Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 543 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Thank you
9 months ago
Thank you

During the difficult time needing to sell the family home of 57 years to facilitate Mum’s progression to her next stage of life in aged care, Jay and his team have been both compassionate and professional exceeding all of our expectations. Jay was able to market and sell our property in an extremely timely manner at a price that was very acceptable. The whole process was painless with Jay keeping us updated at every stage. We would encourage anyone looking to buy or sell to give Jay and his team serious consideration as they won’t be disappointed, Thank you Jay

Seller review
Respectful and responsive.
10 months ago
Respectful and responsive.

Jay was an excellent communicator, relaying buyer feedback and ensuring we were kept informed at all stages of the sale. Jay was respectful and responsive with all our questions. Thank you for your help Jay.

Buyer review
Absolutely amazing!!!
10 months ago
Absolutely amazing!!!

Jay has been nothing short of amazing from the minute we made the first phone call right to the very end! Jay has kept in contact every step of the way from market reports every week, a phone call straight after every open home or just a catch up phone call to let you know what has been happening in the background. Jay has been extremely transparent and has a wonderful no beating around the bush attitude which is what you want in an agent! I cannot recommend Clearly Fairbrother Real Estate any more highly!

Seller review
Outstanding Service
10 months ago
Outstanding Service

We recently engaged Cleary and Fairbrother Real Estate to sell our home. Jay Cleary was the principal agent in contact with us. Jay made an outstanding effort in all aspects of our sale. He communicated well with us throughout the process and his approach was thorough, sincere and honest. Jay was easy to approach and he worked very hard to secure the sale of our home. We were very happy with his service and the outcome. We highly recommend Jay to anyone seeking an efficient, trustworthy and friendly agent, who gets the job done well, in selling or buying a home. This guy is great.

Buyer review
Exceptionally professional and an absolute pleasure to work with!
10 months ago
Exceptionally professional and an absolute pleasure to work with!

Jay was excellent to work with! Jay has fantastic knowledge about the local area and answered all our questions in a timely manner. His communication is second to none; we never had any difficulty reaching Jay when we needed to discuss our property or schedule an inspection. He is exceptionally professional and an absolute pleasure to work with. We couldn't recommend Jay highly enough!

Buyer review
Great! Communication
10 months ago
Great! Communication

We found working with Jay to purchase our property a extremely smooth process. Jay was professional, and made the communication between ourselves and the vendor easy during the process of purchasing.

Buyer review
Property purchase made easy!
10 months ago
Property purchase made easy!

Jay was super helpful with our property search and purchase. He was able to give valuable insight into the market and kept us up to date with potential opportunities that fit our preferences. He was knowledgeable and realistic about property details, and readily available to answer any questions we had. Jay made the search for our new home effortless, and we would recommend him to anybody looking to buy or sell their home.

Seller review
Communicator Extraordinaire
10 months ago
Communicator Extraordinaire

Jay is a brilliant agent, always on point, and goes the extra mile to make sure we were always given up to the minute updates regarding our sale. His persistence, attentiveness to inquiries and down to earth honest nature is an absolute asset. Thank you Jay - you’re absolutely brilliant and we appreciate your open and frequent communication every step of the way.

Buyer review
Very informative
10 months ago
Very informative

Jay was a pleasure to deal with throughout the entire purchase process. Jay constantly impressed by following up after the initial inspection right through to final inspection. A great communicator which made the purchase a great experience.

Seller review
WOW!!! 3 days on the market!!!
10 months ago
WOW!!! 3 days on the market!!!

Great marketing and very focused property positioning. Extremely clear communication and understanding of our expectations. Professionalism at its highest clearly delivered the results we were hoping for. We could not recommend Jay and Sandy and the team any higher. You will not be disappointed in any way at all if you choose Cleary Fairbrother. We are smiling ear to ear with this experience. Thank you very much!!!

Seller review
Stress free
10 months ago
Stress free

Working with Jay Cleary was a fantastic experience. His deep knowledge of the market helped us make smart decisions, and his communication was always clear, timely, and professional. Jay guided us through every step with confidence and care, making the entire process smooth and stress-free. If you're looking for a trustworthy and knowledgeable real estate agent, Jay is the one to call!

Seller review
Honest & Realistic
11 months ago
Honest & Realistic

Jay provided honest and realistic advice even before we went to market which absolutely resulted in our property selling so quick. He was always available to answer any questions we had and made the entire process seamless.

37 - 48 of 543
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent