Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great Salesman
about 2 months ago
Great Salesman

Excellent to deal with definitely knows the housing market and excellent bargaining skills Highly recommend

Seller review
Highly experienced, great market knowledge
about 2 months ago
Highly experienced, great market knowledge

Jay was able to help us while selling our property, the transaction wasn’t straight forward, hence Jays experience was really valuable to help guide us through. We would highly recommend Jay as a trusted advisor when selling your property.

Buyer review
Great experience
about 2 months ago
Great experience

As a first home buyer the experience was great and couldn’t have been better the way jay helped me and communicated with me was fantastic. He told me everything I need to know and I 100% will be looking forward to working with him in the future

Seller review
Authenticity, Professionalism, and Skill!
2 months ago
Authenticity, Professionalism, and Skill!

Jay, Sandy, and Kathleen are an exceptional real estate team and wonderful people to work with and know. They patiently and skilfully guided us through the preparation and sale of our home. The first time I met Jay, he made me feel I was not just a client. He related to me as a human being, which is an exceedingly rare experience. Jay combines this authenticity with his highly professional approach and his deep experience and knowledge of the Bathurst real estate market. Every time I met with him since that first meeting, I went away feeling uplifted and more confident. Once our house was listed, the entire Cleary Fairbrother team worked tirelessly on our behalf and we received three excellent offers within the first four days of listing. We are grateful to Sandy, Jay, and Kathleen for all they have done and recommend them to any prospective vendor looking for the perfect combination of professionalism, honesty, skill, and experience.

Seller review
Excellent communication
2 months ago
Excellent communication

I had a great experience working with Jay during the sale of my property. He was professional from start to finish and made what can be a stressful time feel very manageable. I particularly appreciated being constantly kept in the loop; his communication was excellent, and he made the entire process incredibly easy to deal with. Highly recommended!

Seller review
Supported with kindness, warmth and professionalism as we navigated a new stage of life
2 months ago
Supported with kindness, warmth and professionalism as we navigated a new stage of life

Jay and the team at Cleary Fairbrother Property Bathurst went above and beyond to help us sell our home. Jay made the whole experience feel personal and supported as we prepared for the next stage of our lives, and the meaning of selling our home in the context of our own future. His kindness and warmth through the whole experience made something that could have been stressful an easy and exciting venture. We are so, so thankful for Jay’s attention to detail, advice and support through every step of the process. The communication was above and beyond, and we were informed and updated at every stage as we progressed through the sale. Thank you so much for everything.

Buyer review
Working with Jay was a piece of cake
2 months ago
Working with Jay was a piece of cake

Jay is extremely helpful, honest and the best there is. He will go out of his way to help you if you are buying or selling. He’s one of the good ones! Couldn’t have asked for a better Estate Agent.

Buyer review
Super accessible & upfront
3 months ago
Super accessible & upfront

Jay was extremely helpful when it came to the process of buying our first home. He was very clear & upfront with us about expectations. He made himself super accessible for any questions we had. I would recommend Jay to anyone & will be definitely working with him again in the future

Seller review
Fast Sale, Strong Price, Outstanding Service
3 months ago
Fast Sale, Strong Price, Outstanding Service

We couldn’t be happier with the result Jay achieved for us. He truly exceeded our expectations in every way. From the outset, Jay was professional, proactive, and extremely knowledgeable about the market. His strategy was clear and well thought out, and the outcome speaks for itself — a strong sale price and a fast sale. He kept us informed throughout the entire process and made what could have been a stressful time feel calm and well managed. We are incredibly grateful for his hard work and dedication and would highly recommend him to anyone considering selling their home. Thank you again, Jay, for delivering such a fantastic result for our family.

Seller review
Upfront and Honest, Genuine and Reliable
4 months ago
Upfront and Honest, Genuine and Reliable

Jay is always upfront and honest. Genuine and reliable. On the ball and helpful with everything real estate. Including conveyancing when required. You always know where you stand with Jay. I can't recommend Clearly Fairbrother Real Estate highly enough. These guys really know their stuff and this time due to their networking they sold our house prior to entering the market. A dream sale. Thank you ance again Cleary Fairbrother Real Estate.

13 - 24 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent