Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
851 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, friendly, supportive, reliable, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Amazing Experience
over 1 year ago
Amazing Experience

We had an amazing experience working with Andrew as our real estate agent. From start to finish, he was a true professional, always available to answer our questions and guide us through the process with ease. His communication was excellent—he kept us informed at every step and was quick to respond whenever we reached out. Andrew's deep knowledge of the area was incredibly helpful, and he used that expertise to ensure we made informed decisions. Thanks Andrew!

Andrew Butler

Andrew Butler

  4.7   (63 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent
over 1 year ago
Great Agent

A very professional person , explored all aspects for selling of my property , left no stone unturned to sell the property .a well rounded and accomplished agent

Simon Cookson

Simon Cookson

  4.9   (85 reviews)
Seller review
More Than Helpful
over 1 year ago
More Than Helpful

Andrew helped us sell our property in Pascoe Vale. Kept us informed and up-to-date as everything went on. After settlement we required information and help from the Real Estate again. Andrew was more than helpful. People generally think once the Real Estate has your money that is it but this is not the case with Andrew , very happy and would have no hesitation in using him again..

Andrew Butler

Andrew Butler

  4.7   (63 reviews)
Seller review
Milo got us a great result
over 1 year ago
Milo got us a great result

Milo knows the area very well. He did a great job on auction day to get us the best price possible. He was honest about what our property would likely sell for. We went into auction day eyes wide open. Milo got us a great result at auction. I’d highly recommend him to sell property in our area.

Milo Rasinac

Milo Rasinac

  5   (29 reviews)
Seller review
Prompt Communicator!
over 1 year ago
Prompt Communicator!

Andrew has been an outstanding professional at every stage of my recent purchase. Not only has he maintained effective and prompt communication but he has been very accommodating in relation to all of my requests and queries. He has made this process seamless and has been a pleasure to deal with. A fantastic agent and I’m fortunate to have got him for my purchase!

Andrew Butler

Andrew Butler

  4.7   (63 reviews)
Seller review
Return client to the best agent
over 1 year ago
Return client to the best agent

Over a 14 year period, this is the third property that Andrew has sold for us and his advice, approachability, professionalism have been the reason I'm a return customer. Would highly recommend Andrew to anyone selling their home!

Andrew Butler

Andrew Butler

  4.7   (63 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptional Support
over 1 year ago
Exceptional Support

Julia was amazing when searching for our first home, was professional and demonstrated that she values getting the best result for the client. Would recommended McDonald Upton for any new home buyers

Julia Murphy

Julia Murphy

  5   (150 reviews)
Buyer review
Georgie did the job
over 1 year ago
Georgie did the job

Georgie was prompt responding to emails - her knowledge of the property and market was average. Whilst Georgie was at open inspections, we mostly dealt with Georgie post auction leading to settlement. The experience of working with Georgie started of great, but as general questions were raised about the property leading into settlement, the experience went downhill. I sincerely wish that Georgie maintained her demeanour throughout the process so I could give her 5 stars. I would recommend McDonald Upton in general as a REA, due to positive 5 star experiences in the past with other agents.

Georgie Maggs

Georgie Maggs

  4.9   (83 reviews)
Buyer review
Tom was amazing!
over 1 year ago
Tom was amazing!

As someone nervous about re entering the real estate market Tom was very accommodating. Answering my questions promptly and taking time out of his day to take me through the property multiple times so I could make an informed decision I was comfortable with! Thanks Tom!

Tom Condon

Tom Condon

  5   (52 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent
over 1 year ago
Great Agent

Excellent knowledge of the market which acheived a surprising quick & satisfying sale!

Simon Cookson

Simon Cookson

  4.9   (85 reviews)
Buyer review
Very Professional And Honest
over 1 year ago
Very Professional And Honest

Julia kept in touch the whole time and she was very professional and also very honest the whole time regarding the sale and the vendors expectations and negotiated honestly and was always transparent with the pricing. I would recommend McDonald Upton to anyone buying or selling have a good knowledge of where the market is and heading.

Julia Murphy

Julia Murphy

  5   (150 reviews)
Buyer review
Very Respectful & Responsive
over 1 year ago
Very Respectful & Responsive

We give 5 stars to the team at Mcdonald and Upton who have been amazing, a special thanks to Rhys who has helped us find the property we were looking for. Rhys listened to everything we said he knows the area well, his communication allowed us to be in the best position to find the right home. He is very respectful & responsive. We met many other agents in area in the buying process, but can definitely confirm Rhys was the person who stood out. Thank you Rhys for all that you did.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (150 reviews)
397 - 408 of 851
© 2026 RateMyAgent