Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
144 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Works hard for the best outcome
10 days ago
Works hard for the best outcome

We couldn’t be happier with the sale of our home! Jim achieved a fantastic price off market and worked closely with us throughout the process to get the best possible outcome. From the beginning, we felt listened to and supported, with clear communication and honest advice every step of the way. Jim's professionalism, dedication and knowledge of the market made the whole experience feel seamless. Thank you for all your hard work and for making the sale such a positive experience. We would happily recommend anyone looking to sell their home through Jim Kelly and his sales team at Peter Milling and Company.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (90 reviews)
Seller review
A great experience
10 days ago
A great experience

We can’t thank Jim and his team enough for all their input in selling our home. Jim’s knowledge and professionalism showed in all aspects of the sale. We would very highly recommend Jim to anyone looking to sell or buy a home.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (90 reviews)
Buyer review
Peter Dwyer was informed and realistic re property and price.
17 days ago
Peter Dwyer was informed and realistic re property and price.

We found Peter approachable and very obliging when we arranged extra viewings. He was knowledge about the area and realistic with price estimation and expectation. The auction was professional and we felt well supported by his team. We highly recommend Peter and his Company for property sales.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (45 reviews)
Seller review
Sold to Plan
19 days ago
Sold to Plan

Professional experience from start to finish. Set a date to have the property sold. Set a time line to make sure nothing was missed, which included everything from market appraisal, advertising, signed contracts, clearing sale and livestock sale all to have vacant possession of property before harvest. Great work from Graham Anderson, Peter Dwyer and Staff. Highly recommended.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (45 reviews)
Buyer review
Clear and Transparent
about 1 month ago
Clear and Transparent

It was a real pleasure working with Peter Dwyer and the whole team at Peter Milling & Co throughout the sale & purchase process. Peter was clear and transparent throughout the EOI process and, following acceptance of our offer, was always easy to contact and facilitated excellent communication between us and the vendors. I must also acknowledge and thank the vendors for their generosity and willingness to provide any assistance required to make for a very smooth transition into the property.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (45 reviews)
Seller review
A very professional performence
about 1 month ago
A very professional performence

Right from the start Peter showed how his experience in property sales showed out . He showed that by recalling previous sales he was able to give an accurate price for Quamby I was kept informed by regular updates

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (45 reviews)
Buyer review
A great first home buying experience
3 months ago
A great first home buying experience

I couldn’t have asked for a better experience buying my first home. From start to finish, Jim was incredibly responsive, patient, honest and genuinely kind. He always took the time to answer my questions and make sure I felt comfortable and informed. His professionalism and care really stood out, and I’m so grateful for the role he played in helping me achieve the purchase of my first property. I would highly recommend Jim to anyone looking to buy or sell property.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (90 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent result and a quick sale
3 months ago
Excellent result and a quick sale

Jim and his team were very professional in all areas of the sale. The marketing, communication, open homes, and the negotiation of price resulted in the sale being a very smooth and rewarding outcome.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (90 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing Service
5 months ago
Amazing Service

We would highly recommend Jim Kelly to anyone looking to buy a home. Jim took the time to listen to our needs, build a genuine relationship with us, and guide us through the process with excellent communication. What we appreciated most was that Jim was never pushy. He was accommodating, provided us with a range of options, and genuinely wanted to help us find the right home for our family. Thanks to Jim's professionalism, patience, and support, we found our new home and couldn't be happier with the experience.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (90 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent communication and very efficient operator.
6 months ago
Excellent communication and very efficient operator.

Peter’s experience in the rural industry is evident when discussing rural properties both for vendors and buyers. He easily gains their confidence and that is essential for both parties. Peter is the ultimate professional.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (45 reviews)
1 - 12 of 144
© 2026 RateMyAgent