Nutrien Harcourts McCathies - Ayr

262 Queen Street, Ayr, Qld
  •   4.9   (61 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Nutrien Harcourts McCathies - Ayr has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

27
Reviews
62
Properties for sale
96
Sold properties
$251k
Average sale price
$24.1m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) as lead and supporting agent and published on ratemyagent.com.au. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 5 agents at Nutrien Harcourts McCathies - Ayr.

Amber Hornsby
Amber Hornsby

Licensed Real Estate Agent

  4.9   (47 reviews)
About Amber
With a robust background in customer service, gained from her previous role in the travel industry, Amber brought her passion for client satisfaction to Nutrien Harcourts McCathies in 2019. Starting in the reception role, she swiftly transitioned into the sales department, where she has excelled as a Sales Assistant over the past five years. Amber's tenure at Nutrien Harcourts McCathies has been marked by significant growth in her real estate expertise. Working closely with various sales agents, she has developed a deep understanding of the industry, honed her communication and negotiation skills, and acquired comprehensive knowledge of the local sales market. Her role has also familiarized her with the intricate legislation requirements surrounding property sales, whether vacant or tenanted. Clients past and present appreciate Amber for her professionalism, approachable personality, and attentive listening skills. She has a knack for understanding client needs, ensuring they feel confident and reassured throughout their real estate journey. As a Licensed Real Estate Agent, Amber takes pride in representing Nutrien Harcourts McCathies. She is committed to ongoing learning and development, continually seeking opportunities to expand her knowledge and enhance her skills in Sales. Amber's dedication to delivering exceptional service, paired with her solid industry knowledge and client-focused approach, exemplifies her role as a valued member of our team, dedicated to achieving the best outcomes for our clients under the Nutrien Harcourts McCathies banner.
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
John Mottin
John Mottin

Director

  4.9   (9 reviews)
About John

John currently has 29 active property listings and 12 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Paula Mottin
Paula Mottin

Licensed Real Estate Agent

  5   (5 reviews)
About Paula
Since 1998, Paula has continued building her knowledge through University studies and establishing a successful career as a teacher of dance, piano and music. A career change emerged in 2012 into the real estate industry as Sales Administrator for Landmark (Rural Real Estate). During 2014 Paula and her husband John, purchased a share in the long standing local business of McCathies Real Estate Agency and merged the two businesses to create Nutrien Harcourts McCathies. In 2021 John and Paula acquired full ownership of the business. As a business owner, Paula prides herself in providing all our clients with comprehensive advice, exclusive marketing campaigns and knowledgeable advice on all aspects of real estate. Effective communication is the key to our businesses ongoing success and we will, as business owners, always use it to build trust with our clients. When choosing Paula to represent you, you can be assured of being treated with the utmost care, consideration, honesty and respect. Paula will work tirelessly on your behalf to secure the best possible outcome for you. With strong local connections, Paula looks forward to meeting you and to help you achieve the very best results for your real estate needs.
View Profile
Latoya Hartwell
Latoya Hartwell

Sales Associate

Lisa Sarri
Lisa Sarri

Sales Associate

About Lisa

Lisa currently has 9 active property listings.

View Profile

About us

"Nutrien Harcourts McCathies" is a specialist Real Estate Agency located in Ayr Qld. We offer residential property sales, residential property management, residential property leasing, residential property auctions, commercial property sales, commercial property management, commercial property leasing, free property appraisals, free market appraisals, free rental appraisals, rural property sales, lifestyle blocks, farm sales, acreage sales. Although we are located in Ayr, we service clients from Jarvisfield, Mcdesme, Home Hill, Brandon, Barratta, Rita Island, Colevale, Alva, Wangaratta, Cromarty, Aligator Creek, Roseneath and all surrounding areas. If you are looking for the best Real Estate Agents in North East QLD then look no further!" We are locally owned with over 90 years Real Estate experience. We have the expertise with the local market and current property trends, a solid work ethic plus well-developed negotiation skills to offer our clients exceptional service and achieving success. Trust, honesty and integrity remain the company’s personal hallmarks. We at Nutrien Harcourts McCathies believe that strong communication, a personalized experience and attention to detail generate successful outcomes for our clients.

Our reviews

  4.9  
61 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 6.
Seller review
Exceptional Service - Above and Beyond Expectations
2 days ago
Exceptional Service - Above and Beyond Expectations

Amber is an absolute credit to her profession. Selling a property while living in a different state could have been challenging, but Amber made the entire process so much easier. Her communication, professionalism and dedication were exceptional. She went above and beyond at every opportunity, keeping us informed, supported and reassured throughout. Nothing was ever too much trouble. We cannot recommend Amber highly enough. She is a true gem and a credit to the real estate industry.

Amber Hornsby

Amber Hornsby

  4.9   (47 reviews)
Seller review
Amazing .. he was very supportive, knowledgeable and communicated everything
about 2 months ago
Amazing .. he was very supportive, knowledgeable and communicated everything

When I was selling due to very difficult circumstances John was amazing and his beautiful Angels in his office - Lisa and Tayla they just made the whole experience a very smooth transaction and would not hesitate to recommend them to anyone thank you Team

John Mottin

John Mottin

  4.9   (9 reviews)
Buyer review
Helpful to our needs
about 2 months ago
Helpful to our needs

Thank you for helping us buy the house at Mount Kelly. It was great service from both you and John. Thanks again,

John Mottin

John Mottin

  4.9   (9 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent communication and respectful
2 months ago
Excellent communication and respectful

Very responsive to the buyer while still catering to the Sellers needs answering all questions and going above to do video calls do to not in the area

Amber Hornsby

Amber Hornsby

  4.9   (47 reviews)
Show all 61 reviews
map

Our properties

Nutrien Harcourts McCathies - Ayr has 62 properties for sale and sold 96 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$389,000
12-14 Mill St
Giru QLD 4809
3
1
2
House
For Sale
$435,000
31 Fifteenth A Street
Home Hill QLD 4806
3
2
2
House
For Sale
$549,000
67 Graham Street
Ayr QLD 4807
4
1
7
House
SoldNov 4, 2026
Price not available
76 Thirteenth Avenue
Home Hill QLD 4806
3
1
1
House
Show all 158 properties
© 2026 RateMyAgent