Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
357 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Natalie is the best to deal with and gets the job done
8 months ago
Natalie is the best to deal with and gets the job done

We engaged Natalie Fransis to sell my mums place, in Warners bay. The whole process was daunting since we had not gone through this before . Natalie made this process so easy. All the suggestions about what to do to the place from start to finish was made easy, including the idea of staging, which is a must. This made all the difference. From start to finish Natalie was always there to answer any questions or concerns. And when ever she wasn't available, she always got back to me, keeping me updated with what was going on. She kept her word even when the buyers/ Lawyers tried to hold things up. She pushed things through quickly, ethically, but more importantly in a manner that made the outcome right for both sides. She's a beautiful girl , professional in all aspects of her job. You won't be disappointed. SHEILS

Natalie Francis

Natalie Francis

  5   (37 reviews)
Seller review
I can highly recommend Peter Shiels & Co.
8 months ago
I can highly recommend Peter Shiels & Co.

Peter and his team were great to work with from start to finish. They were very thorough and professional. Peter secured a sale quickly for an outstanding price. Highly recommended.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Seller review
We highly recommend Garth 100%
8 months ago
We highly recommend Garth 100%

Garth is highly professional, driven & got us a great result in the end. Our property was in a very niche market being 6 bedrooms. We had plenty of offers when we were on the market with a previous agent, none of which were within the price guide. Garth saw beyond that and worked for the vendor, not the purchaser. He demonstrated great perseverance & didn't give up until he found a genuine buyer who could totally appreciate the quality of the home & subsequent price point. We would highly recommend Garth if you want to sell your property for the price you want, as opposed to other agents who want to sell as quickly as possible to make their sales record look good. Garth always kept us updated and was a pleasure to work with.

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (47 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent
9 months ago
Great Agent

I've dealt with Pete on both the purchase and sale or a property in Whitebridge and on both occasions was impressed with his integrity, diligence and unwavering commitment both as a buyer and a seller. Further the administraive support from his office was always timely and efficient.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Seller review
Best Real Estate in Lake Macquarie
9 months ago
Best Real Estate in Lake Macquarie

We couldn't be happier with our selling experience with Peter and Nat. From our first meeting with them both, our confidence was with them totally. The whole process was streamlined, relaxed and extremely professional. They knew how to market our property to its utmost potential and gain interest from multiple parties. They had our house sold in 2 weeks. We would highly recommend using Shiels&Co to anyone.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Seller review
Very satisfied.
9 months ago
Very satisfied.

Garth is very easy to work with. He is always available and communicative. His market knowledge is broad and his pleasant manner makes selling a house a pleasant experience. We definitely recommend Garth.

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (47 reviews)
Buyer review
A great experience!
9 months ago
A great experience!

Our experience with Peter & Natalie has been amazing from the second we first called to ask about the property. They have been honest and the communication was great. As soon as our offer was accepted, everything felt really easy! A friend of mine also purchased through Shiels & Co and had the exact same feedback. We are very very happy with how the whole process went. Thanks again Peter & Natalie.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Buyer review
Friendly and responsive sales team
9 months ago
Friendly and responsive sales team

Peter and the Shiels team were direct in communication and easy to deal with, and accommodated all of my requests around property inspections and information with ease. The purchase process was friendly throughout and given the busy timing just before Christmas, the team were responsive and ensured that everything was finalised before holiday closures. All in all my purchase felt like a genuine and low-stress experience.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Seller review
Pete and his team are 10 outta 10!
9 months ago
Pete and his team are 10 outta 10!

Pete and his team secured us out asking price and kept us in the loop the whole time with great communication and support. If you live in the 2290 don’t sell with anyone else.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Seller review
Communication and professionalism
9 months ago
Communication and professionalism

Pete was amazing to work with, nothing was ever a bother, always had the answers and supported us through the process. Had the best communication, we always felt like we were looked after and in safe hands. Would highly recommend Pete.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Seller review
Best house sale experience ever!
9 months ago
Best house sale experience ever!

I sold my house with Shiels & Co and it was the best experience imaginable. The house was under offer and subsequently sold very well in what must be a record time of one day after listing! My experience with Peter has been nothing but fantastic. He is professional, punctual and respectful, offered insight and advice and was always just a quick call away. Peter clearly understands the market and the area very well, as is evidenced by the many successful sales I could see - something that influenced my decision to engage him in the first place. Similarly, my experience with the agency was great, from the listing process and organising the one house inspection I actually had, to general advice and the mechanics of the sale. Natalie and Ruby were very helpful and it was always easy to know exactly where I was in the process, what was needed etc. With Shiels, I always felt that things were in hand and everything was transparent - the way it should be. So with all this in mind, I am very happy that I chose to go with Peter and company, would use them again and would wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone looking for a truly professional representation in the market and a smooth, hassle-free and transparent sale process.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (389 reviews)
Buyer review
Absolutely Amazing
9 months ago
Absolutely Amazing

Natalie is a legend and helped John and I find our first home. Couldn’t have asked for anyone better to look after us 🥳🩷

Natalie Francis

Natalie Francis

  5   (37 reviews)
49 - 60 of 357
© 2026 RateMyAgent