Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
981 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Excellent Communicator
about 1 month ago
Excellent Communicator

Throughout the selling process Brent was very professional demonstrating excellent communication skills and absolute commitment to selling my house for my desired price. He had a high work ethic and always responded to messages in a timely manner. My house was sold in two weeks and I couldn’t have been happier with Brent and McCartney’s Real Estate

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Genuine Commitment
2 months ago
Genuine Commitment

From our very first interaction Brent demonstrated professionalism, deep market knowledge and a genuine commitment to helping us achieve the best possible outcome. His communication was always prompt, clear and honest. I highly recommend Brent to anyone looking to buy or sell a property on the Surf Coast.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Professional & Transparent
4 months ago
Professional & Transparent

Brent was great to work with; he understood the market really well and ensured we got the right price. Both my wife and I found Brent very professional and transparent with the process and with dealings on our behalf.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding Local Knowledge
4 months ago
Outstanding Local Knowledge

Their knowledge of the market was outstanding. There are always many houses for Sale in Torquay which is a challenge for the seller and Agents. Brent always kept us informed of what was happening in the area, and advised us on one occasion to slightly change the price which resulted in a win for all. I was so surprised how Brent and Matt operated as they were always in touch with us. Even when Brent was on holidays he did not hesitate to pick up the phone to give us advise.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Keeping it Cool!
4 months ago
Keeping it Cool!

Brent was the really cool calm head you need when selling real estate. During the process, Brent endured a tough situation, but was still there to help pull together a great deal. He knows Torquay, who is looking and who will buy your home. He negotiated a great deal, that made us all happy.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional service from Tim Carson and the McCartney Real Estate team.
5 months ago
Exceptional service from Tim Carson and the McCartney Real Estate team.

From our first meeting with Tim Carson we found him to be extremely knowledgeable, exceedingly professional, enthusiastic and approachable. Throughout the whole sale process, Tim was continually communicating and consulting. Tim and his helpful colleagues proved that we had made the right choice of using McCartney Real Estate Torquay to sell our property. We express our gratitude to Tim.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptional local knowledge
6 months ago
Exceptional local knowledge

Tim brings a wealth of experience and local knowledge to the surf coast property market. A fantastic communicator and extremely diligent during the sales campaign, I have been very pleased to both sell and purchase with Tim and the team at McCartney Real Estate.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Krystin was an absolute pleasure to deal with. The experience was professional, personal and valued.
6 months ago
Krystin was an absolute pleasure to deal with. The experience was professional, personal and valued.

Considering I did not give prior notice, Krystin made herself available to show the property to me giving me an informative and detailed viewing without me feeling at all pressured for not making a prior appointment. I have since made further requests for access and to view the property and Krystin has willingly made herself available to accommodate me. Krystin has also been able to provide prompt answers to any questions and requests I have put forward.

Krystin Trewin

Krystin Trewin

  5   (1 review)
Seller review
Great agent
6 months ago
Great agent

We couldn’t be happier with the service Tim provided. From start to finish, he kept us well informed, communicated clearly, and handled everything with honesty and professionalism. His local knowledge led to a great result for our family and we would highly recommend Tim to anyone looking for a reliable and skilled real estate agent. Thanks Tim!

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Stress free experience
6 months ago
Stress free experience

Tim was fantastic. Was a seamless experience he was just honest we made the process so easy. Highly recommend

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Property Expert and Customer Focused
6 months ago
Property Expert and Customer Focused

Geoff Bennet provided us with a professional plan and package that helped sell our home. His professionalism and knowledge of the Torquay market was reassuring and provided us with the confidence of a positive outcome. Geoff Bennet is someone we highly recommend and trust.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
1 - 12 of 981
© 2026 RateMyAgent