Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
735 reviewsacross 49 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, responsive, supportive, reliable, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent
over 2 years ago
Excellent

Simon is fair, polite, experienced and practical. He will always give frank and fearless advice. He is an excellent auctioneer. Simon sold my current house, my last house and my mums house quite a while ago. He is easy to talk to, always ready to help and very trustworthy. If you are selling your house, engage Simon, you won’t be disappointed

Simon Cookson

Simon Cookson

  4.9   (78 reviews)
Seller review
Highly regarded experienced and effective real estate agent
over 2 years ago
Highly regarded experienced and effective real estate agent

Rhys' knowledge of the market, experience and choice of strategy equate to a successful month long campaign culminating in a positive outcome. Rhys' trust worthy manner, upfront and committed approach ensured we as the vendor never had any doubts regarding any part of the sales process, expectations were always clear and aligned to the campaign, and we were kept updated with regular progress reports that honestly reflected buyer interest. Highly recommend Rhys and the team from MacDonald Upton.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (134 reviews)
Seller review
Personable Professional Prompt
over 2 years ago
Personable Professional Prompt

Julia was lovely to deal with on all levels. We were kept informed at all times and trusted her completely. All of the staff at McDonald Upton have been a pleasure to work with.

Julia Murphy

Julia Murphy

  5   (136 reviews)
Seller review
job well done
over 2 years ago
job well done

I am happy to recommend Joe and his team to anyone that are contemplating selling or buying a home.

Joe Zucco

Joe Zucco

  5   (107 reviews)
Seller review
Review re Rhys Afford
over 2 years ago
Review re Rhys Afford

to whom it may concern Rhys worked on the sale of my parents flat in Essendon recently. I found him very personable and professional in the way that he dealt with me, my family and potential purchasers. I also believe that he behaved in a very knowledgeable, ethical way. I wouldnt hesitate to recommend him and would use his services again. cheers David Robertson.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (134 reviews)
Seller review
Professional with great knowledge of local market
over 2 years ago
Professional with great knowledge of local market

Paul and the team at McDonald Upton were both friendly and professional in helping make the sale of our home a smooth and stress- free process. We trusted Paul's advice up to and at the auction as he has a broad knowledge of the local market and experience of many years in real estate. We were extremely pleased with the result and happy to welcome our lovely new neighbours into Kilmartin Street.

Paul McDonald

Paul McDonald

  5   (74 reviews)
Seller review
Above and Beyond
over 2 years ago
Above and Beyond

Julia went above and beyond to sell our property in an extremely tough market, and was able to hold countless inspections, both scheduled and private at the drop of a hat. She communicated well with us on a regular basis. Thanks Julia for your efforts!

Julia Murphy

Julia Murphy

  5   (136 reviews)
Seller review
Boutique care and attention to detail!
over 2 years ago
Boutique care and attention to detail!

Sheryl has managed my property and also the sales campaign for it. She has a unique ability to manage tenants fairly and also prepare a stellar campaign. Sheryl guided me through the process, recommending stylists and conveyances. I got a great sale price based on her very hands on approach. Couldn't recommend Sheryl more highly.

Sheryl Upton

Sheryl Upton

  5   (16 reviews)
Seller review
worked hard
over 2 years ago
worked hard

George work really hard to get best price

Georgie Maggs

Georgie Maggs

  4.8   (71 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional on every level
over 2 years ago
Exceptional on every level

Julia was outstanding. Her knowledge, professionalism, first class negotiating skills and her warm nature made this process such a positive experience. We felt informed and supported by Julia and the team, which allowed us to make calm, considered decisions. We also felt she worked exceptionally well with buyers ensuring we got the best possible price. We highly recommend Julia and thank her for her guidance.

Julia Murphy

Julia Murphy

  5   (136 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent
over 2 years ago
Excellent

An excellent understanding of the local market and his advice was imperative in achieving the desired result on our property.

Simon Cookson

Simon Cookson

  4.9   (78 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent
over 2 years ago
Great Agent

Joe was great to deal with. I couldn't recommend a better agent to sell your property.

Joe Zucco

Joe Zucco

  5   (107 reviews)
385 - 396 of 735
© 2026 RateMyAgent