Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
253 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, great negotiation, honest, responsive, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Matthew is an amazing agent
5 months ago
Matthew is an amazing agent

Matthew is an amazing agent, proactively resolving issues for me, very approachable and transparent for the process. Great to work with him, nothing I needed to worry throughout the entire selling.

Matthew Cilia

Matthew Cilia

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
The outcome was excellent
6 months ago
The outcome was excellent

I recently sold my house family home in West End that I owned for 29 years. It was a big undertaking, particularly by myself. It could have felt fairly overwhelming except for the fact that Luke helped me through the process, every step along the way, to ensure I was kept informed and understood my options. Luke’s communication with me was excellent and ensured I was kept up-to-date. Reports were sent to me every week and discussed on the phone as well. The outcome was excellent.

Luke Croft

Luke Croft

  4.9   (201 reviews)
Seller review
Genuinely cares about his clients
6 months ago
Genuinely cares about his clients

I first met Matthew through a call, and he’s been amazing ever since—always keeping me updated with accurate market info. When I decided to sell, he guided me through every step and achieved a record price for my building! He’s professional, proactive, and genuinely cares about his clients. Highly recommend Matthew if you’re looking to sell your property!

Matthew Cilia

Matthew Cilia

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
We would recommend!
6 months ago
We would recommend!

Luke and Darcy sold our apartment, they were great to deal with and we couldn’t be happier with the result. We would recommend to anyone selling in the 4101 postcode.

Luke Croft

Luke Croft

  4.9   (201 reviews)
Seller review
We would recommend!
6 months ago
We would recommend!

Luke and Darcy sold our apartment, they were great to deal with and we couldn’t be happier with the result. We would recommend to anyone selling in the 4101 postcode.

Darcy Pearson

Darcy Pearson

  5   (9 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, patient and persistent
6 months ago
Professional, patient and persistent

Luke and his team were professional, patient and persistent. They were also transparent in their dealings with us and frank in their feedback to us.

Luke Croft

Luke Croft

  4.9   (201 reviews)
Seller review
We could not have hoped for a better outcome!
6 months ago
We could not have hoped for a better outcome!

Luke and his team guided us thoughtfully and strategically through the sale process. Luke's advice and support took any anxiety out of preparing the property for sale and in the lead up to auction day. We chose Luke as he is well known, highly regarded and sells a lot in the Highgate Hill area. His timely communication, smart marketing and skilled process gave us reassurance and confidence. This resulted in the successful auction of our property. We could not have hoped for a better outcome!

Luke Croft

Luke Croft

  4.9   (201 reviews)
Seller review
Highly recommended
6 months ago
Highly recommended

Luke is reliable and straightforward in every step of the process. Communication was always clear and prompt, and everything was handled in an organized and efficient manner. Thanks to his expertise, the final result exceeded our expectations. Highly recommended.

Luke Croft

Luke Croft

  4.9   (201 reviews)
Seller review
Matthew was very professional in all aspects
7 months ago
Matthew was very professional in all aspects

As an interstate buyer, Matthew went out of his way to assist with the preparation of my unit prior to sale. He organised the removal of old furniture and arranged for painting of the unit. Matthew was very professional in all aspects of the sale where he clearly explained the end to end process and ensured any questions were answered in a timely manner.

Matthew Cilia

Matthew Cilia

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
Matthew was professional
7 months ago
Matthew was professional

Matthew was professional, responsive and straightforward. He really knew the area and how to best approach our property. Very happy.

Matthew Cilia

Matthew Cilia

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
The #1 Agent for a Reason
9 months ago
The #1 Agent for a Reason

Luke Croft has been the leading agent in Highgate Hill for decades, and now we know exactly why. He achieved a record-breaking sale for our unit at Dornoch Towers—$45,000 over the previous building record! His expertise, professionalism, and commitment were unmatched. Luke made the entire process smooth and stress-free. If you’re selling in Highgate Hill, don’t even consider anyone else.

Luke Croft

Luke Croft

  4.9   (201 reviews)
Seller review
If you're selling in the area, Darcy is the only agent to call.
9 months ago
If you're selling in the area, Darcy is the only agent to call.

Darcy Pearson was incredible throughout the sale of our unit at Dornoch Towers. He got us a record price—$45K above the previous record for the building! Always professional, supportive, and generous with his time. He did everything possible to achieve the best outcome. If you're selling in the area, Darcy is the only agent to call. We wouldn’t use anyone else. Highly recommend!

Darcy Pearson

Darcy Pearson

  5   (9 reviews)
1 - 12 of 253
© 2026 RateMyAgent