Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 589 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Jay was very helpful and professional throughout the whole process of our purchase.
2 months ago
Jay was very helpful and professional throughout the whole process of our purchase.

Jay’s market knowledge, professionalism is top of the industry, Jay always communicated with us and was always quick to respond and follow up on any questions, concerns or issues we had. Again cannot express how professional, knowledgeable and courteous Jay was throughout the whole process.

Buyer review
A smooth and positive experience, making the whole process simple, straightforward, and stress-free.
2 months ago
A smooth and positive experience, making the whole process simple, straightforward, and stress-free.

I had a very positive experience with We Buy the House. Communication was clear, friendly, and consistent throughout the process, and they were always willing to answer my questions and explain the next steps. He demonstrated strong market knowledge and gave me a clear understanding of the process and what to expect. I also appreciated their straightforward approach to negotiation—they were fair, transparent, and easy to deal with. Overall, his professionalism really stood out. The process was handled efficiently and respectfully, which made the experience feel simple and stress-free. I would happily recommend We Buy the House to anyone looking for a professional and straightforward property-selling experience

Seller review
Great communication with regular updates.
2 months ago
Great communication with regular updates.

Great knowledge of our area with constant feedback on current sales and expectations. Jay even took my calls whilst he was on holiday with his family.

Seller review
Outstanding service from start to finish!
2 months ago
Outstanding service from start to finish!

Jay is a fantastic communicator with expert knowledge of the local market and pricing. He kept us informed every step of the way and made the whole selling process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend!

Buyer review
Excellent service, great to deal with
3 months ago
Excellent service, great to deal with

Jay is a great guy to deal with, excellent knowledge of the area & local market, he made the whole purchase easy, thanks

Buyer review
Very attentive & extremely helpful
3 months ago
Very attentive & extremely helpful

Jay was very knowledgeable with the current market & the area where I purchased my property. Any questions or concerns I had were followed up promptly & professionally. I was very appreciative of how things were dealt with throughout one of the most stressful times in my life. Jay (and Sandy) went above & beyond with getting my son & I into our own home without adding extra stress for something that they really didn’t have to arrange to have done. I cannot express how much gratitude that I have for Jay.. tears definitely fell on settlement & I was very humbled. The “welcome home” pack was a lovely touch. I definitely recommend this team when buying your property :)

Seller review
Excellent communication
3 months ago
Excellent communication

I recently sold my property with Jay and he far exceeded my expectations. He is honest, knowledgeable and kept me informed every step of the way. nothing was too much trouble. I throughly recommended anyone wishing to buy or sell to go with the best team of all ‘Cleary Fairbrother Property’ thank you Jay and team for an excellent result.

Seller review
Property sale
4 months ago
Property sale

I have had Jay sell my last 2 properties and each time it has been a great experience. Jay is always upfront, does what he says he will do and always exceeds my expectations. I strongly recommend anyone looking to sell their house in the Bathurst region consider Jay Cleary. There are plenty of agents out there but if you want results go with the best and you won't be disappointed.

Seller review
  Proessionalism of the highest standard
4 months ago
Proessionalism of the highest standard

We would like to thank Jay for the sale of our property, from the listing, his market knowledge, his communication with us ,keeping us informed of inspection,s and what prospective purchasers comments of the property were , Through to a successful sale

Seller review
Jay was always easy to work with & I am very pleased with the results achieved..
4 months ago
Jay was always easy to work with & I am very pleased with the results achieved..

Every step of the way Jay was very professional & knowledgeable and was always calm and reassuring in what can often be an extremely stressful process. I can highly recommend Jay to any potential vendors or purchasers.His advice was always sound and he acted with integrity at all times.My sincere thanks to Jay and the entire team at Cleary Fairbrother,

13 - 24 of 589
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent