Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
339 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Top Dollar without the Stress
10 months ago
Top Dollar without the Stress

Peter and his team have gone above and beyond expectations. They were easy to work with and professional. They got us top dollar for our home and took all the stress out of selling. I would highly recommend Sheils and Co to sell your home!

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
A seamless home sale experience
10 months ago
A seamless home sale experience

Peter and Natalie made selling our parents' home of 60 years a breeze. Their advice on sales strategy, the type of preparation to be focused on, and the price we could expect to achieve was spot on. We live in Sydney, so they organised all the contractors involved in the preparation for us. They always kept us up to date with developments and got us a wonderful price within two weeks. We can't recommend them highly enough.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Steady support, no pressure and honest conversations
10 months ago
Steady support, no pressure and honest conversations

Working with Peter Shiels to sell our home was a genuinely very positive experience. From our first meeting, Peter had such a calm and reassuring presence — something we really appreciated during what can be a stressful time. There was never any pressure, just steady support and honest conversations. What we valued most was Peter's advice, especially when it came to pricing and negotiating. It was clear that he had our best interests in mind and helped us navigate decisions with clarity and confidence. In the end, we felt really good about the outcome, and that’s thanks to Peter and his team at Shiels. We’re so glad we chose to work with Peter and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Peter to anyone selling their home.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
A TRUE GENTLEMAN
10 months ago
A TRUE GENTLEMAN

Exceptional service from Peter at Shiels & Co! He was communicative, transparent, and friendly throughout the entire process of selling our home. Peter's dedication to customer service is clear, and I'd highly recommend him to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy agent.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Buyer review
Fabulous support and guidance
10 months ago
Fabulous support and guidance

From the moment we engaged with Pete around what we wanted, he was able to support and guide us in the purchase of our property. Even though some bumps he was completely transparent and worked with us through every step of the way.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Buyer review
The best of the best
10 months ago
The best of the best

We cannot thank Pete & Nat enough. Not only did we have an exceptional selling experience with them, but we’ve now also purchased one of their offmarket properties and we honestly cannot fault them. The level of care and compassion they show to everyone they work with is second to none. As soon as a house popped up that Nat knew we’d love, she contacted us straight away. The communication throughout the whole process was insanely appreciated!

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Thank you Cameron for another great result
10 months ago
Thank you Cameron for another great result

Cameron is a personable and proactive estate agent. His knowledge of real estate in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie is second to none. This is the 2nd property Cameron has sold for me over the last 12 months.His communication was daily and solid work ethic is commendable. Cameron has gone above and beyond once again and I highly recommend to entrust him in selling your property.

Cameron Stevenson

Cameron Stevenson

  4.9   (166 reviews)
Buyer review
Great, friendly service
10 months ago
Great, friendly service

Peter and his team have been incredibly kind, friendly, and easy to work with throughout our purchase. They went above and beyond to address every issue, big or small, with care and professionalism.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Garth Brennan
10 months ago
Garth Brennan

Working with Garth and the team from Shiels property was excellent.There confidence was reassuring and communication excellent would not hesitate to recommend Garth to family or fiends Thanks Garth

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Buyer review
Wonderful job done by Peter!
11 months ago
Wonderful job done by Peter!

We had a fantastic experience working with Peter and the Shiels team. Excellent communication throughout the entire process, always keeping us informed of where we stood. As first home buyers, we never felt overwhelmed or pushed along at any stage and Peter embodies honesty and integrity. While we were hoping for a shorter settlement, we understood the vendors situation and Peter was patient and responsive to help us navigate it. Natalie and Ruby were also wonderful to deal with. Were grateful for the smooth, stress free experience and wouldn't hesitate to recommend Peter and the team.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Pete is personable, attentive, and knows the local market inside out.
11 months ago
Pete is personable, attentive, and knows the local market inside out.

Pete Shiels is an absolute pleasure to work with. Pete is personable, approachable, and truly takes the time to listen to your needs. Pete's in-depth knowledge of the suburb market is impressive, and he provides valuable insights to help you make confident decisions. Pete’s professionalism, combined with his friendly manner, makes the buying or selling process stress-free and enjoyable. Highly recommend!

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
73 - 84 of 339
© 2026 RateMyAgent