Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
135 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Genuine with good knowledge of the local market
5 months ago
Genuine with good knowledge of the local market

Peter was professional from start to finish, provided realistic expectations and maintained regular communication. Our property sold quicker than we expected and for a good price.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (40 reviews)
Buyer review
High quality
5 months ago
High quality

Jim made our experience of buying our first home very easy and simple. We reached out to Jim, with what we were looking for in a house. Jim provided us with a home that ticked all our boxes. Jim was very genuine throughout all whole experience.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (86 reviews)
Seller review
Experience and personal touch that made the difference!
5 months ago
Experience and personal touch that made the difference!

Peter is very knowledgeable and nailed the valuation. He made the process smoother and helped us at every step, whilst being very proactive in keeping us informed. We're glad we chose him. A big shout out to our videographer too! ;-) Small feedback: the road sign was simply illegible when driving. Too busy. Should have been simpler or much larger.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (40 reviews)
Seller review
Professional and outstanding communication
5 months ago
Professional and outstanding communication

Jim Kelly was very professional and kept me well informed with my propert being on market until it was sold. Jim communicated with me regulary and kept me updated. I would not hesisitate to have Jim as my future agent. Thankyou so much for your help Jim.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (86 reviews)
Buyer review
Good local knowledge
5 months ago
Good local knowledge

Peter was accomodating as to our timeframe to view the property. He followed up on queries and was a pleasure to work with.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (40 reviews)
Buyer review
Great experience
5 months ago
Great experience

We had a great experience working with Peter. From the very first contact he was professional, approachable, and extremely knowledgeable about the local market. Communication was clear and timely throughout the entire process, and nothing ever felt like too much trouble. Peter was honest, realistic, and always had our best interests in mind, which made the whole experience far less stressful than we expected. His attention to detail and follow-up was excellent, and we always felt well informed and supported. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Peter to anyone looking to buy or sell a genuine professional who delivers results.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (40 reviews)
Buyer review
Very happy purchaser Oct 2025
5 months ago
Very happy purchaser Oct 2025

Peter listed a property in Walmer which we were interested in. Being from Sydney, we had to rely heavily on Peter's honesty and integrity with regard to the property description. At all times during the negotiation and purchase, he was an absolute gentleman and true to his word. A very welcome relief when compared to other negotiations we have recently done. I genuinely feel he got a good result for both parties, and would be my choice if we ever decide to sell. Very happy thank you.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (40 reviews)
Buyer review
Easy to deal with, no hassles
5 months ago
Easy to deal with, no hassles

Jim was easy to deal with, punctual with replying to queries and questions. The whole experience was smooth sailing.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (86 reviews)
Seller review
Good Sale Outcome
about 1 year ago
Good Sale Outcome

Peter Dwyer is the local Guru when it comes to property sales in the NSW West. His vast knowledge of values and the current market are outstanding. Thank you Peter.

Peter Dwyer

Peter Dwyer

  4.8   (40 reviews)
Buyer review
A great outcome.
about 1 year ago
A great outcome.

I have sold and purchased homes through Jim Kelly, and I have no hesitation in recommending Jim for your Real Estate needs. Jim is very approachable with good communication skills and has a great knowledge of the market. The purchase of this home has been smooth sailing, and I am very pleased with the outcome.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (86 reviews)
Seller review
Stress  Free Sale
about 1 year ago
Stress Free Sale

Working with Jim Kelly of Peter Milling Real Estate was an absolute pleasure. Nothing was a problem and Jim and his team made the process of selling a stress free experience. Jim's expertise of the local market was evident from our initial meeting. If you want a professional agent, who keeps you informed with the market, I would certainly recommend Jim to be your agent without hesitation.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (86 reviews)
Seller review
Ultra Professional
about 1 year ago
Ultra Professional

Jim Kelly is a brilliant realestate agent, He is/was so easy to deal with, Very knowledgeable & he and his company treated me with ultimate respect & communication was perfect!

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly

  5   (86 reviews)
13 - 24 of 135
© 2026 RateMyAgent