Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
82 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
about 1 year ago
James is a reliable expert in the residential sales market

James is a reliable expert in the residential sales market in the inner suburbs of Sydney. He is supported by an exceptional team of experts with decades of experience. James achieved a pleasing sale price at auction in a challenged market at a time of low clearance rates. Being a property professional myself, I highly recommend James.

James Natoli

James Natoli

  5   (118 reviews)
about 1 year ago
James was calm, super-efficient and gave great advice

We have been absolutely delighted with the service we got from James. He was calm, super-efficient and gave great advice. We got an amazing result, really quickly, and, most of all, he acted with decency and integrity and played completely straight at all times.

James Natoli

James Natoli

  5   (118 reviews)
over 1 year ago
I cannot overstate the exceptional service that James provided

I cannot overstate the exceptional service that James Natoli and his team provided during the recent sale of my home - a consummate professional with outstanding market knowledge, a tireless work ethic and trustworthy. At all times he was supportive, encouraging and reliable. He always followed through with every aspect of the sales process and at all times I was kept informed and reassured. My apartment sold, off market and with a record price for the complex. I highly recommend James!

James Natoli

James Natoli

  5   (118 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Expert Knowledge of Local Market

James has expert knowledge of the local market. He fulfilled all undertakings regarding his services at a very high level. He consistently phoned/ messaged promptly to provide detailed updates on buyer interest/feedback and I appreciated our face-to-face discussions on how to respond strategically as the campaign progressed. He helped me to obtain the price that I expected. In summary, James was professional in all his dealings with me. I would recommend him to other vendors in the area.

James Natoli

James Natoli

  5   (118 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Amazing real estate agent and person

Andrew has sold a few of our properties He is very knowledgeable and professional on every achieve We keep using Andrew as he continues to sell our properties for great prices

Andrew McKinnon

Andrew McKinnon

  5   (30 reviews)
over 1 year ago
A seamless experience

We're really glad we decided to sell our apartment with Andrew. From beginning to end, he has been a great pleasure to work with, offering insight into the market and making intelligent suggestions on sales strategies. He was able to immediately connect us with a buyer, avoiding unnecessary marketing costs and allowing us to move forward quickly with the sale. He kept us in touch with the process, even while we were travelling, and helped us achieve higher than expected sales price. We would highly recommend Andrew without hesitation.

Andrew McKinnon

Andrew McKinnon

  5   (30 reviews)
over 1 year ago
I highly recommend James Natoli to anyone looking to buy or sell

From the start James was professional, knowledgeable, and always responsive. He took the time to understand my needs and guided me through every step of the process, making the experience very enjoyable easy. I highly recommend James Natoli to anyone looking to buy or sell.

James Natoli

James Natoli

  5   (118 reviews)
over 1 year ago
First time selling and I couldn’t fault my experience with James

First time selling and I couldn’t fault my experience with James and his team. I appreciated James’ professional yet genuine approach. Communication was regular and transparent, helping to remove any stress and always making me feel that my home was in good hands. Would not hesitate to work with James and his team again.

James Natoli

James Natoli

  5   (118 reviews)
over 1 year ago
James went above and beyond in delivering a great result

James and his brilliant team (incl Anita and Lilly) have just sold my house and I cannot recommend him highly enough. He is extremely professional, trustworthy, enthusiastic, and a hard worker - and this showed throughout. He was in constant contact with me throughout the campaign and he and his team went above and beyond in delivering a great result. You can tell he is passionate about selling homes and it shows in his work ethic, suburb knowledge, and the end result we got. Thank you James!

James Natoli

James Natoli

  5   (118 reviews)
almost 2 years ago
Down to earth and true to his word

We had the pleasure of purchasing a property represented by Andrew and were very happy with our experience. Andrew was very professional, kept us in the loop, and true to his word. He had excellent knowledge of the property he was representing and answered our questions promptly. Buying a property (especially your first!) is a high stress experience, and Andrew made us feel comfortable. I would recommend working with Andrew if you have the opportunity to do so.

Andrew McKinnon

Andrew McKinnon

  5   (30 reviews)
25 - 36 of 82
© 2026 RateMyAgent