Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
990 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Taking The Stress Away
11 days ago
Taking The Stress Away

We have now sold our second property through Brent Hartigan at McCartney Real Estate, and we couldn’t be happier with his service. Brent makes the whole process easy. He is honest, upfront, hardworking and always keeps you informed. Selling a property can be stressful, but Brent takes a lot of that stress away and makes the experience as smooth as possible. We would happily recommend Brent to anyone looking to sell their property.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (39 reviews)
Seller review
Knowledge, Postivity and Communication
18 days ago
Knowledge, Postivity and Communication

I couldnt have asked for more with Krystin. Her knowledge, positivity and communication were fabulous. She was always accessible and prompt with return phone calls. I admire her patience in this market.

Krystin Trewin

Krystin Trewin

  5   (6 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Advice and Clear Communication
18 days ago
Excellent Advice and Clear Communication

A huge thank you for helping us sell our house, including your excellent advice, handling buyers, clear communication, and always keeping everything on track. We were pleased to appoint Matt, yourself and your team as our agents to sell our home.

Krystin Trewin

Krystin Trewin

  5   (6 reviews)
Seller review
Great Communication, Efficient and Personable
about 1 month ago
Great Communication, Efficient and Personable

Krystin was very professional over the course of the sale, she knows the Torquay market very well. Great communication, efficient and personable. An honest, no nonsense agent who let us know how offers were going promptly even over the weekends, we recommend Krystin and the McCartney team.

Krystin Trewin

Krystin Trewin

  5   (6 reviews)
Seller review
Persistence Pays
about 2 months ago
Persistence Pays

Brent managed the sale of my house in a difficult market. He was persistent, kept me informed at all times and was great to deal with. I am very pleased with the result and highly recommend him.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (39 reviews)
Seller review
Genuine and Authentic Agent
2 months ago
Genuine and Authentic Agent

Easily the most genuine and authentic agent I have dealt with over many sales of properties. She was honest and accurate with the property value, and managed to get that value and more! I received frequent updates on market movement as well as thorough feedback after every open in regard to the numbers through and whether here was genuine interest or not. Krystin made a potentially stressful process easy and stress free. Couldn’t be happier…would definitely recommend! Thanks so much Krystin

Krystin Trewin

Krystin Trewin

  5   (6 reviews)
Seller review
Honest and Upfront
2 months ago
Honest and Upfront

Right from day one Krystin Trewin was honest and upfront about valuations and costings, never tried to over value to get the listing and turned out to be spot on with sale price as valued. I got a phone call from Krystin after every inspection outlining the people that attended and was kept fully informed of everything going on. Krystin organised the staging of the property, the garden maintenance and just made the whole process super easy. Fantastic job Krystin - Thank You!

Krystin Trewin

Krystin Trewin

  5   (6 reviews)
Buyer review
Went Above and Beyond
3 months ago
Went Above and Beyond

Brent and the team were fantastic throughout the purchase of our property. His communication was spot on and went above and beyond what was required. We highly recommend Brent for either buying or selling!

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (39 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Communicator
4 months ago
Excellent Communicator

Throughout the selling process Brent was very professional demonstrating excellent communication skills and absolute commitment to selling my house for my desired price. He had a high work ethic and always responded to messages in a timely manner. My house was sold in two weeks and I couldn’t have been happier with Brent and McCartney’s Real Estate

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (39 reviews)
Buyer review
6 Parker Street, Torquay
5 months ago
6 Parker Street, Torquay

We had a great experience buying from Matt at McCartney in Torquay. He was very knowledgable about the property and the local area and facilitated multiple inspections and phone calls very patiently. We didn't feel pressured or rushed through the process. The final processes of buying were super smooth, with minimal admin. Matt is a super pleasant real estate agent who we felt very comfortable navigating the process of first home ownership with. Thanks Matt!

Matt Kavanagh

Matt Kavanagh

  5   (2 reviews)
Seller review
Genuine Commitment
6 months ago
Genuine Commitment

From our very first interaction Brent demonstrated professionalism, deep market knowledge and a genuine commitment to helping us achieve the best possible outcome. His communication was always prompt, clear and honest. I highly recommend Brent to anyone looking to buy or sell a property on the Surf Coast.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (39 reviews)
Seller review
Professional & Transparent
7 months ago
Professional & Transparent

Brent was great to work with; he understood the market really well and ensured we got the right price. Both my wife and I found Brent very professional and transparent with the process and with dealings on our behalf.

Brent Hartigan

Brent Hartigan

  4.7   (39 reviews)
1 - 12 of 990
© 2026 RateMyAgent