James Paynter

James Paynter

Auctioneer / Licensed Real Estate Agent at Buxton Brighton
  •   5   (8 reviews)

About James

James Paynter's career spans more than two decades, in which he has become one of the most trusted advisors in Melbourne real estate, bringing his experience to clients across Melbourne's bayside and throughout the Mornington Peninsula. Warm and relaxed with an unwavering commitment to achieve outstanding client results, on which James has built his reputation. He has also created a keen following for his renowned, entertaining auctioneering style. Founding James Paynter Real Estate in 2021, with a desire to re-define how the industry operates. A return to values, and to value those that we represent. The results speak for themselves and our clients speak highly of the commitment, transparency and integrity with which James and his team operate.

James' reviews

  5  
James has 8 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 6.
Review James
over 3 years ago
Great result

Dear James Many thanks for the sensational result you achieved for me last Saturday. I put myself in your hands and what strong hands they were. I felt comfortable throughout the whole process and was cheered by the updates after each “open” which seemed better and better as we progressed. Again sensational result. That’s what happens when you have the best auctioneer !!!! Regards, Carrie

over 4 years ago
Seamless Sale

Another seamless sale. James went above and beyond to achieve a great result. Thank you!

almost 5 years ago
Great experiences

James has now bought and sold for our family 3 times. He and his team have been fantastic, supportive and knowledgeable in the sale of 2 properties and the purchase of another one. His knowledge of the market and great people skills were so helpful, empathy with guidance through the processes were a godsend. Real estate can be daunting but James and the team are so thoughtful . Side note- An Auction with James is an event!

about 5 years ago
Thanking for excellence in servicing

Many thanks James for the selling of our property 24 Yawla Street Bentleigh 3204 with so much clarity, you achieved a better result than was expected Again, thank you for your professionalism and we will not hesitate in using your services or recommending your services Kind Regards George & Christine Marszalek

Show all 8 reviews

James' properties

James has 4 properties for sale and sold 4 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
Price not available
75A Champion St
Brighton VIC 3186
5
3
2
House
SoldApr 21, 2026
Price not available
1 View Court
Brighton VIC 3186
4
3
2
House
For Sale
Price not available
22 Downes Avenue
Brighton VIC 3186
4
3
2
House
For Sale
Price not available
22 Plunket St
Brighton East VIC 3187
4
2
2
House
Show all 8 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent