thank Mick and Mel enough for their continued support over the past few months of selling ours and eventually buying our forever home. Their communication, guidance, and support throughout the whole process made everything so much easier for us. Both homes managed to settle on the same day, which was a great outcome for us. Thank you so much ☺️

Mick Butterfield

Mick Butterfield

  4.8   (226 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Service from start to finish!
20 days ago
Excellent Service from start to finish!

Working with Mick was a breath of fresh air. He responded to every inquiry within minutes, kept us updated at every stage. His professionalism shone through in every interaction, and his dedication made us feel like we were his top priority. Thank you Mick & the team at Butterfield Property for A true 5‑star experience from start to finish!

Mick Butterfield

Mick Butterfield

  4.8   (226 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent negotiation skills, excellent Agent to deal with
about 1 month ago
Excellent negotiation skills, excellent Agent to deal with

I loved purchasing my home, with Melisa Aston. Friendly, professional, Melisa knows the area really well, that kind of knowledge is priceless. I would 💯 recommend Melisa and the team at Butterfield real estate Bermagui to anyone, buying, selling or leasing. Thank you Melisa. Goldie

Melisa Ashton

Melisa Ashton

  5   (57 reviews)
Seller review
Very responsive and prompt. All staff were professional.
about 1 month ago
Very responsive and prompt. All staff were professional.

Amount of interest indicated property could have been valued higher. Initially problems with potential buyers dropping out after making commitment caused concern. Perhaps a more robust vetting process could have been used? When the eventual buyer was found, the buyer wanted to make a commitment on their terms, we felt that our position as vendors should have been better considered.

Mick Butterfield

Mick Butterfield

  4.8   (226 reviews)
Seller review
Great job team Butterfield
about 1 month ago
Great job team Butterfield

Unlike other agents, Mick Butterfield truly cared about my unique situation. Butterfield customer service was unmatched, tailoring their search to fit my lifestyle and budget. If you’re looking for a good real estate experience look no further—this is the agent for you!” Also would recommend first home buyers to consider Butterfield as Micks knowledge on how to get into the market was something to pass along! Great work.

Mick Butterfield

Mick Butterfield

  4.8   (226 reviews)
Buyer review
Easy professionalism
2 months ago
Easy professionalism

Mick did an all round good job, great communication and commitment

Mick Butterfield

Mick Butterfield

  4.8   (226 reviews)
Seller review
Mel is highly responsive & very professional
3 months ago
Mel is highly responsive & very professional

From the get go Mel & her team were insightful & knowledgeable of current markets trends, timing of campaign & price guide. During the selling period Mel kept us informed & provided advice to support us during the selling process. Would highly recommend Butterfield team to others.

Melisa Ashton

Melisa Ashton

  5   (57 reviews)
Buyer review
very knowledable on details of the property
4 months ago
very knowledable on details of the property

Mel was very helpful and went the extra mile to help. Could not fault her professionalism and service.

Melisa Ashton

Melisa Ashton

  5   (57 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional service from start to finish – Mel made selling simple and stress-free
5 months ago
Exceptional service from start to finish – Mel made selling simple and stress-free

Selling our home could have been stressful, but Mel and the entire Butterfield Property team made it an absolute breeze! From day one, Mel was warm, approachable, and completely focused on making the process as smooth as possible. She was always quick to respond to our questions, no matter how small, and explained everything clearly so we felt confident every step of the way. Mel’s local knowledge was a game-changer. She gave us great advice on pricing and presentation, and her insights helped us attract the right buyers quickly. What really stood out was how people-focused she is. Mel genuinely cared about our experience and made sure we felt supported throughout. It never felt rushed or transactional, it felt like working with someone who truly wanted the best outcome for us and we couldn’t be happier. If you’re looking for an agent who’s knowledgeable, responsive, and backed by an amazing team, we can’t recommend Mel and Butterfield Property highly enough!

Melisa Ashton

Melisa Ashton

  5   (57 reviews)
Seller review
Happy client.
5 months ago
Happy client.

Very happy dealing with Mick and the team. The sale process was very simple and without complication. Thanks Mick.

Mick Butterfield

Mick Butterfield

  4.8   (226 reviews)
1 - 12 of 283
© 2026 RateMyAgent