Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1706 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, supportive, honest, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Excellent communication
over 4 years ago
Excellent communication

Penny's communication throughout this process has been second to none. As this is our first home, we've had lots of questions along the way and Penny has been extremely helpful and available at all hours to answer our questions. We would highly recommend Penny for anyone that is looking to sell or purchase their home. Thank you so much for all of your help along the way!

Penny Shields

Penny Shields

  4.9   (182 reviews)
Seller review
Best Real Estate Agent Ever!!
over 4 years ago
Best Real Estate Agent Ever!!

Catharina went over and above when selling my home. She helped me get tradies in to improve my home and that she did! Catharina helped me get an extra $80k and was a delight to deal with - she was as honest as the day is long and made a stressful time extremely easy. I would only ever want Catharina as my Real Estate Agent.

Catharina Darken

Catharina Darken

  4.9   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Very pleasant to deal with.
over 4 years ago
Very pleasant to deal with.

Very honest and reliable. Always responded to messages. Great to deal with.

Richard Stacey

Richard Stacey

  5   (103 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of the Century
over 4 years ago
Seller of the Century

Tash was great to work with, she is passionate about her job and Community. She went above and beyond both myself as the seller, our tenants and the buyers were more than impressed with her style and how pleasant and thorough she is. Sold my house “in a minute” and got me more than I asked for. Thanx Tash and thanx PRD, she’s an asset to Company and Community Would recommend Tash in a heartbeat.

Tash Martin

Tash Martin

  4.9   (241 reviews)
Buyer review
A wonderful experience with Tash
over 4 years ago
A wonderful experience with Tash

Tash got off the mark as soon as I expressed interest in a couple of properties she had listed. Her knowledge of the Hepburn Shire, and in particular the Creswick area was second to none. I found her down-to-earth, and very easy to talk to. She had a breadth of experience which made me feel very comfortable, especially during this stressful time (lockdown, etc). Communication was very easy with Tash and she responded to all my queries quickly and efficiently.

Tash Martin

Tash Martin

  4.9   (241 reviews)
Buyer review
First home buyer
over 4 years ago
First home buyer

Catharina was great to deal with, prompt in replying to my messages and questions and super helpful. Made the process of buying my new home easy.

Catharina Darken

Catharina Darken

  4.9   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
A seamless, professional and friendly experience.
over 4 years ago
A seamless, professional and friendly experience.

Both my wife and I would highly recommend Catharina to anyone thinking of buying or selling their house. On our first meeting with Catharina we were made to feel welcome. Her knowledge of the real estate market and communication with us was brilliant. Not only did we purchase our new house through Catharina we decided to sell our existing house through her as well. We couldn't recommend her enough. Thanks for making both transactions a memorable experience for us Catharina. Best regards Anthony & Donna

Catharina Darken

Catharina Darken

  4.9   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional & Experienced
over 4 years ago
Professional & Experienced

Penny Shield helped us in securing our first home. She provided outstanding representation getting our offer accepted over multiple offers received. We feel so blessed to had her negotiate a great deal for us. Penny is an excellent real estate agent and person, she is caring of ones need. I would not hesitate to recommend Penny for your real estate needs, she will look after you.

Penny Shields

Penny Shields

  4.9   (182 reviews)
Seller review
Enthusiasm and Professionalism Personified!
over 4 years ago
Enthusiasm and Professionalism Personified!

From the start, we were uplifted by Catharina's enthusiasm. This great first impression was soon buoyed by superior professionalism and market knowledge. We were kept informed at every stage and engaged with Catharina's bubbly, happy personality. We have no hesitation in awarding 5 stars and a recommendation to anyone selling a property in the area. Use PRD!

Catharina Darken

Catharina Darken

  4.9   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic Service
over 4 years ago
Fantastic Service

Catharina was very supportive throughout the sales process and quickly found a buyer within her network.

Catharina Darken

Catharina Darken

  4.9   (242 reviews)
Seller review
A Great Result!
over 4 years ago
A Great Result!

Richard was terrific from the get go! I could not have asked for more, he was someone who would listen, and more importantly explain what was happening in the forever changing market. You can tell Richard enjoys his work and was able to get the best price possible.

Richard Stacey

Richard Stacey

  5   (103 reviews)
Seller review
Professional and efficient
over 4 years ago
Professional and efficient

Penny was very professional and efficient in the sake of my house, with it being sold within one week and above my asking price.

Penny Shields

Penny Shields

  4.9   (182 reviews)
1201 - 1212 of 1,706
© 2026 RateMyAgent