Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 110 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
almost 9 years ago
Very happy working with Jay

Jay was a great agent and I highly recommend him. He was excellent at communicating on a daily basis and handled the entire process in a professional matter.

almost 9 years ago
A Great Agent - in a league of their own

When we were looking for an agent to sell our property we wanted someone who had a strong reputation in the area and who acted with integrity. We also wanted an agent who was willing to invest their time and energy in not only preparing the property for sale, but also securing the best possible sale price. On all these measures (and many others) Jay Carroll and his amazing team at Barry Plant Ringwood, delivered and secured a great price for our unit. I have no hesitation in recommending Jay to anyone contemplating selling their property. He acts in a highly professional manner, is well respected and extremely knowledgeable in the industry. Most importantly, Jay is extremely diligent and keeps you informed at all points of the sale journey. A sincere thank you to Jay and the rest of the team for their terrific efforts and a great result - they are clearly in a league of their own!

almost 9 years ago
Best agent ever!

Jay is the most professional, kind- hearted agent I have ever seen! Alway be honest and genuine helping people instead of just selling. Stong recommend!

about 9 years ago
Fantastic Agent

I'd like to thank Jay and his team for all there hard work in the selling of our Nans property, a very difficult time for all the family but Jay was extremely compassionate and understanding!! So easy to talk to and was never ever pushy!! Will definitely be using Jay again!!

about 9 years ago
Top agent.

It has been a pleasure to deal with Jay Carroll from Barry Plant, Ringwood. He was considerate, informative and very enthusiastic. Jay offered good advice when asked and put a clear, concise plan into action. He communicated with us extremely well. Not only did he please us, the vendors, but from all accounts the buyer is most pleased with his acquisition.

about 9 years ago
Testamonial

It was my lucky day when I signed my property over to Jay Carroll. I always consider myself to be a good judge of character but this time I surpassed myself – the whole experience has been a smooth and even enjoyable time. Jay has been there for me from the beginning, nothing has been too much trouble for him and no question too difficult. Working with his Team Reuben he has not only achieved the very best price for me but also nurtured the buyer to also share in the happiness of a successful sale....a win, win situation. I thank Jay for everything and I wish him well for his future in real estate He is a 'new breed' of estate agent one with genuine, excellent people and communication skills and I cannot recommend him high enough to anyone considering entering the market.

about 9 years ago
Great Work, Professional, Friendly and Results Focused.

Very Happy with Barry Plant and in particular the work Jay carried out throughout our campaign, the Friendly, Professional manner and conduct of auction, then further negotiation to sell our property at Jeffrey Drive. Great Result!

about 9 years ago
Great agent

Jay was helpful throughout the whole process of selling my house and would highly rate him as the best agent in the eastern suburbs. Also on another note he isn't pushy which is a +.

about 9 years ago
Top Result

As I have lived in my home for more than 40 years it was very important to me to find the right agent that I could trust to sell my home. Jay was highly recommend to me and on meeting him found him to be honest, reassuring , enthusiastic and very professional. I was extremely happy with the results on Auction day and would not hesitate to recommend Jay. CHEERS Jay on a job well done. Sue.

over 9 years ago
Superstar Agent!

From the moment we met him, we knew he had to be ours! We could not be happier that we selected Jay as our agent. Working with Jay and Zak was an absolute pleasure; both are such down to earth, genuine people who understand the emotion attached with selling your family home. Jay's communication was impeccable; he kept us informed every step of the way, providing expert advice and guidance without ever putting any pressure on us. His ability to build rapport with potential buyers from all works of life is to be commended, as are his outstanding negotiation and auctioneer skills which achieved an amazing result in the sale of our home at auction.

over 9 years ago
Jay Carroll - Sale - Mitcham unit

We were delighted to have Jay Carroll market and sell our unit. Jay offered his advice and guidance and kept us well informed throughout the process. We knew exactly what to expect along the way and so by auction day we were very confident that the unit was going to sell. With so many genuine buyers attending the auction, the result exceeded our expectations and we could not have been happier. We would never hesitate to use Jay again.

over 9 years ago
Outstanding!

I found Jay and Zak to be polished, respectful, patient and professional at all times. Jay's communication was outstanding and he kept me well informed after every OFI and was very complimentary with they way I had presented my property. He was willing to meet with myself or my family at anytime and was always well prepared and had a great knowledge of his prospective buyers. The result on auction day speaks for itself and I couldn't be happier! Well done Jay and the Team!

73 - 84 of 110
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent