Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
68 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Disappointing result
about 1 year ago
Disappointing result

Our original estimate from Matt was 980k based on a very similar house down the road that sold for that amount. There was talk that 1.05M was possible I thought that was far-fetched though. We were up front that we are looking for a new house and that this estimate would determine our price range. So we set our finances at 960k to give us a buffer of 20k and bought a house based on getting that amount. We let Matt know we were now on the clock to sell this house before the one we bought settles. Matt ran a campaign of 4 weeks ending in an auction. The first open home he left the key to the house at the office. After the second week and after a little pressure from buyers Matt set the price guide at 950k, 30k below what we originally discussed and started getting offers of 940k. Not being realtors ourselves we let him proceed, maybe it's all part of the plan to hit 980k... but I was worried we'd not get the right group of buyers. We were very close to getting 975k in the 4th week, but the buyers pulled out at the last minute and didn't attend the auction. We re-did our finances to try and get more breathing-room but we actually made a mistake originally, and the new financing set our lowest sell price now to 969k. More than the 960k we thought. At auction the best bid was 940k which would put us 29k in the hole if we accepted. We passed it in on a vendor bid of 970k. Matt went on leave after the auction. With the house now advertised as 970k we got an offer of 980k a week later from buyers that wanted a short settlement. We accepted, it was exactly what we needed. Matt came back from leave and helped negotiate terms during the cooling off period. Matt was friendly, professional and upfront about everything. The results he provided were just disappointing, maybe that's just how the market was at the time. We also noticed after a few open houses that the side gates weren't closed properly, and the front window facing the street was left open at one stage.

Matthew Callus

Matthew Callus

  4.9   (76 reviews)
Buyer review
Absolutely Amazing
about 1 year ago
Absolutely Amazing

Matthew went above and beyond to help my wife and I purchase our first home. He was simply outstanding and very helpful with the process. My wife and I highly recommend Matthew. We will be using him in the future for further purchases.

Matthew Callus

Matthew Callus

  4.9   (76 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional and warmhearted
over 1 year ago
Professional and warmhearted

Antoinette is amazing! She's always helpful, responds promptly, and truly thinks from my perspective. Her dedication and professionalism made everything so smooth. Highly recommend her

Antoinette Davino

Antoinette Davino

  4.9   (59 reviews)
Seller review
Highly Recommend
over 1 year ago
Highly Recommend

Antoinette was fantastic to work with during the sale of my property. She was professional, communicative, and really went the extra mile to achieve a great result for us.

Antoinette Davino

Antoinette Davino

  4.9   (59 reviews)
Buyer review
Stress-free home purchase
over 1 year ago
Stress-free home purchase

We had the pleasure of working with Matt during the purchase of our new home and cannot recommend him highly enough. From our first encounter, Matt was approachable and made us feel at ease. He has extensive market knowledge and facilitated excellent communication between us and the vendor. Matt ensured the process was clear and easy, never pressuring us and always available to answer to answer any questions. He accommodated our requests to view the home multiple times,making us feel comfortable with our decision. Overall, our buying experience with Matt was fantastic. We will definitely reach out to him in the future if we decide to sell and we highly recommend him to anyone looking for an exceptional real estate agent!

Matthew Callus

Matthew Callus

  4.9   (76 reviews)
Seller review
Forget the Rest, Trust the Best
over 1 year ago
Forget the Rest, Trust the Best

We had 3 agents pitch to us for the sale of our home. From the outset it was clear that Matt's experience and knowledge of the industry and how to get the job done was miles greater than the others. throughout the entire process Matt was consistently communicating with us as to where things were at and reassuring that we would achieve what we wanted. during the sale of our home we conducted many inspections for a new home, and the level of interaction Matt has with potential buyers during an open was second to none in comparison to what we experienced in others. selling a house can be a stressful time, and picking the right agent either adds or subtracts from the stress. at no point during the process with Matt did we feel stressed or overwhelmed. in the future if I'm looking to sell again I would only be engaging Matt.

Matthew Callus

Matthew Callus

  4.9   (76 reviews)
Buyer review
House purchase in Camden
over 1 year ago
House purchase in Camden

We’ve recently purchased our home through Matthew and throughout the whole process he has been professional, very prompt and easy to deal with. Highly recommend Matthew and his team!

Matthew Callus

Matthew Callus

  4.9   (76 reviews)
Seller review
Professional service
over 1 year ago
Professional service

From the outset Antoinette and her team have been professional, approachable, honest and incredibly easy to deal with. I always felt confident that they were doing their utmost to get the best result for us with the sale of the home. Without hesitation, I would recommend Starr Partners Narellan to anyone needing an agent in this area and I'd definitely be using them should the need arise in the future.

Antoinette Davino

Antoinette Davino

  4.9   (59 reviews)
Buyer review
Prompt and professional!!
over 1 year ago
Prompt and professional!!

We just purchased our home through Starr Partners Narellan and we’re very happy with how they handled the process from start to finish. They were very prompt, professional and friendly. Highly recommend their services!

Antoinette Davino

Antoinette Davino

  4.9   (59 reviews)
Seller review
Amazing agent
over 1 year ago
Amazing agent

We have used Matthew twice now and have recommended him to everyone we know. He is great at what he does and makes you feel very comfortable throughout the process!

Matthew Callus

Matthew Callus

  4.9   (76 reviews)
Seller review
She's been a good agent
almost 2 years ago
She's been a good agent

She's very professional Very punctual

Antoinette Davino

Antoinette Davino

  4.9   (59 reviews)
Seller review
Knowledgeable, attentive and supportive
almost 2 years ago
Knowledgeable, attentive and supportive

Antoinette and the team at Starr Partners were extremely knowledgeable, transparent and professional throughout the entire sales experience. Her unwavering patience, support and constant communication was greatly appreciated, and ensured the selling process was successful, smooth and stress free. Antoinette went above and beyond to ensure a fantastic sale result I would highly recommend Antoinette and the Starr partners team to anyone looking to buy, sell or rent.

Antoinette Davino

Antoinette Davino

  4.9   (59 reviews)
13 - 24 of 68
© 2026 RateMyAgent